User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP For Defense: Bad D=Good XP
Page:
 
luckystrike
offline
Link
 
The current system rewards players for the number of plays they are on the field for. If a defense holds a team to 3 and out all game long. They are not getting as much XP as a defense that gets run all over and never stops a third down conversion.

This is not good.
There needs to be some performance based XP.
 
Link
 
Score faster? lol. I agree though.
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Actually this is one of the few ideas that is really good. The only issue is .. how do you register the person on defense in order to give a modifier to the XP.

For example, take the USA Pro league where lots of people play both ways and they have like 25 people on a roster or something. What happens when your #3 CB is also your #1 WR, does he get an XP boost based on the snaps he played on defense? That would add a lot of math and snap tracking to the system that presently doesnt exist and would probably be a big headache.

I understand the issue, my offense can get from 10-30 snaps a game more than my defense depending on the quality and gameplan of the opponent, this stunts defensive player growth unless you get them extra snaps on offense like some "max/min" people do because they are gaming the system, but there are enough threads ranting about that.

Also you want performance based XP, that is NOT a good idea, but a general modifier of 10% or so on players who are naturally defensive players MIGHT be good, but not with the present system where players can play anywhere, because then certain people (we all know who they are) who like to game the system would use this to their advantage and exploit it.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
I've argued this point before and it doesn't seem to really come to anything. But I completely agree, good defenses get the shaft EXP-wise.
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Well it would be almost impossible to implement without introducing all kinds of exploits and bugs .. I mean ... sure you give defensive players 1.1 modifier for game experience or something .. what determines a defensive player? Would that encourage people to have more defensive players, probably not.

If you had to track snaps between who gets ST, Offense and Defense snaps .. that is even worse. I know that the game tracks TEAM offense and defense snaps, its in the "other" in the league stats .. which I dont quite understand because I think ST plays are covered under offense and defense in that case.

Anyhow point is there is a system, it works and well .. its a little imbalanced exp wise, but I just havent seen a good solution proposed.

I also know that there are XP modifiers out there, I figure that a kicker XP modifer is somewhere around x10 so 6XP/FG would get them 60 snaps .. maybe x5 or x6 considering kickoffs, point is, they have a modifier so it clearly "could" work, just the balancing it so that it wouldnt be exploited or "best utilized within the rules of the game" if we want to use a Tim Harper-ism.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
I've argued this point before and it doesn't seem to really come to anything. But I completely agree, good defenses get the shaft EXP-wise.


I know, and that makes me sad. I intentionally have a stone wall defense where they can't have extended drives. Most of the TDs I give up are broken tackle 60+ yarders that happen against any pressure squad. So, by not giving up yards, my D actually gets less XP...even though they do more then the defense out there for 100 plays. It baffles me how bort/dd have it programmed right now. I refuse to change it just because my players can level faster. I want a bonus for having the leagues best defense (which I did, over the last five weeks or so), not a punishment.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by luckystrike
This is not good.
There needs to be some performance based XP.


Agreed: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=63851&page=4
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
I think you give defensive players an xp boost. If someone is playing both ways they dont get the defensive boost.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
If you gave natural defensive players a 10% modifier, and put a check in where the bonus was only given on defensive plays (if that's possible), it would be a fair solution.

Or, they could address the depth issue at the same time by heavily increasing the exp given from the first 30-40 plays and sharply lowering the exp given after that.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
So does the bonus XP awarded come out of the offenses's XP?
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
If you gave natural defensive players a 10% modifier, and put a check in where the bonus was only given on defensive plays (if that's possible), it would be a fair solution.

Or, they could address the depth issue at the same time by heavily increasing the exp given from the first 30-40 plays and sharply lowering the exp given after that.


Someone with a solution!
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Also, I think that Offensive players/defensive players playing the opposite side of the ball should have all abilities dramatically cut when playing on the opposite side. Also they should not get more XP, than a normal player would. They also should Have EXTREME fatigue.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
Also, I think that Offensive players/defensive players playing the opposite side of the ball should have all abilities dramatically cut when playing on the opposite side. Also they should not get more XP, than a normal player would. They also should Have EXTREME fatigue.


I believe this is coded in already. There is a significant attribute loss when playing in a non natural position for your player.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
How do they get away with a Pro team playing both ways. I would think that would KILL your chances against a team that didn't do that. I just don't think it's as strong as it needs to be.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
How do they get away with a Pro team playing both ways. I would think that would KILL your chances against a team that didn't do that. I just don't think it's as strong as it needs to be.


I don't know about others, but in my case, it's really people far down on the depth chart. Like I have my K/PR in as WR5. Is it a penalty? Sure. But what are the other options? I need a 5th WR for some plays, I don't want to use a CPU (which would be even worse) and I can't bring on a human player just for that position or they won't level.

It's not like my WR1 is also my CB2 or anything like that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.