User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bump and Run in the sim... is it in, and how good is it?
Page:
 
treygreen13
offline
Link
 
I want to preface these comments by saying that this isn't a complaint about how the Bump and Run coverage works. Obviously from our win, it wasn't a deciding factor in the points scored, but it did bring up an issue I thought might be interesting to discuss in terms of the new AI and the acceleration nerf.

So, after watching my first scrimmage sim, I noticed that what appears to be Bump and Run coverage is being used very effectively. However, it seems to be much too effective against WRs.

My first clue was this play:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79405&pbp_id=284896
Watch Trey Amigos and OH GOD IT BURNS here. They both get hit at the 5 yard mark and are effectively taken out of the play. The TE is wide open, though.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79405&pbp_id=284925
Here it is again. Same drive, same general play. The WRs take 3 steps, get bumped, and then the CBs just stand on top of them until the play ends. Another TE opening.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79405&pbp_id=287024
As you can see, my #1 WR spends most of the game being sat on at the 5 yard mark. He has very high speed and high agility, but there's no way to get off the line. The CB just slams into him, effectively taking him out of the play.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79405&pbp_id=287224
A TD play, watch as both CBs play bump and run and sit on the #1 receiver, giving him absolutely 0 chance to get past the 5 yard mark.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79405&pbp_id=287409
OH GOD IT BURNS tries to run forward on this middle length pass play, but the CB drapes himself over the WR and he never gets into his route.

It's not a matter of agility, as OH GOD IT BURNS is our punt returner (and thus very fast and very agile) and has 4 points in first step. However, with the recent nerf to acceleration, is the Bump and Run coverage being used by the game too effective?

I think there are two questions here.

1. Can a WR hope to ever get open against bump and run coverage if it makes them accelerate twice? The play is usually over before a WR can accelerate to escape a CB after the bump. From what I understand, the purpose of the bump and run type coverage is to throw the WR slightly off his path and disrupt the timing of the play... not stop him completely.

2. If the intent of the coverage IS to stop the WR completely, is there something in the sim that allows the WR to go around the bump and run coverage? It seems like when he encounters the bump and run coverage, he just lays down and forgets the play ever happened. He doesn't slant in to try to cut inside on the coverage, he doesn't even really attempt to play any longer.

I was just curious about the whole thing. I understand how bump and run coverage usually works, and it's not a matter of my player lacking the necessary agility to get around the CB. Does anyone have any suggestions or comments regarding this?
 
FluffyPenguin
offline
Link
 
try training strength and put some skill points into route run
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
I agree, the new change to speed is really making the passsing game no fun to watch.
Even with my CB I am not happy how its running plays.
 
treygreen13
offline
Link
 
Maybe it's the "smooth operator" special ability allowing them to hold the WR?
 
Swampgator75
offline
Link
 
Looks like WR's might actually need to pay attention to STRENGTH this season. That's how you beat B&R.

Any WR who tries to out maneuver B&R (SPD and AGL) takes himself off his route which destroys timing patterns.

This all makes sense to me.
 
Ryiotgear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by treygreen13

1. Can a WR hope to ever get open against bump and run coverage if it makes them accelerate twice? The play is usually over before a WR can accelerate to escape a CB after the bump. From what I understand, the purpose of the bump and run type coverage is to throw the WR slightly off his path and disrupt the timing of the play... not stop him completely.

2. If the intent of the coverage IS to stop the WR completely, is there something in the sim that allows the WR to go around the bump and run coverage? It seems like when he encounters the bump and run coverage, he just lays down and forgets the play ever happened. He doesn't slant in to try to cut inside on the coverage, he doesn't even really attempt to play any longer.

I was just curious about the whole thing. I understand how bump and run coverage usually works, and it's not a matter of my player lacking the necessary agility to get around the CB. Does anyone have any suggestions or comments regarding this?


We also noticed this on most passing plays. To me it seemed to impact everyone from high agility WRs to TEs with 50+ strength. I'd be curious what some thoughts were as to minimizing the effectiveness of the bump and run from the offensive standpoint and from the alternative perspective how to make it work better for you on defense.
 
