User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #2 > I have a hard decision to make
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I really do love this game. I spend almost every minute of free time I have on here. I have already invested over $200 on it and I have over 1300 FP in the bank.

Right now I have only reserved this team through the end of season 4. I had planned on always keeping a team, but due to the ethics or lack there of from some of the moderators, and developments support of their actions, I'm conflicted as to how much of an investment I really want to have in this game.

I'm torn between sticking with a game I love, and not wanting to support an organization which supports poor ethical behavior. I haven't given anyone on my team a contract past the end of season 4 and I won't do so unless I decide to keep the team longer.

I love this league and don't want to throw a gutted team back into it, just because I have problems with the way the game is currently being run, so I will see what I can do as far as finding someone to take over for me and keep the team together if I decide I'm not going to continue ownership.

I will probably stay in the game even if I don't keep a team. However, if I keep the team I will need to put more cash into the game. If I don't, then I will retire some of the players I have already created and just keep playing with players until the current FP I already have invested eventually run out.

I will probably take about a week to make my decision one way or another, and wait and see what announcements development makes over that time. I will let everyone know when I have come to a decision one way or another.
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
I think we've all been in this position in some form or another. From being ON a gutted team to having someone use your team as their personal farm team to constantly losing to the same teams that you KNOW have been built up through some seriously shady transactions.....to anything in between.

I think a lot of the positives far outweigh the negatives, especially when we're talking about Oceania in general. There's been some tight bonds formed through mutual respect and friendly rivalries in this league. So much so that they now span from A all the way to PRO.

I hope you find an answer that you're comfortable with and that a lot of the mess you're refering to gets cleaned up. I'm sure, this being a business first and foremost, if enough people make their disgust with what's being allowed to happen (though the proper channels of course); something will be done. If there is someone who's exploiting a "power" given to them THEN turning around and threatening to "discipline" paying customeres who question his actions, eventually it'll drive those paying customers away. Allowing that to happen is not a smart move from a business point of view.

Maybe you can get the ball rolling. A petition (via PM) requesting immediate corrective actions, which can then be consolodated and sent to support or a developer once it hits 100 paying signers?

Hell, maybe 500?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I guess I'm kind of pissed because I immediately went to support to complain about this issue, and the basic response from Bort himself was "He didn't do anything wrong, and we aren't going to answer any more PM's on the issue. This thread is locked."

I love this game. I love this league. I have a good relationship with the people who have players on my teams, and I have a good relationship with the owners that have my players on their teams. Also, I haven't been personally efected by these actions. I just have a moral dilemma in whether or not I want my money going to support an organization that operates in the manner this one does.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Start a petition, and I'll be your John Hancock. I really love the game, but some of the people in power need to quit their trip and keep the game fair.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
So something like.

Please add your name if you believe GLB needs a moderator code of ethics.


Moderators in GLB are the most visible authority figures of the game. Since success in this game is centered around message board use, and they have authority over the message boards, it also makes them the most prominent authority figures of the game.

With authority, also comes responsibility and the expectations of a higher code of conduct. In society, police are expected to maintain a higher code of conduct whether in or out of uniform than the average citizen is held to. Teachers, religous leaders, military officers, and others who hold positions of authority over groups of people are also held to higher standards. The same should be true for moderators of not only games but any message board in general.

Because of this I propose that GLB adopt a moderator code of conduct. Those moderators who want to abide by it can maintain their position. Those who feel it is to restrictive can choose to give up their position as I am sure there are many people who would be willing to apply for the positions and abide by it.

The code should include but not be limited to

1. Moderators should maintain a civil and professional demeanor when responding to threads or posts. No matter how ridiculous a comment is, how many times a question has been asked, or how misguided the poster is in his comments or accusations, moderators should never answer in a sarcastic, mean spirited, or emotional manner.

2. Moderators should never be able to moderate a thread in which they are actively participating in a debate. If they are a participant and feel a thread is getting out of hand, they should notify another moderator not involved, and let that moderator judge whether or not intervention is needed.

