User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
To all AA owners, especially those at the bottom rung:

If you weren't aware, the Canada A owners are rallying against being promoted this season for the most part, because they fear the competition in the AA leagues is to great for their current teams (they think they are too low leveled).

I would like to get the input of AA teams who would be demoted to A, because it would affect you as well. Do you want to stay in AA for another season? Do you think the A owners are wrong/right?

Thanks.
 
cowboy54
offline
Link
 
I know we arent in the relegation zone, but surely even if they stay in the A leagues, unless they can sign players for all positions there will always still be the gap?
 
Link
 
Although not effected by either promotion or relegation this season, I think that for the long term health of the game, promotion and relegation must take place.

JMO, but the strongest teams in A started with mostly level 13s, quite a few of them who boosted to level 16 to start the season...a quick look at the average levels will show that promoted A teams will be ok in AA...maybe not dominant, but ok.

I think that for some of the AA owners who have endured constant thrashings for three seasons, and two of them with nowhere to be relegated to...the game is probably losing its' luster, and a move down would be a healthy change.

And next season will be uncapped for A league anyway, correct?

We all take our lumps in this game at one time or another, and I can understand the concern on the part of the owners who will be moving up. But I think that for competition to level out across the board long term, promotion/relegation should happen.
 
Savage Smurf
offline
Link
 
Well a team that's moving up to AA#3 is about 8 levels below the rest of the league and i doubt they will put up any competition and just end back up in A leagues again.
 
123619
offline
Link
 
i know im not in AA but my team won our confrence so this would affect us, most A teams dont want the promotion because of the level cap of 13 we had.
 
Brohl
offline
Link
 
I don't know, looking at the Calgary Destroyers as one of the teams that will be promoted. I think they would be competitive with a couple of the lower rung teams, but not the top tier. If I had to handicap it, I would say in AA#2 they would be maybe 4-11 next season, possible 3-12. I think we all take our lumps in this game from time to time. Promotion and relegation should happen.
 
Link
 
I'm not in this range, but I was in here, and I think maybe just the bottom of each AA Conference gets demoted, so its only one team per A league.
 
trauty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MightyPoopster
Although not effected by either promotion or relegation this season, I think that for the long term health of the game, promotion and relegation must take place.

JMO, but the strongest teams in A started with mostly level 13s, quite a few of them who boosted to level 16 to start the season...a quick look at the average levels will show that promoted A teams will be ok in AA...maybe not dominant, but ok.

I think that for some of the AA owners who have endured constant thrashings for three seasons, and two of them with nowhere to be relegated to...the game is probably losing its' luster, and a move down would be a healthy change.

And next season will be uncapped for A league anyway, correct?

We all take our lumps in this game at one time or another, and I can understand the concern on the part of the owners who will be moving up. But I think that for competition to level out across the board long term, promotion/relegation should happen.


This is not true, there were very few unboosted level 13's available when the teams were released mid-season, nobody was really able to plan ahead. If you were lucky you got 1 or 2 of them. Our 2 highest leveled players (both 19's) would backup for most teams in Canada AA. We just want one more season to catch up a little, as well as be able to have more time to recruit. If we want to compete at AA we will have to gut our teams and restock with higher leveled players (which aren't exactly easy to find). If we don't do this we will wind up back in A next season and what would be the point of that? Most Canada AA teams that got demoted would likely end right back up in AA next season. Most teams will be at a huge financial disadvantage as well.
 
scarpenter23
offline
Link
 
So in other words they want to punish the team in AA that struggled because they had to change most of roster last year and make them stay where they get hammered again so they dont have to go through a bad season. All I know is if a team goes through a bad year and things dont get better.... Then players want to go and then you take chem. hits again and the cycle repeats... We got behind do to nonboosters... the chem hits and losses mounted and we never recovered... I dont think there is any right/wrong or fair way to do this... But, we gotta know so if we do have to stay we can at least try to get the highest level guys in we can to compete this season...

