User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Does GLB almost necessitate farm teams (discussion)?
Page:
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
This is actually not a pro farm team argument, but rather a problem I see in GLB itself.

Basically in order for your player to develop he has to play. The best teams have starters that play 80% of the time and backups that play 20% of the time. Consider also that effect of practice on player development compared to actually playing in games is miniscule.

Not to get too Marxist on you, but GLB is set up such that success can only be sustained by exploiting a large group of players. These are the "backups" who you need, but who will probably never be starters. They join GLB and in many cases pay money to boost, but of course there is a catch-22 which is unavoidable: you must start to improve; you must improve to start.

Frankly this is one reason why farm teams get created in the first place (none of my teams are farm teams so don't go there please). I feel that developmental teams are not the problem, but are symptomatic of a greater, fundamental problem with the way GLB is set up which I have enumerated above.

Possible solutions, perhaps backup levels of training. You get say 100-150 XP per day (compared to 600-900 every other day for starters), but there is a cap on the amount of in-game XP you can get. For example, if you select this training option you would get say 100 XP per day, but the most you could get in your game is 200 regardless of how many plays you play. This would allow perennial backups to get 300-400 XP every other day and give them a legitimate shot to one day be starters It would also prevent abuse from people who would train as a backup and put a "starter" with low stamina ahead of themselves and collect the big backup XP plus the big game XP (believe me it would happen). The numbers can be tinkered with of course.

I would be curious to see what others think about the fundamental "problem" with the system that I see which leads to a need for developmental teams, and I would also be curious to hear alternate suggestions along the lines of what I have proposed to give the "backup" a fairer shot at starting someday.

Please don't just say "No one can have more than one team." If you feel this way, fine, but even if everyone had only one team the problem I listed above would still exist.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Alternate leagues with level caps would be a solution to that issue without the need for farm teams. Personally, I am in favor of a farm system, but I'm just saying there's more than one way to look at this.
 
remaxjon
offline
Link
 
The problem is you are wrong. There is no need for farm teams for players to gain xp. Players may be back ups to start but after a year they will be able to sign on with a new team and start. If you think there arn't going to be a ton of new teams every year I don't know what to tell you. People are begging for teams who do you think is going to fill those positions. I know I have a couple players on my team who were backups that have asked to be traded or released to a team where they can start. As soon as the new teams arrive that won't be a problem..
 
CaliGaucho
offline
Link
 
That's a great idea IMO. At least from my perspective, I'd love to stay on my current team, but I'm probably going to leave because of the exact reason you state here. I can never pass the starters. Eventually, aging will have an impact, and you will back up the aging veteran until they slip enough where you can surpass them. Aging and a salary cap will give you a more diverse line up and give the back up a light at the end of the tunnel. Right now, with the new teams coming in to play, a good deal of the back ups on current teams will leave for a starting job on a new team.
 
vcolev
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
This is actually not a pro farm team argument, but rather a problem I see in GLB itself.

Basically in order for your player to develop he has to play. The best teams have starters that play 80% of the time and backups that play 20% of the time. Consider also that effect of practice on player development compared to actually playing in games is miniscule.

Not to get too Marxist on you, but GLB is set up such that success can only be sustained by exploiting a large group of players. These are the "backups" who you need, but who will probably never be starters. They join GLB and in many cases pay money to boost, but of course there is a catch-22 which is unavoidable: you must start to improve; you must improve to start.

Frankly this is one reason why farm teams get created in the first place (none of my teams are farm teams so don't go there please). I feel that developmental teams are not the problem, but are symptomatic of a greater, fundamental problem with the way GLB is set up which I have enumerated above.

Possible solutions, perhaps backup levels of training. You get say 100-150 XP per day (compared to 600-900 every other day for starters), but there is a cap on the amount of in-game XP you can get. For example, if you select this training option you would get say 100 XP per day, but the most you could get in your game is 200 regardless of how many plays you play. This would allow perennial backups to get 300-400 XP every other day and give them a legitimate shot to one day be starters It would also prevent abuse from people who would train as a backup and put a "starter" with low stamina ahead of themselves and collect the big backup XP plus the big game XP (believe me it would happen). The numbers can be tinkered with of course.

I would be curious to see what others think about the fundamental "problem" with the system that I see which leads to a need for developmental teams, and I would also be curious to hear alternate suggestions along the lines of what I have proposed to give the "backup" a fairer shot at starting someday.

Please don't just say "No one can have more than one team." If you feel this way, fine, but even if everyone had only one team the problem I listed above would still exist.


