User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Field Goal Range (leave blank for "auto"):--Bug
Page:
 
czman
offline
Link
 
I leave this blank and seem to have random problems with kicking FGs. We did not attempt any in the first quarter. After that we were fine. We also had a problem in our first scrimmage game where we did not kick in the second quarter. I know Bort typed something about the distance getting miscalculated sometimes for FGs. Can this please be looked at because at some point it may make a difference. Thanks in advance.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
If I have something wrong can an admin take a look at either send me a PM or post why this is happening.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Bort said he is looking into it here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=757575
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
What I want to know is what exactly the FG range refers to. I get conflicting responses every time.

Implied here that it's the length of the FG, not the yard line.
Originally posted by Bort
Things to watch out for, that I've noticed people do: 2 inputs that are mutually exclusive, where there is a gap in the middle.

For instance:

input 1: Outside FG range, between own goal and opponent 35: Punt
input 2: Inside FG range, between opponent 35 and opponent goal: Kick FG

If you're on the opponent 38 and your FG range is for the 40 yard line, neither of these will trigger.

Input 1 won't fire because you're not outside FG range.
Input 2 won't fire because you're not between the 35 and opponent goal

So it goes on to the next thing which is probably a pass or something and you go for it.


Yet, it looks like here that it's the yard line.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Kakseca

Originally posted by Bort


Did you have the FG range set manually, or choose automatically? Remember that FG range is +17 yards beyond where the ball is spotted.


So, if I want our Kicker to go as far as only kicking 50yd FG's max. I would set the my number to 33?


Yes, that would do it.


Which is it? I set mine to 30 last game, and it punted from the 13 yard line even when the FG input in the AI was above the Punt input and it was the 1st quarter with no overrides. Very frustrating.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cabrasher
What I want to know is what exactly the FG range refers to. I get conflicting responses every time.

Implied here that it's the length of the FG, not the yard line.
Originally posted by Bort

Things to watch out for, that I've noticed people do: 2 inputs that are mutually exclusive, where there is a gap in the middle.

For instance:

input 1: Outside FG range, between own goal and opponent 35: Punt
input 2: Inside FG range, between opponent 35 and opponent goal: Kick FG

If you're on the opponent 38 and your FG range is for the 40 yard line, neither of these will trigger.

Input 1 won't fire because you're not outside FG range.
Input 2 won't fire because you're not between the 35 and opponent goal

So it goes on to the next thing which is probably a pass or something and you go for it.


Yet, it looks like here that it's the yard line.
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Kakseca


Originally posted by Bort



Did you have the FG range set manually, or choose automatically? Remember that FG range is +17 yards beyond where the ball is spotted.


So, if I want our Kicker to go as far as only kicking 50yd FG's max. I would set the my number to 33?


Yes, that would do it.


Which is it? I set mine to 30 last game, and it punted from the 13 yard line even when the FG input in the AI was above the Punt input and it was the 1st quarter with no overrides. Very frustrating.


What was your FG range set to?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok I think I might have found a problem - Auto kicking range was subtracting 17 yards from the "allowed distance" when I'm pretty sure isn't right. Ranges looked really short when I had it output what it was using, like in the 20-25 yd range. I didn't knock kicking back THAT much. I took that - 51 ft out so maybe that will help.
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
FG range was set to 30, but it was actually the 12.5 yd line that he punted from, so that should have even been within the range of 30 no matter the method you would use here. The FG input was setup before the Punt input in my AI, so either the AI is not checking through in the proper order or something's wrong with the FG range calculation.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cabrasher
FG range was set to 30, but it was actually the 12.5 yd line that he punted from, so that should have even been within the range of 30 no matter the method you would use here. The FG input was setup before the Punt input in my AI, so either the AI is not checking through in the proper order or something's wrong with the FG range calculation.


It's - 17 yards. Maybe some sort of rounding problem (12.5 is close to 13)? I'll check it out.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by cabrasher

FG range was set to 30, but it was actually the 12.5 yd line that he punted from, so that should have even been within the range of 30 no matter the method you would use here. The FG input was setup before the Punt input in my AI, so either the AI is not checking through in the proper order or something's wrong with the FG range calculation.


It's - 17 yards. Maybe some sort of rounding problem (12.5 is close to 13)? I'll check it out.


