User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Good Gaming / Exploitation or combination of above slow builds focus
Page:
 
cober
offline
Link
 
I have started making a few slow build players of my own and have come to conclusion that really this is almost exploiting the system for an advantage. But firstly you must understand that 80 percent of new players entering this game will not know about this until they have developed their first or 2ND character which will cause frustrations.

Firstly you need to understand the major benefits of slow building.

AT Level 4 you will have capped your first skill at 49 then your auto level points shall raise that skill.
By level 23 that skill will have raised to 59.5 without needing to invest any more skill points. This will give you net benefit of 19 SP just through levelling. And benefit over a normal build of 9.5 or 2 level worth of skill points.

By level 10 (possibly 9) you will have capped your 2nd major skill at 49. This by level 23 shall result in skill rising to 55.5 without further investment. Net benefit of 13 skill points. And benefit over normal build of 1.5 worth of skill points.

3rd major is capped at 16 (possibly 15). Results in skill rising to 52.5 by level 23. Net benefit of 7 skill points and benefit over normal build of half a level worth of skill points.

So in that example a slow build character that advances to same level as normal built character will have benefit of 4 levels or 20 skill points! This is built free through current levelling system.

On some characters you can gain further advancement by raising your primary up to 60. This can be done by level 8. And net benefit then is gain of 24 skill points through natural levelling bonus by level 23. Half that and you gain 2.5 levels worth of free skill points.

As you can see slow building results in benefits which normal built character cannot ever access. Due to that fact i find it hazy on if it’s just good common sense or exploiting the build engine.

I can see a sense of dissatisfaction developing down the track when a lot new players realize that their level 25+ player is really 4 levels worse off in SP department then slow built player.

There are some obvious solutions to this problem

A) If Bort & DD are happy with concept put up a guide. At least then you can show players that the knowledge is available if they had just looked.

B) Have bonus to stat per levelling be effected by soft cap. Example when i go from level 4 to 5 my soft caped skill would only raise by .25 . This would result in even playing field. I am not sure if Bort could filter out current players developed that way.

c) Eliminate auto rising of primary stats. And instead give players 8 SP per level.

D) Reset all players spent SP. And then allow them to reallocate them. This would allow any the above fixes to be put in place without allowing those of us who already taken the path to further benefit by removing the path to others.
Anyway in conclusion i do find this to be extremely close to an exploit and fact it goes against what bort has said about players requiring that you take a balanced approach to developing your player. Fact is for a little pain in first couple seasons. Your players can benefit by 4 levels worth of SP is rather scary. And that benefit continues with each level worth of bonus to primary statistics.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
This isn't a bug, it's a suggestion.
 
Stickman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
This isn't a bug, it's a suggestion.


Hence it being in the suggestion forum......

Thanks,
StickMan
 
Devolution
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stickman
Originally posted by Jed

This isn't a bug, it's a suggestion.


Hence it being in the suggestion forum......

Thanks,
StickMan


LoL
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Option D would be nice. It would also allow people to customize their players better since the 3 extra points would not be allocated automatically for people. Though, the players would be weaker overall -- but since everyone is weaker there is no relative change.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Devolution
Originally posted by Stickman

Originally posted by Jed


This isn't a bug, it's a suggestion.


Hence it being in the suggestion forum......

Thanks,
StickMan


LoL


It was in Bugs, I moved it here
 
bob_tomato
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cober
---SNIP--- detailed explanation of the slow build process and the poster's suggestion for addressing it


One question: how many seasons does it take to slow build a player in this manner? Anyone done the math? I have to wonder if the tradeoff here is the fact that a "normal" build character gets the chance to play on a team(s) for a full ten seasons (assuming that cap is accurate), while a "slow" build character will be limited to a shorter active playing career.

Last edited Jul 30, 2008 12:17:17
 
Dee
offline
Link
 
I agree. Anyone who doesn't slow build their character atleast to some degree (even just maxing a skill asap) is at a distinct disadvantage.


If they (the developers) want any sort of realistic low level builds, they need to rethink how the +skills on levelup work. It should probably give +1 if under 49, +0.5 if 49-60, +0.33 if 61-69 or whatever, etc, etc
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
Yes, slow building can work very well. The downside is that it takes 2-3 seasons to pay off, and you really suck for a while. So you're giving up at least 2 and possibly 3 seasons just getting your guy playable.