I would have to disagree, I was backup for half my season and got plenty of playing time and have even moved up to starter within the season.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Just to clarify, I understand that players can go to new teams and potentially start. My question to you would be can they make enough teams for every human to start? If not there will be a large number who are backups, and player retirement is 9 seasons (= 1 year away). The problem of a large group of exploited players remains. The fact that people are scrambling to get on any team makes it worse. They are willing to be backups when there is a likelihood they may never start over people who already have such a big head start.
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
You can allow subs to play multiple backup positions + special teams for them to get more experience.
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
Think about it long term. You can just buy players off the smaller teams who need the money, just like professional soccer. We won't need farm teams because everyone will have a thousand to pick from.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Whatever.
The simple fact is that the regular season dictates giving players as much playing time as possible.

However, the best teams actually will have depth.
If the game wasn't set up so that depth was desirable then we wouldn't need farm teams.

The reason the best teams will want farm teams is because you DO want depth. You just don't want it during the regular season because you lose experience for your players.

So... yeah.
If you want to be a great team then the game is set up so that you will get as much experience as possible for both starters and backups. And then the playoffs come and you just want to win.

...that's Farm Teams.
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 20:57:29
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jkocurek
Think about it long term. You can just buy players off the smaller teams who need the money, just like professional soccer. We won't need farm teams because everyone will have a thousand to pick from.


But imagine if you owned 3 teams. The top team is the competitive one, the second and third teams are designed, not to win, but to rotate players in such a way that as many as possible get the most reps, and thus level the fastest (overall). These teams act only as feeders of cash (if two owners aren't the same person) and players up the ladder, while the lower players essentially spend a year or two in limbo gaining XP on what, to them, is the practice field.
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
But if nobody has farm teams then there will be no disadvantage to not having one.
 
Fandom
offline
Link
 
If you're playing some players 80% of the time, you're hurting yourself in the long run.

At the beginning of a game, your players will earn close to 100% of the expected XP from performance. But, as the number of plays climb, that XP is reduced greatly...the reduction seems to come in about 1 percent per play. So, if you've played 50 plays, you'll be getting only about 50% of the expected XP...as the number of plays approaches 100, you're XP gained will be at or near ZERO.

So, If you want your TEAM to advance most quickly, you'll play a lot of players.

This is especially advantageous when you have several players around the same level at the same position. Obviously, it's not the best decision if you have one guy who is 10 levels above everyone else.
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
But imagine if you owned 3 teams. The top team is the competitive one, the second and third teams are designed, not to win, but to rotate players in such a way that as many as possible get the most reps, and thus level the fastest (overall). These teams act only as feeders of cash (if two owners aren't the same person) and players up the ladder, while the lower players essentially spend a year or two in limbo gaining XP on what, to them, is the practice field.


It's the same as any other artificial market bubble, like the farming banks from the 1930s or the subprime lending thing going on now. The only reason this is desirable, right now, is because this is the fastest way to level your players. It's an artificial increase that is unhealthily inflating player levels, while most people do it normally.

If you eliminated multiple teams, or at least swapping players among them, then there is no need to super level your dudes because nobody else is doing it either, meaning the game can persist at a healthy, constant rate, and everyone has fun.

Greedy bankers ruined our economy at least twice now, why let some greedy players do that to us?
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 21:02:20
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fandom
So, If you want your TEAM to advance most quickly, you'll play a lot of players.



Yeah... exactly. And if you're smart then most of your players will play on FARM TEAMS!!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jkocurek
Originally posted by

But imagine if you owned 3 teams. The top team is the competitive one, the second and third teams are designed, not to win, but to rotate players in such a way that as many as possible get the most reps, and thus level the fastest (overall). These teams act only as feeders of cash (if two owners aren't the same person) and players up the ladder, while the lower players essentially spend a year or two in limbo gaining XP on what, to them, is the practice field.


It's the same as any other artificial market bubble, like the farming banks form the 1930s or the subprime lending thing going on now. The only reason this is desirable, right now, is because this is the fastest way to level your players. It's an artificial increase that in unhealthily inflated player levels, while most people do it normally.

If you eliminated multiple teams, or at least swapping players among them, then there is no need to super level your dudes because nobody else is doing it either, meaning the game can persist at a healthy, constant rate, and everyone has fun.


I agree, but there are pretty simple ways of fixing this (the restructuring idea I gave, trade limits, etc) so we'll see what the Devs have to see.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.