User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
mavsman
offline
Link
 
The Samoa Gangsters just lost the championship game by two points and one of our players brought this up which I find odd.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=78060&mode=pbp

To close the first half the Gangsters have the ball and it is 2nd down with 31 seconds on the clock on the opposing teams 16 yard line. Why don't we kick a FG there? No we pass and make an 8.5 yard catch which really only takes about 5 seconds, which would give the special teams 26 seconds to get on the field if there happened to be no timeouts. 26 seconds should be plenty of time without timeouts, or since we just got a first down we could have spiked it. Why didn't we kick a field goal then?

The only theory my fellow GM and I could come up with is because the game thought we were not giving up the ball because we were getting the kickoff at the half, and decided a FG wasn't warranted.
Last edited Jul 20, 2008 22:55:05
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
I actually thought they had kind of fixed this. No idea why it didn't kick the ball instead of pass.
 
Noaheli
offline
Link
 
Saratoga Thoroughbreds 1:28
1:28 Kickoff by Andrew McDonald, 53 yd, fielded by The Specialist [missed tackle: Ridho Hammam] (37 yd return) [tackle: Stewart Pickett]

1:17 1st & 10 OPP 46.5 Xander Lebeaux pass to Amazing Larry up the right side (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Frank "Pistons"]

0:35 2nd & 2.5 OPP 38.5 Xander Lebeaux pitch to He Hate Me [missed tackle: Chela Kit] [missed tackle: Stewart Pickett] [missed tackle: Hank Boomer] to the left (13.5 yd gain) [tackle: GEE KAY]

0:01 1st & 10 OPP 25 42 yd field goal attempted by Jean-Luc Lebeaux, made [FG] [Virginia Cowboys: 6 | Saratoga Thoroughbreds: 26]

We did
 
mavsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Noaheli
Saratoga Thoroughbreds 1:28
1:28 Kickoff by Andrew McDonald, 53 yd, fielded by The Specialist [missed tackle: Ridho Hammam] (37 yd return) [tackle: Stewart Pickett]

1:17 1st & 10 OPP 46.5 Xander Lebeaux pass to Amazing Larry up the right side (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Frank "Pistons"]

0:35 2nd & 2.5 OPP 38.5 Xander Lebeaux pitch to He Hate Me [missed tackle: Chela Kit] [missed tackle: Stewart Pickett] [missed tackle: Hank Boomer] to the left (13.5 yd gain) [tackle: GEE KAY]

0:01 1st & 10 OPP 25 42 yd field goal attempted by Jean-Luc Lebeaux, made [FG] [Virginia Cowboys: 6 | Saratoga Thoroughbreds: 26]

We did


Well there goes the theory about getting the ball in the 2nd half.

You did have 4 more seconds then we did but you play went much longer. If you had enough time, we should have had enough time.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
these topics come up whether they kick it or not... each complaining about why they did or didn't. it's stupid.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
these topics come up whether they kick it or not... each complaining about why they did or didn't. it's stupid.


Yeah, but it does prove there is a bug in the code, at the very least. The more times it is presented, the easier it is to figure out why kickers aren't attempting these short kicks.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
You ever watch real football? Sometimes teams have horrible clock management and even though it seems they have enough time to do something they waste time and don't do it.

Maybe this isn't a bug, but a variable built into the game. There can't always be perfect clock management.

I wish it showed when timeouts were used (been suggested before).
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
these topics come up whether they kick it or not... each complaining about why they did or didn't. it's stupid.

We're not complaining (publicly). However, I've seen a couple games lately in which the team set to receive the 2nd-half kick fails to make the obvious FG to end the first half. Is it impossible that this might be an AI bug?

It's not like we're suggesting the game should be overturned. But if there is a bug, it would be good to fix it.
 
CoachB05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Noaheli
Saratoga Thoroughbreds 1:28
1:28 Kickoff by Andrew McDonald, 53 yd, fielded by The Specialist [missed tackle: Ridho Hammam] (37 yd return) [tackle: Stewart Pickett]

1:17 1st & 10 OPP 46.5 Xander Lebeaux pass to Amazing Larry up the right side (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Frank "Pistons"]

0:35 2nd & 2.5 OPP 38.5 Xander Lebeaux pitch to He Hate Me [missed tackle: Chela Kit] [missed tackle: Stewart Pickett] [missed tackle: Hank Boomer] to the left (13.5 yd gain) [tackle: GEE KAY]

0:01 1st & 10 OPP 25 42 yd field goal attempted by Jean-Luc Lebeaux, made [FG] [Virginia Cowboys: 6 | Saratoga Thoroughbreds: 26]

We did


But why didn't they? And did you get the ball in the 2nd half?
 
Forces904
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
these topics come up whether they kick it or not... each complaining about why they did or didn't. it's stupid.


Well when they lost the game when they could have easily made the field goal and won... It's pretty significant... But I've found several of your posts in the past to be ignorant too so I can't say I'm very surprised at your response
 
Forces904
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
You ever watch real football? Sometimes teams have horrible clock management and even though it seems they have enough time to do something they waste time and don't do it.

Maybe this isn't a bug, but a variable built into the game. There can't always be perfect clock management.

I wish it showed when timeouts were used (been suggested before).


Do YOU ever watch real football?? Have you ever seen a team waste the last 30 seconds of the half on one play that wasn't intentionally wasted??
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by forces904
Do YOU ever watch real football?? Have you ever seen a team waste the last 30 seconds of the half on one play that wasn't intentionally wasted??


Hell yes I have.

http://blogs.thenewstribune.com/seahawks/2007/10/09/holmgren_on_clock_management

We had three timeouts, there was forty seconds to go...if we had kind of executed, at least threw the ball the same way, whether it was complete or not we would have had time to kick the field goal, that’s what I was hoping for, and it didn’t work.”

Edit: OK, I missed the 'one play' part of your question. Still, I think my point stands. Things happen, time gets wasted, mistakes are made. This isn't necessarily a bug.
Last edited Jul 20, 2008 23:56:59
 
Forces904
offline
Link
 
Yeah that was terrible management... But 21-0 a field goal wouldn't have helped lol
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by forces904
Originally posted by jeffgarcia

these topics come up whether they kick it or not... each complaining about why they did or didn't. it's stupid.


Well when they lost the game when they could have easily made the field goal and won... It's pretty significant... But I've found several of your posts in the past to be ignorant too so I can't say I'm very surprised at your response


I never make ignorant posts. Why? Because I don't post when I don't know what I'm talking about. The same cannot be said for most people on this site such as yourself.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Noaheli
Saratoga Thoroughbreds 1:28
1:28 Kickoff by Andrew McDonald, 53 yd, fielded by The Specialist [missed tackle: Ridho Hammam] (37 yd return) [tackle: Stewart Pickett]

1:17 1st & 10 OPP 46.5 Xander Lebeaux pass to Amazing Larry up the right side (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Frank "Pistons"]

0:35 2nd & 2.5 OPP 38.5 Xander Lebeaux pitch to He Hate Me [missed tackle: Chela Kit] [missed tackle: Stewart Pickett] [missed tackle: Hank Boomer] to the left (13.5 yd gain) [tackle: GEE KAY]

0:01 1st & 10 OPP 25 42 yd field goal attempted by Jean-Luc Lebeaux, made [FG] [Virginia Cowboys: 6 | Saratoga Thoroughbreds: 26]

We did


hmmm maybe they didnt have enough time like you cuz they did have 4 seconds less (1-4 = -3) so maybe they were getting ready to hike it when the buzzer sounded
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.