I think in about 10 years from now LaDainian Tomlinson will be the greatest RB. of alltime.
Forum > Free for All > When it's all said and done best RB ever
Jerome Neil
offline
offline
Statistically? Probably.
But I still rate Sayers, Payton, Sanders, Dickerson and Faulk (off the top of my head) alot moreso than I have ever done LaDainian.
But I still rate Sayers, Payton, Sanders, Dickerson and Faulk (off the top of my head) alot moreso than I have ever done LaDainian.
pootytang
offline
offline
prueter is probably correct, 10 years from now barring injury LT will have both the TD and rushing record. Hes also a stand up guy.
whotookmybowtie
offline
offline
And he carries that offense. The only other threat they've had is Antonio Gates, who I'll admit, is probably the best receiving tight end right now, but he's never had any wide outs that could take the attention away from him.
Tiznut
offline
offline
Originally posted by PRUETER
I think in about 10 years from now LaDainian Tomlinson will be the greatest RB. of alltime.
Hard to argue with that with the rate he scores TDs.
I think in about 10 years from now LaDainian Tomlinson will be the greatest RB. of alltime.
Hard to argue with that with the rate he scores TDs.
dlinebass5
offline
offline
Will he be running in ten years? That's an obvious question that needs to be answered (or at least postulated) before any discussion of his ranking among the greats can be hashed out.
Tiznut
offline
offline
Originally posted by dlinebass5
Will he be running in ten years? That's an obvious question that needs to be answered (or at least postulated) before any discussion of his ranking among the greats can be hashed out.
NO it doesn't. He said in 10 years from now people will say he's the best. He doesn't need to be still playing then for people to reflect on his career in such a manner. Hell half the time it takes retirement for people to finally sit and really look at what a player accomplished. Normally when it's going on people are just in too much awe to think of what effects it has on history. Just ask the underappreciated Marcus Allen.
Will he be running in ten years? That's an obvious question that needs to be answered (or at least postulated) before any discussion of his ranking among the greats can be hashed out.
NO it doesn't. He said in 10 years from now people will say he's the best. He doesn't need to be still playing then for people to reflect on his career in such a manner. Hell half the time it takes retirement for people to finally sit and really look at what a player accomplished. Normally when it's going on people are just in too much awe to think of what effects it has on history. Just ask the underappreciated Marcus Allen.
quicksilver
offline
offline
If Adrian Peterson can stay healthy, he has a chance at giving LT a run for his money.
But yes, LT will be the best of all time when his career is over. Nobody is or was more dynamic.
Sanders, Brown, Payton... All greats, but none have everything LT does.
But yes, LT will be the best of all time when his career is over. Nobody is or was more dynamic.
Sanders, Brown, Payton... All greats, but none have everything LT does.
dlinebass5
offline
offline
Tiznut, you're morphing his original post into your own, I think... But, let's go off of your's, then. I think that, as he's still playing, and there has been nothing but talk of how he is the best, your statement is false. Take a better look at today's media, and come to realize just how much hype players recieve in regards to greatness. How much talk has there been about Adrian Peterson being one of the greats as his career continues? It does not take retirement for people to consider a player's achievements.
Now, to answer the question, I don't believe that he'll be the known as the greatest runner to ever play the game. He is a great player, but also consider the variation in today's game to the game of the past. I'm not sure it's right to even compare players of different eras. I usually don't get into these types of discussions, but I guess that I just wandered in here... As for today's game, I do think that Tomlinson has to be among the best. I don't know enough about him to examine every aspect of his game, nor do I know enough about all the other backs in the league, so I cannot crown him the best. A terrific player with the ball in his hands, though, without question.
Now, to answer the question, I don't believe that he'll be the known as the greatest runner to ever play the game. He is a great player, but also consider the variation in today's game to the game of the past. I'm not sure it's right to even compare players of different eras. I usually don't get into these types of discussions, but I guess that I just wandered in here... As for today's game, I do think that Tomlinson has to be among the best. I don't know enough about him to examine every aspect of his game, nor do I know enough about all the other backs in the league, so I cannot crown him the best. A terrific player with the ball in his hands, though, without question.
Jerome Neil
offline
offline
Originally posted by quicksilver
If Adrian Peterson can stay healthy, he has a chance at giving LT a run for his money.
But yes, LT will be the best of all time when his career is over. Nobody is or was more dynamic.
Sanders, Brown, Payton... All greats, but none have everything LT does.
As a running back? Sure.
As a football player, I disagree.
If Adrian Peterson can stay healthy, he has a chance at giving LT a run for his money.
But yes, LT will be the best of all time when his career is over. Nobody is or was more dynamic.
Sanders, Brown, Payton... All greats, but none have everything LT does.
As a running back? Sure.
