User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Keeping the game competitive
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
1. Limit XP to 40 plays per game. I didn't pick this number out of thin air. After looking at several game logs, 40 is a number many starters at certain positions never make it to in games, but almost all starters get at least 35. I've listed reasons why this is good in other threads, so I'm not going to rehash. See below

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=73300&page=last#459636

2. In season 5 and 6 limit players to two level bumps per season. In season 7 and 8 limit players to one level bump per season but make it cost double. From season 9 ^ no level bumps are allowed, and players have to pay player starting FP to keep skills from declining. As long as FP are paid, skills don't decline until after season 12 instead of 10. In season 11 and 12 you have to pay 2X as much FP to keep from losing skills.

A. Once we get to 8th, 9th, 10th season, players should already be built up. At that point, it should be a matter of seeing what the player can do with their skills. NFL players don't keep getting better.

B. You don't want all your top players and even all competitive players to be in the last year of their career. 7th and 8th season players should be capable backups and some well built and well managed players should even be able to crack the starting lineup. This should prevent signing completely new teams or 3/4 of a team after season 10. A 7th season player won't be as competitive if he is 9 bumps behind a 10th season player.

C. Once you get to the 8th season of a player, you have a commitment to the game. You've had your free play especially if you didn't bump. At this point you should be in the pros. To compete in the Pros once everything is established should no longer be free. 100 - 300 FP per season is not an unjust amount. Especially if you get 70% back when player retires. Plus this makes up for revenue lost in no more bumping.

3. Make no bump leagues and farm leagues that are cheaper than the top leagues. These leagues can never be competitive with the top teams and would be less attractive as an owner. However, there is a need for them as new players enter, and it at least gives owners of the teams a chance at full enjoyment of the game. Maybe 800 FP for first 2 seasons, and 300 FP per season after that. You could even go with 3 levels. 1000 per 2 seasons, 800 per 2 seasons, 600 per 2 seasons. The lower levels get less options and advanced tactics for play calling.

A. These leagues would not only have a salary cap, but a player level cap. Once players got to say level 7, they would have until the end of that season if reached before 1/2 point or until end of next season if after 1/2 way point to auction the player off to higher level teams.

B. Players who don't get successfully auctioned will be entered into a draft for the next level. There will be 3 rounds of draft. Any player not drafted goes into free agency or retires.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 14:19:22
 
Graythreat
offline
Link
 
Don't like these ideas at all.....

#1. Player Lvl caps are a bad idea. How will teams ever be able to "climb the ladder" when they can't have high lvl players on their team? At some point, there will be an "invisible" system in place where players naturally gravitate to better teams, but if a high lvl player wants to play with his friends, he should be able to. I personally play with friend and family....for us it's about the team, not the individual, and have no desire to play elsewhere. Capping us would force us to break up eventually and thus lose a lot of the fun of the game.

#2 if exp. stops at 40 plays, then what is the point of jacking up your stamina for more lay time?

 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Gary #!

You will have to move up when your team gets to a certain point. I think that this will be addressed. You wont be able to grow anymore. You will either A) Stay at the same level, and then when ur team is ready move up. Or B Forgo your team commitments, and move up the ladder yourself.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by
#2 if exp. stops at 40 plays, then what is the point of jacking up your stamina for more lay time?


Be more popular with the ladies?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Graythreat
Don't like these ideas at all.....

#1. Player Lvl caps are a bad idea. How will teams ever be able to "climb the ladder" when they can't have high lvl players on their team? At some point, there will be an "invisible" system in place where players naturally gravitate to better teams, but if a high lvl player wants to play with his friends, he should be able to. I personally play with friend and family....for us it's about the team, not the individual, and have no desire to play elsewhere. Capping us would force us to break up eventually and thus lose a lot of the fun of the game.


The farm leagues wouldn't be the bulk of the league. They would be the leagues for letting new players build up. As more and more people enter this game, it's going to be harder and harder for new players to get on teams where they get playing time. Plus, these teams shouldn't be able to move up or have all the game options of other teams because they will be paying less for ownership.

Originally posted by

#2 if exp. stops at 40 plays, then what is the point of jacking up your stamina for more lay time?