Swampgator75
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ryiotgear
To me it seemed to impact everyone from high agility WRs to TEs with 50+ strength.


Were those TE's going against LB's that were just as strong? B&R should be a match up like like G vs. DT is. The strongest one wins.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ryiotgear
I'd be curious what some thoughts were as to minimizing the effectiveness of the bump and run from the offensive standpoint and from the alternative perspective how to make it work better for you on defense.

Perhaps we can get a change to one of the abilities (such as "Route Run") that provides a similar effect to the way "Shed Block" works for DEs. It would work based on Agility/Vision/Strength to allow the WR to side-stop or bulldoze a CB trying to bump him off his route.
 
treygreen13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Swampgator75
Originally posted by Ryiotgear

To me it seemed to impact everyone from high agility WRs to TEs with 50+ strength.


Were those TE's going against LB's that were just as strong? B&R should be a match up like like G vs. DT is. The strongest one wins.


Bump and Run isn't in real life doesn't work out as just an opposed strength check. The Bump and Run is to throw a receiver off his route slightly and disrupt the timing, not to lay him out on the 5 yard spot and sit on him. The game isn't all about strength.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
It's funny, the opposite seemed to happen with my WR.

The CB would get up all nice and cozy and then my guy would shove him off create separation and catch the ball. Though, he wasn't pressed as hard as your guy. I'll have to keep an eye on that.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79811&pbp_id=156002
 
treygreen13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ryiotgear
Originally posted by treygreen13


1. Can a WR hope to ever get open against bump and run coverage if it makes them accelerate twice? The play is usually over before a WR can accelerate to escape a CB after the bump. From what I understand, the purpose of the bump and run type coverage is to throw the WR slightly off his path and disrupt the timing of the play... not stop him completely.

2. If the intent of the coverage IS to stop the WR completely, is there something in the sim that allows the WR to go around the bump and run coverage? It seems like when he encounters the bump and run coverage, he just lays down and forgets the play ever happened. He doesn't slant in to try to cut inside on the coverage, he doesn't even really attempt to play any longer.

I was just curious about the whole thing. I understand how bump and run coverage usually works, and it's not a matter of my player lacking the necessary agility to get around the CB. Does anyone have any suggestions or comments regarding this?


We also noticed this on most passing plays. To me it seemed to impact everyone from high agility WRs to TEs with 50+ strength. I'd be curious what some thoughts were as to minimizing the effectiveness of the bump and run from the offensive standpoint and from the alternative perspective how to make it work better for you on defense.


Well, from an offensive standpoint, if I was facing lots of bump and run coverage, I'd tell the WRs to run inside crossing routes and run my biggest back outside.
However, I can't tell my guys to do that because I can't instruct my WRs to run inside routes specifically. I have to go with what options the game gives me, which are
A: Abandon the WR pass, and pass to TEs only.
B: Run, because I can't pass to WRs who are writhing on the ground being strangled by CBs.

From a defensive standpoint, it would seem that it would be beneficial to play bump and run all the time on every WR. It takes the WR out of the play, leaving every other target for the QB at the mercy of the rest of the defense.
 
treygreen13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
It's funny, the opposite seemed to happen with my WR.

The CB would get up all nice and cozy and then my guy would shove him off create separation and catch the ball. Though, he wasn't pressed as hard as your guy. I'll have to keep an eye on that.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79811&pbp_id=156002


You see, my CBs did mostly that too. They'd stay really close, but they never got the same "beat down" effect that my WRs did. It seems like they were almost pancaked at the 5 yard mark, rather than the traditional bump and run type move (shoved off course, briefly paused)
 
cane__boy
offline
Link
 
strenght!!!
 
biohazarddfl
offline
Link
 
How does one impliment the bump and run? Is it as simple as typing in the output bump and run?
 
treygreen13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by biohazarddfl
How does one impliment the bump and run? Is it as simple as typing in the output bump and run?


That is a very good question.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.