User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
epicness
offline
Link
 
Is this a bug?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78374&pbp_id=740535

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=82658&pbp_id=682857

Seems.. pretty.. out there...
 
slipknottin
offline
Link
 
first one looked like a cover 4 with the #3 and #4 CBs in man coverage. The slot recievers ran deep forcing both there own CB and the zone CBs deep with them leaving the underneath reciever wide open.

Similar situation on the second one. Thats the reason that zone coverage still isnt overly effective in this game. In that play someone should have been assigned to cover the flats, wether its a LB or saftey.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 23:05:34
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
This can't be a vision problem. Our team has stressed high vision from the start so i know all of those cornerbacks have good numbers in that area.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slipknottin
first one looked like a cover 3 with the #3 and #4 CBs in man coverage. The slot recievers ran deep forcing both there own CB and the zone CBs deep with them leaving the underneath reciever wide open.

Similar situation on the second one. Thats the reason that zone coverage still isnt overly effective in this game. In that play someone should have been assigned to cover the flats, wether its a LB or saftey.


That is clearly not zone though...i mean look at how the CBs hug the WRs. It's obviously m2m.
 
slipknottin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow


That is clearly not zone though...i mean look at how the CBs hug the WRs. It's obviously m2m.


You shouldnt be able to tell if its zone or man based on how close the CBs are playing, it can be identical (which it often is in real life) aggressive zone players look just like they are playing man.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
I'm not buying that argument.

If this is what happens in Zone, whats the point of even playing it? We already use an extremely low % of Zone.
 
slipknottin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
I'm not buying that argument.

If this is what happens in Zone, whats the point of even playing it? We already use an extremely low % of Zone.


Im not arguing with you, just telling what I believe happened.

In both of those plays the major problem is that those deep WRs end up getting triple teamed, which would never happen. The saftey on the side where there is a double team should be coming down immediately when he sees that WR sitting at the line. If he comes down into the flat that turns into a 2-3 yard gain instead of a 10-15 yard one.

Im not saying its not a bug, I just believe the reasons for it happening are different.
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
Your safeties look like zone...
Interesting on the corners though.
Question, did the personal settings on the cb's conflict (one to play aggressive man, the other play off man)? Both cases one corner looks set to play close, the other looks to play off 5 yds. It seemed to cross up whom was covering who.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
I get what you're saying, but i've heard so many of these explanations by now, that i'm tired of how illogical they are.

That's not a knock at you, because what you're saying makes perfect sense. It just doesn't make sense that it actually happens in the game.
 
slipknottin
offline
Link
 
Just to restate my argument. This is the problem when a cover 4 player is essentially told that his responsibility is just to not let anyone beat him deep.
Same as a prevent defense allows tons of completions underneath. Hence why defensive coordinators who use a prevent usually dont last long in the NFL. The cover 4 in this game should actually be far more complicated based on what players do what.

I would imagine the code to write something like that is actually fairly complicated, hence it doesnt exist. Even Madden has yet to get zone play correct. You can utilize the same glitches in madden. Especially on hitchs and posts.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 23:21:22
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rivergato
Your safeties look like zone...
Interesting on the corners though.
Question, did the personal settings on the cb's conflict (one to play aggressive man, the other play off man)? Both cases one corner looks set to play close, the other looks to play off 5 yds. It seemed to cross up whom was covering who.


I am almost 100% certain all of our Corners were on "Stick like glue" at the time.

As for the Safeties playing zone, usually they should be playing some type of zone, especially if there are enough CBs to cover all the Receivers on the field. In that case (which is what you see in these plays), the Safeties should be playing over the top, which they are.

The problem is, right off the snap, the Cornerback covering the left side Wide Receiver, just behaves like he doesnt even recognize that there is a WR in that spot. He basically ignores the obvious coverage there and plays a medium, over the top zone on the Slot WR, who is already double covered. It doesnt make much sense.
 
slipknottin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
It doesnt make much sense.


It does make sense, but it shouldnt happen. There are a couple options here on how to deal with this.

The saftey playing that deep zone should realize that the two CBs are covering that reciever, so the saftey should come down into the flat. Youll see this occasionally in the NFL, youll see two CBs covering a WR deep and say.. hmm where the heck is the saftey? Another idea. It could be a cover 4 based on which WR goes deep, if the slot reciever goes deep then the CB matched against him can become that deep cover 4 cb, while the outside CB can play man against his reciever- essentially swapping out there roles. Another possibility, when the HB stayed in to block the LB covering him could slide over to the flat instead of running around the middle of the field where there were no recievers.

I think the main issue is just that zone defense is too watered down at this point, its far far more complex in real life for exactly this reason
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 23:25:57
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
I think we're actually agreeing here, lol. I'm totally with you, the real life application makes perfect sense. What doesnt make sense is how the sim is handling it.

We're basically saying the same thing but the wording is confusing us
 
epicness
offline
Link
 
So, Any official announcement on this?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by epicness
So, Any official announcement on this?


I've adjusted the zones on the outside CB's who are supposed to cover underneath - they were not shallow enough. That should help.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.