You may need your starters more than 40 plays a game to win. You don't have to pull starters after 40 plays, they just stop getting XP past that point. It encourages owners to play the players on their depth chart. This game won't be nearly as successful if 50-70% of players who don't own teams are run off because they don't see their players developing. Non owner players can expect to see more playing time. Plus stamina effects your player as you lose energy, not just prevent you from losing it. Stamina should have an effect at play 10, 15, 20 as well as play 45, 50.



 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Take for example the USA league. There are 8 leagues that are full price leagues.

Now say below those leagues you have 2 farm leagues. 1 of the farm leagues (A) has 32 teams and allows bumped players. Players don't have to be bumped but they can be. These players can go to level 12 then they have to be released according to guidelines above. The other farm league B has 16 teams and doesn't allow bumped players. Level 7 should be as high as they can go before they have to be released after 1 full season, but they can still be auctioned off to farm league A.

Farm teams can never move up or down and their rosters will be changing regularly as they sell players up the chain.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Oh yeah,

For next season

The 1 level 15 player can not bump in season 2.
The 17 level 14 players can only bump 1 level in season 2.
The 51 level 13 players can only bump 2 levels in season 2.
 
fightfreak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by

#2 if exp. stops at 40 plays, then what is the point of jacking up your stamina for more lay time?


Be more popular with the ladies?


LMAO, beat me to it...
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Oh yeah,

For next season

The 1 level 15 player can not bump in season 2.
The 17 level 14 players can only bump 1 level in season 2.
The 51 level 13 players can only bump 2 levels in season 2.


Well that doesn't make alot of sense really.


And 40 plays?? are you kidding?? I have starters getting 60-70 some games. If you want a lower cap i'll listen. I think drop the "top edge" from 90 plays to 75-80 plays. Most games you dont run more than 80 plays. I dont see the harm in making the huge drop off 80 plays. But 40?? sorry i can't support that one.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Look at these games

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=5373

In this game, one team only had 38 offensive plays.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=5359

In this game, one team only had 54 offensive plays.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=242

One team had 59 offensive plays

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=11

Neither team had 70 offensive plays.



Now if you look at all those, you can find several starters in each game that didn't reach 40 plays.

If you want a formula, then you take the average number of plays per game. Divide that in 1/2 for offense defense. Then multiply that number by 66%. If there are 120 plays a game on average, then 60 plays on each side of ball. 2/3 of 60 is 40.

Starters get XP for 2/3 of the average number of plays on one side of the ball. After that, they stay in to win games, but don't get more XP.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Well im sure i can find games to back my point up as well. Also did you add in all of the kickoffs and punts?? That usually adds another 15 or so plays as well.

The minnesota Mauraders typically run about 80 plays a game on offense. So to limit the OT i have on that team to 40 you're saying only half his plays should count.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 16:18:22
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Well im sure i can find games to back my point up as well. Also did you add in all of the kickoffs and punts?? That usually adds another 15 or so plays as well.

The minnesota Mauraders typically run about 80 plays a game on offense. So to limit the OT i have on that team to 40 you're saying only half his plays should count.


How many plays is your defense on the field? Should someone with a crappy defense that's on the field more get more xp for their defensive players than teams that do well on defense.

Should a team that runs a ball control offense and reduces the number of plays in a game be punished for running that style of offense?

Plus, if you run 80 plays per game on offense, you should have to have a backup in there some of those plays rather than having 1 OT in for 80 plays, he should be in 60 max.

The Mauraders are one of the 7 teams with more than 3 level 13 or higher players. There are only 10 with more than 1. Play your backups.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
OL dont come out of games in real life either though. Also i think all of those guys over 13 are fully boosted as well.

But your estimate of only 120 plays for a game is a little low i believe. 140-150 might be a better average from what ive seen.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
I still don't get why my team is being punished for being a lockdown D. It's impossible for them all to get 80+ plays when they're only on the field for 50 something. That kind of bonus for arbitrary numbers hurts my team.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
I still don't get why my team is being punished for being a lockdown D. It's impossible for them all to get 80+ plays when they're only on the field for 50 something. That kind of bonus for arbitrary numbers hurts my team.


Score faster maybe??

This was discussed in alpha...and you're going to get exp for playing on the field. You wont get a "bonus" for being better!!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.