Can we also get an official post (by an admin) that states how the FG distance needs to bet. We should not have to test this. Is it from the spot of the ball or the kick and does it take into account the ten yards for the end zone. If something official has been posted I am sorry I missed it but can it be linked here, please.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by cabrasher


FG range was set to 30, but it was actually the 12.5 yd line that he punted from, so that should have even been within the range of 30 no matter the method you would use here. The FG input was setup before the Punt input in my AI, so either the AI is not checking through in the proper order or something's wrong with the FG range calculation.


It's - 17 yards. Maybe some sort of rounding problem (12.5 is close to 13)? I'll check it out.


Can we also get an official post (by an admin) that states how the FG distance needs to bet. We should not have to test this. Is it from the spot of the ball or the kick and does it take into account the ten yards for the end zone. If something official has been posted I am sorry I missed it but can it be linked here, please.


I should just put it on the tactics page to avoid confusion. It's from the spot of the kick.
 
jazzedpap1028
offline
Link
 
Agreed
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by czman

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by cabrasher



FG range was set to 30, but it was actually the 12.5 yd line that he punted from, so that should have even been within the range of 30 no matter the method you would use here. The FG input was setup before the Punt input in my AI, so either the AI is not checking through in the proper order or something's wrong with the FG range calculation.


It's - 17 yards. Maybe some sort of rounding problem (12.5 is close to 13)? I'll check it out.


Can we also get an official post (by an admin) that states how the FG distance needs to bet. We should not have to test this. Is it from the spot of the ball or the kick and does it take into account the ten yards for the end zone. If something official has been posted I am sorry I missed it but can it be linked here, please.


I should just put it on the tactics page to avoid confusion. It's from the spot of the kick.


Ok, this to me is contradictory to what is said above. Above you say my input of 30 would mean a 30-yd FG, or from the 13 yd line. The last response says it's from the spot of the kick? I'm more confused now than before.

Let me just ask it straight up so there's no confusion from here out. If I want my kicker's FG range to be 47 yds, in other words from the 30-yd line, should I put 30 or 47 in the FG range input?
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 10:21:10
 
Kakseca
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by czman

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by cabrasher



FG range was set to 30, but it was actually the 12.5 yd line that he punted from, so that should have even been within the range of 30 no matter the method you would use here. The FG input was setup before the Punt input in my AI, so either the AI is not checking through in the proper order or something's wrong with the FG range calculation.


It's - 17 yards. Maybe some sort of rounding problem (12.5 is close to 13)? I'll check it out.


Can we also get an official post (by an admin) that states how the FG distance needs to bet. We should not have to test this. Is it from the spot of the ball or the kick and does it take into account the ten yards for the end zone. If something official has been posted I am sorry I missed it but can it be linked here, please.


I should just put it on the tactics page to avoid confusion. It's from the spot of the kick.


Eh? So now on "Field Goal Range, from the spot of the kick (leave blank for "auto"): 50 yds". For my kicker to only attempt 50yd FG's? I thought you just said 33yds to attempt a 50yds FG?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kakseca
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by czman


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by cabrasher




FG range was set to 30, but it was actually the 12.5 yd line that he punted from, so that should have even been within the range of 30 no matter the method you would use here. The FG input was setup before the Punt input in my AI, so either the AI is not checking through in the proper order or something's wrong with the FG range calculation.


It's - 17 yards. Maybe some sort of rounding problem (12.5 is close to 13)? I'll check it out.


Can we also get an official post (by an admin) that states how the FG distance needs to bet. We should not have to test this. Is it from the spot of the ball or the kick and does it take into account the ten yards for the end zone. If something official has been posted I am sorry I missed it but can it be linked here, please.


I should just put it on the tactics page to avoid confusion. It's from the spot of the kick.


Eh? So now on "Field Goal Range, from the spot of the kick (leave blank for "auto"): 50 yds". For my kicker to only attempt 50yd FG's? I thought you just said 33yds to attempt a 50yds FG?


I might have misunderstood or misread, etc. Been kinda tired lately.

It's from the spot of the kick. The LOS for that will be whatever your put - 17 yards.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 10:27:14
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cabrasher
Let me just ask it straight up so there's no confusion from here out. If I want my kicker's FG range to be 47 yds, in other words from the 30-yd line, should I put 30 or 47 in the FG range input?


Put in 47. If you put in 30, he will kick from the 13.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.