As a football player, I disagree.
Tiznut
offline
offline
Originally posted by dlinebass5
Tiznut, you're morphing his original post into your own, I think... But, let's go off of your's, then. I think that, as he's still playing, and there has been nothing but talk of how he is the best, your statement is false. Take a better look at today's media, and come to realize just how much hype players recieve in regards to greatness. How much talk has there been about Adrian Peterson being one of the greats as his career continues? It does not take retirement for people to consider a player's achievements.
Now, to answer the question, I don't believe that he'll be the known as the greatest runner to ever play the game. He is a great player, but also consider the variation in today's game to the game of the past. I'm not sure it's right to even compare players of different eras. I usually don't get into these types of discussions, but I guess that I just wandered in here... As for today's game, I do think that Tomlinson has to be among the best. I don't know enough about him to examine every aspect of his game, nor do I know enough about all the other backs in the league, so I cannot crown him the best. A terrific player with the ball in his hands, though, without question.
Not morphing. Just reading it at face value. He says "I think in about 10 years from now LaDainian Tomlinson will be the greatest RB. of alltime."
it doesn't say "in 10 years I think LT will just now be breaking Emmitt's record".
It's in the same light as discussing greatest back of all time now. We aren't discussing any players that are currently playing are we?
As for your not considering him the best now. I agree. As I said in my post I think if he keeps up his TD rate it would be hard to argue against him being the greatest.
I'm also a realist and no that no matter how great a player is to us now someone else will come along and be just as good, if not better later. I call it the Lebron James syndrome. No one would consider him a better player than Jordan but reality is he, as well as Kobe, benefit from Jordan's game film and are able to take what Jordan did to another level. I would never consider them greater than Jordan cause of the impact on the game but they are breaking Jordan records as we speak.
Tiznut, you're morphing his original post into your own, I think... But, let's go off of your's, then. I think that, as he's still playing, and there has been nothing but talk of how he is the best, your statement is false. Take a better look at today's media, and come to realize just how much hype players recieve in regards to greatness. How much talk has there been about Adrian Peterson being one of the greats as his career continues? It does not take retirement for people to consider a player's achievements.
Now, to answer the question, I don't believe that he'll be the known as the greatest runner to ever play the game. He is a great player, but also consider the variation in today's game to the game of the past. I'm not sure it's right to even compare players of different eras. I usually don't get into these types of discussions, but I guess that I just wandered in here... As for today's game, I do think that Tomlinson has to be among the best. I don't know enough about him to examine every aspect of his game, nor do I know enough about all the other backs in the league, so I cannot crown him the best. A terrific player with the ball in his hands, though, without question.
Not morphing. Just reading it at face value. He says "I think in about 10 years from now LaDainian Tomlinson will be the greatest RB. of alltime."
it doesn't say "in 10 years I think LT will just now be breaking Emmitt's record".
It's in the same light as discussing greatest back of all time now. We aren't discussing any players that are currently playing are we?
As for your not considering him the best now. I agree. As I said in my post I think if he keeps up his TD rate it would be hard to argue against him being the greatest.
I'm also a realist and no that no matter how great a player is to us now someone else will come along and be just as good, if not better later. I call it the Lebron James syndrome. No one would consider him a better player than Jordan but reality is he, as well as Kobe, benefit from Jordan's game film and are able to take what Jordan did to another level. I would never consider them greater than Jordan cause of the impact on the game but they are breaking Jordan records as we speak.
DeWittFootball
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jerome Neil
Statistically? Probably.
But I still rate Sayers, Payton, Sanders, Dickerson and Faulk (off the top of my head) alot moreso than I have ever done LaDainian.
A solid argument could be made for Sanders and Payton, but Sayers is based on what could have been, Dickerson eh great but I say a step down from the top few, and idk how you can say Faulk only thing I would think of is receiveing but LT is the only RB to rush for more than 1000 yrds and catch 100 passes in a season so its not like he doesnt have receiving skills.
Once hes done LT will be remembered as the greatest in my mind for a long time to come. Especially if he can get San Diego a SB or two before hes done.
Statistically? Probably.
But I still rate Sayers, Payton, Sanders, Dickerson and Faulk (off the top of my head) alot moreso than I have ever done LaDainian.
A solid argument could be made for Sanders and Payton, but Sayers is based on what could have been, Dickerson eh great but I say a step down from the top few, and idk how you can say Faulk only thing I would think of is receiveing but LT is the only RB to rush for more than 1000 yrds and catch 100 passes in a season so its not like he doesnt have receiving skills.
Once hes done LT will be remembered as the greatest in my mind for a long time to come. Especially if he can get San Diego a SB or two before hes done.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























