User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #2 > Do you consider renting players out acceptable practice?
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
As far as I know, no one in this league is participating in this practice. For those who do not know what it is, owners are "renting" out their own players for part or all of a season. They sign their own players to contracts that end on day 40 of the season. They then trade them for max cash, or players signed to longer contracts.

When the season ends, they resign their player while the team chemistry hit is minimal, then trade them again for players or cash.

I have not engaged in this practice and I refuse to engage in this practice, even though I could afford to. However, I feel practices like this will ruin GLB by turning it into a game where those who are willing to spend the most real cash and resort to any tactic, will be the only ones able to field competitive teams.

I love playing in this league and find it very competitive and fun. I like having to work on my gameplan almost every game to have a chance at winning. I want to stay and be an owner for a long time.

With that said, if I discover any team in my conference, and maybe even in the league resorting to this practice, I will sign every player on my team to an end of year contract and then sell it back 2 days before their contracts expire.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
This happens A LOT when teams are obviously out of the playoffs. A couple hundred grand for a lvl 20+ guy in the last few days of the trading period this season.

It's one way for rebuilding teams to raise a little money so they're more competitive down the road. I don't do it, but I could have with a few of my guys. I figured it was more important to get a culture of competitiveness going and try to win a few of our last games. I don't blame teams that do it though, that's the system Bort has implemented. It's not unlike MLB where there are always players on short deals being sent to contenders.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
This happens A LOT when teams are obviously out of the playoffs. A couple hundred grand for a lvl 20+ guy in the last few days of the trading period this season.

It's one way for rebuilding teams to raise a little money so they're more competitive down the road. I don't do it, but I could have with a few of my guys. I figured it was more important to get a culture of competitiveness going and try to win a few of our last games. I don't blame teams that do it though, that's the system Bort has implemented. It's not unlike MLB where there are always players on short deals being sent to contenders.


But MLB players don't turn around and sign another 1 year deal with the team that just traded them either.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I don't agree with it, but there is a market for these players because...

A) if they are good, they might help win a championship or help a team earn home games + more cash.

B) there are a ton of bad owners that don't bother to check contract ending dates or who owns a player and whether they own a team or not.

Until there is a rule against it or no market for this, it will continue. I've traded one of my players away, but it was to get him more playing time and he won't be coming back to my team at this time, probably not ever. I'd rather win and earn my title, not buy it or cheat my way to it.
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
It's cheating
 
xerofs
offline
Link
 
I cant really see how it can be classified as cheating... if you have money to buy players you can do it anytime, and if an owner knows that they are getting a player for only the playoff push then I don't see the problem with it.

even though MLB players or NHL players dont often sign back to the teams they left in the trade, they do have that choice and they could sign there if they wanted to, and if they had chosen to resign where they were traded from i doubt anyone in the sporting would consider it cheating.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xerofs
I cant really see how it can be classified as cheating... if you have money to buy players you can do it anytime, and if an owner knows that they are getting a player for only the playoff push then I don't see the problem with it.

even though MLB players or NHL players dont often sign back to the teams they left in the trade, they do have that choice and they could sign there if they wanted to, and if they had chosen to resign where they were traded from i doubt anyone in the sporting would consider it cheating.



Because it is using an advantage of having outside cash to create more of your own players to trade off each season, and bring back. An owner who can't afford to build 10 players for his own team and has to recruit them all in doesn't have the option of trading them off for part of a season knowing they will sign back with their team the next. It is not the team that is getting the rent a player that is being cheated, it is the other teams in the league the rent a players are coming from that are being cheated.

MLB, NHL, etc. have a very small number of teams. If a player were traded once, came back to the team he was traded for and signed another 1 year deal, what team in their right mind would trade for that player the following season? GLB has 1000s of teams, and free agents and it is easier to get a temporary fix until you can find a full time replacement. Sure you can find owners willing to make the deal but you are using a tactic that is not available to all of your competition, which therefore makes it an unfair practice.
 
Polished Rock
offline
Link
 
It's not in the spirit of "the game". It becomes who can, and will, manipulate those things on the fringe.
 
ThirdFingerUp
offline
Link
 
It should be a very heavy penalty but allowed
 
xerofs
offline
Link
 
^^^ points well taken (Rage)
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
I think it is unethical, but I also don't see how it could be regulated.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I liked the idea of a bigger chemistry hit if they went back to the other team withing X days, TBD.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
I think it is unethical, but I also don't see how it could be regulated.


Only allow a player to be traded from a team 1 time in their career. If you create a player and trade him off your team once fine. If you later feel you need to bring him back, or even if you were renting him out once, OK (I don't agree with it, but I could live with it, and there are a lot more reasons other than renting where this could occur.) But after that, you must either keep the player on your team or release him.
 
noiddodge
offline
Link
 
Or set the game up so that a "released" player cannot rejoin a previous team for 1/2 season......Freaking mercenaries
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
People want to regulate the heck out of this game. Collusion and gutting are the old real issues I wish Bort would clamp down on. Otherwise he needs to be fixing the mechanics and increasing the control we have over the tactics. Rental players and owners who field their own teams are always complained about, and I don't see the real issue with either.

Some of these problems will start to solve themselves as GLB matures. By season 6 you're going to find that teams that haven't been operating intelligently or haven't won or hosted playoff games can no longer afford the contract demands their level 32 players have for equipment upgrades at $800K/player. Part of the problem we have is that expansion is still pulling high level players out of leagues like this one. As the game matures I expect that we'll start to see more differentiation between Pro and AAA teams compared to A and BBB teams.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.