Actually this is one of the few ideas that is really good. The only issue is .. how do you register the person on defense in order to give a modifier to the XP.
For example, take the USA Pro league where lots of people play both ways and they have like 25 people on a roster or something. What happens when your #3 CB is also your #1 WR, does he get an XP boost based on the snaps he played on defense? That would add a lot of math and snap tracking to the system that presently doesnt exist and would probably be a big headache.
I understand the issue, my offense can get from 10-30 snaps a game more than my defense depending on the quality and gameplan of the opponent, this stunts defensive player growth unless you get them extra snaps on offense like some "max/min" people do because they are gaming the system, but there are enough threads ranting about that.
Also you want performance based XP, that is NOT a good idea, but a general modifier of 10% or so on players who are naturally defensive players MIGHT be good, but not with the present system where players can play anywhere, because then certain people (we all know who they are) who like to game the system would use this to their advantage and exploit it.