He'll be a major bad-ass by season 5 or 6, though.

The real difficulty is finding a team to let you slow build. If you have your own team this isn't a problem.
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dee
If they (the developers) want any sort of realistic low level builds, they need to rethink how the +skills on levelup work. It should probably give +1 if under 49, +0.5 if 49-60, +0.33 if 61-69 or whatever, etc, etc


This is how it should have worked from the beginning. No question at all.

The problem is that changing it vastly advantages people who have higher level players since they'll have gained a whole bunch of points already. The only way to make it work is to actually subtract the "extra" points from those players and I just can't see that working.

So Bort has painted himself into a bit of a corner; the way it currently works is almost broken and encourages stupid, arbitrary, gamey min-maxing. But fixing it at this point will be a fiasco.

That's why you think about the impact of your design before it happens, not after. This was an easy problem to see coming.

edit: Let me say that Bort should change it even with the flamefest that would result. Sometimes you have to suck it up and fix a mistake even if people will scream bloody murder. The longer it stays the way it is the harder it will be to fix.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 12:39:23
 
JAY25M2396
offline
Link
 
I don't know if it will take 5-6 seasons to be good. I built a Center in right before game 9 of last season. He is level 8 now with 2 boosts. so in one season, he went up to level 6 and that was playing in the D-League. On a human team, My SS pretty much got on one immediately. In his first full season, he leveled up 7 times not including the 3 boosts in that 1 season alone. So I think it will only take maybe 3 seasons for a slow built player to be bad ass.

just my opinion though.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
I like how people decide that whenever they made decisions which turned out to be less advantageous than other choices which were available, the other choices must have been "exploits."

I don't see anything wrong with how Bort designed player development. I broadcast this distinction as soon as I learned of it (late season 1, about 4 days after I started playing) so that others would recognize the benefits (and costs) of choosing to develop a player in this fashion. Player development offers many choices. Those who thought that it was cool to build players to be productive immediately got to bask in better player statistics early in their players' careers. Slow building offers the opportunity to have better players later on in their careers, at the price of not getting to use all those special abilities early as well as suffering through a season or two of not being optimally suited to be a stud on the field "right now."

The game offers choices in how to accomplish your goals. I find it unsporting to complain after you've made one choice that the option you didn't choose was an "exploit" and demand that it be nerfed. What's so hard about living with your deccisions, particularly since players have limited careers so you can make entirely different choices every time you make a new player?
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
Did I say anything about an exploit? No, no I did not.

I said that a better game design would have been to have the automatic points follow the same progression as regular skill points. And from an objective game design standpoint I strongly believe it <i>would</i> have been a better way to set thing up as it would lead to more intuitive and less gamey results. And a good measure of how your design works is how intuitive and natural the results are. If your design results in football players advancing naturally, that's a good result. If your design results in players tending to advance in screwy rules-manipulating ways, that's a bad result.

The results of the way skill points work is objectively gamey and playing the system rather than the sport of football. That's just a fact.

Is it wrong to play the game as written instead of the game is it would ideally be? Of course not. I just set up 2 halfbacks that I'm building to take advantage of the way skill points progress. Clearly if I'm doing it myself I don't think it's wrong to do so. I was speaking solely about how it should have been set up in the first place.

I realize maybe you were talking to the first guy, but I thought I'd throw in my 2 cents anyway.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
I disagree...knowing the game is the only advantage to playing this game longer. EXP slows down so much people will catch up in 3-5 seasons anyway. But its your knowledge that will get you to the promise land.

What happens next season when there are 25-32s everywhere?? A solid 25 will beat a bad built 32....imo
 
cober
offline
Link
 
But should the solid built 25 have an extra 20 skill points to spend due to knowing the system. Thats not good building. If you gave anyone 20 extra skill points their character is most likely going to be superior.

Fact is i doubt Bort expected players to gain an advantage by not spending skill points and max raising one skill in order to gain bonus level points above the stat cap. Which is using the system to your advantage and not in the way that developers wanted.

Problem is a slow built solid 25 build is far superior to solid normal built level 25. 20 skill points superior. Knowing the game should give you advantage but not in a way which gives you extra points to spend over another player.


How long to develop a player using this system 2 season and you can be 15 with 3 stat capped skills. By the 3rd season your well in front of the other players.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 21:20:49
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.