3. Moderators should not use their name to advertise their teams or players. The act of being a moderator, inherently gives one a position of much higher visibility. It also causes many members of the community to beleive that they have extra knowledge about how the game works and how players should be created. Whether this opinion is valid or not, is of no consequence. The fact that the belief exists among a significant percentage of the community presents an opportunity for moderators to take advantage of their name.

Moderators can still recruit and they can still try to get their players on a team. Examples of appropriate threads:
USA PRO PLAYOFF CONTENDER needs a few good players
Level 4 player with custom equipment and will boost looking for new team

Examples of inappropriate threads:
MODERATOR A is looking for players
MODERATOR B has 3 players looking for a home

4. Moderators may not make propositions that the vast majority of customers could never find someone to agree to. It does not matter if there are a few non-moderators who could gain the same advantage, because moderators should be held to higher standard. If less than 5% of the community could expect to have a proposition met, then a moderator should not make it.

Example of an inappropriate proposition:
I have a level 3 DT with no custom, and I will not boost until the end of the season. I am an experienced active team player, and I will boost at the end of each season, but I will not share his build. I want a 1 year contract and a starting spot. However, I will help out the team in any way I can.

5. Moderators can not let owners with moderator players on the team use that as a recruiting tool. They must tell owners up front that this practice is not allowed, and they can lose forum priviledges for doing it. Once again, if people believe that moderators have special knowledge because of their position, it is an unfair recruiting tool whether it is true or not.

6. It is not enough for a moderator to abide by the letter of the law. Moderators must always try to act in a manner that upholds the spirit of the game. If a practice seems to be questionable, or in a grey area, they should get approval from development before engaging in that practice.


Now how to I get it passed around or to stay on a message board without getting locked?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=605994
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
already locked. It took less than 2 minutes.

The decision made on this subject will have a huge effect on my future contribution to this game.
Last edited Jul 16, 2008 22:26:26
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
Well, look @ the bright side, both Tim and Bort are aware there is a problem, no matter how "underhanded" the comments were seen.

If you're serious about persuing this, go through the initial thread that Tim mentions and start PM'ing anyone and everyone who you think will endorse this suggestion.

Compile the names, quote the replies, and periodically consolodate them into 1 PM to a friend. Keep the list updated then send it directly to Bort and DD once you feel you have enough names. Maybe the PM will make it there before they "reach a decision" and the weight of support will help them reach the proper decision

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I don't have the time nor the inbox capacity to do that. I will now leave it up to others to find people that agree and are willing to sign on. Everyone who reads this can feel free to copy it and send it to as many people as they wish and see what kind of support it gets or who replies to them. I got the ball rolling, now I am going to wait and see what the results are.
 
mhviper1
offline
Link
 
Well, you got my vote on the idea. May even want to have something along the lines of a moderator league, so they can play, and people know what they are getting into. Just a thought to add to a good one.
 
tsimp93
offline
Link
 
Stay!
 
ThirdFingerUp
offline
Link
 
One of the biggest reasons I am leaving GLB and you couldnt have said it better I have been fighting this battle since week one of this game..

Shady underhanded dealings not only from Mods but from certain team owners it became almost unfair to even have a team.

I have sent Bort many complaints only to have them fall on deaf ears never once in the last 10 pm's to Bort have I received a response from him Thorn or even Digital

Bort continues to allow people to make thier own rules it came down to this

Your either a Friend of Borts (or one of his Mods) or your a GLB Customer

 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
I have to agree, the Mods are shady. I stay for my team and the competition. It's something I do in my free time.
 
turftoe
offline
Link
 
Are there any mod teams here in Oceania? I think that's one of the reasons why I'm so much in the dark on these issues - I haven't run into any of these types of problems.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
To be honest, the majority of Mods are on the level, but there are a few, not going to bother naming them here as that's just asking for a suspension from one of them, that bend the rules whenever they can, have itchy-trigger-fingers when it comes to suspensions, or are just assholes in general.

Hopefully Bort, DD & Thorn, and the other Admins, realize that the mods are, in many cases, the face of this game. Heck, some people think they are admins. And the way some of them act is turning people off the game. It really is an issue I wish they would actually address.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.