Last edited Jul 21, 2008 05:29:45
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scarpenter23
So in other words they want to punish the team in AA that struggled because they had to change most of roster last year and make them stay where they get hammered again so they dont have to go through a bad season. All I know is if a team goes through a bad year and things dont get better.... Then players want to go and then you take chem. hits again and the cycle repeats... We got behind do to nonboosters... the chem hits and losses mounted and we never recovered... I dont think there is any right/wrong or fair way to do this... But, we gotta know so if we do have to stay we can at least try to get the highest level guys in we can to compete this season...



I agree at 95% to this. The AA owner's reasons can't be so straight forward (they don't want to change their roster and they just want to stick together)
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 05:59:35
 
beanerz
offline
Link
 
As a Canada 'A' owner that is position to promote my thoughts are that promoting us will simple lead to us having to either completely overhaul our entire teams or settle for a losing season. I think given another season in 'A' and we would learn enough tactically wise and have a strong enough team that after promotion we would be able to compete, atleast to the point of staying up.

This is a tough decision I just hope it is made soon so I can either start rebuilding or make a few small changes.
 
Mauler
Tsalagi
offline
Link
 
As a Canada A owner I actually see both sides of the argument. However, since we will be uncapped this year anyways once one team starts picking up LVL 19/20 players I am sure the others will follow, chemistry hit or no chemistry hit!!!!!
 
libertylane
offline
Link
 
Hey guys,

As a Canada A owner that has been against promotion from the get go (and was eliminated in my conference finals, so the issue no longer directly affects me), i would appreciate it if you checked out these two threads that explain some of the Canada A owners concerns.

(even if you just read the first post here thats ok, it explains a lot of the argument) http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=612016

(This thread was a poll done, asking for input of all Canada A owners facing promotion, and Canada AA owners facing Demotion). http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=614058 [There should be two posts to read on the first page there for the important information, the very first post from Nano, and then the very first post from SeanJansen]
 
jokerpac32
offline
Link
 
As a GM for a team in Canada A that would get promoted I personally am against it. Personally I wouldn't of cared either way a few days ago, but with this being day 40. NO WAY! I've spoken to several FA's in the higher levels, like 18-22 as spoken above. And all said until we know if we'll be A or AA, no thanks. And have committed with other teams. This has completely hurt my chances at signing any of these players. And I'm sure other A owners and GM's have felt this as well.

Plus take the following under consideration.

1) We were level capped at 13.
2) Our chemistry grace period was less than half it normally is.
3) We only got our teams for 8 games.
4) AA's have been a free go since jump.

I'm sure I could go on and on, but all in all regardless of fair or unfair, I don't think it mattered, but when the teams don't know until at the gun, it hurts. Plus no one has actually come forward, that I've seen and said for sure the level cap was being lifted. I'm guessing that it will be, but until an actually official decision is said, it's all assumption.

So to sum this all up, I'd feel bad for the AA team's that got whacked this year. But the sad thing is no matter how bad those AA teams were against AA teams, chances are 95% or more of those whacked teams are better than the A teams that would be promoted.

And use the Canada A #4 champions. They have great starters, they might be able to compete in AA. But pull back the skirt and you'll see very weak depth, and they would kill them in AA. But upgrading can fix that, sure. But that takes me back to the teams not knowing until the last second, and players worried about XP hits.

So yah all teams, owners, players should get a full season with no restrictions before being promoted.
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 07:49:21
 
dan rules
offline
Link
 
Either way there are losers, but a canada AA team that spends another year in AA would be much better off then a Canada A team that will be outleveled by 7-8 if they got promoted.

Not to mention whichever AA teams get demoted will become dominant teams in A, because they didn't have level caps.

It would just be fair to give Canada A teams another year to build their teams up instead of having to demolish their teams and sign all kinds of FA's to try and compete with the much higher levels in AA.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.