User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
brookjacoby5
offline
Link
 
One more ranking left after this one, so make the interleague play count. Let's see how the top 8 from each conference fairs against each other.

1.) San Juan Ridgerunners (15-0)
2.) KrAzY MoNKeYs (14-1)
3.) Brazil Cubs (13-2)
4.) Belo Horizonte Miners (13-2)
5.) Rio Revoluccion (14-1)
6.) Manus Thunder (13-2)
7.) Cleveland DawgPound (12-3)
8.) San Cristobal 49'ers (10-5)
9.) USAORG Cartel (9-6)
10.) Peru Deacons (12-3)
11.) Cuiaba Arsenal (12-3)
12.) Camelot Knights (11-4)
 
aprjem
offline
Link
 
Rio dropped to 5th???
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Peru, Cuiaba, and Camelot are behind a 9-6 Cartel team? They're a decent team, sure, but... huh? All six of their losses come against teams with winning records, that are posted above them in the power rankings. But I'm sorry, a six loss team does not belong above a three loss team IMHO. I guess that inter-league matchup between them and Arsenal will be pretty interesting, no?

I have Arsenal winning it 27-10.
 
brookjacoby5
offline
Link
 
Yep, the Arsenal vs. Cartel game will tell us how bad these rankings really are.

Are you willing to admit these rankings aren't so bad if Cartel wins?
 
Ramius
offline
Link
 
No surprise here. Heavily biased against the alpha conference.
 
brookjacoby5
offline
Link
 
Well how about the 6 seeds in each conference matching off....

Machu Picchu Bulldogs vs. San Cristobal 49'ers
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brookjacoby5
Yep, the Arsenal vs. Cartel game will tell us how bad these rankings really are.

Are you willing to admit these rankings aren't so bad if Cartel wins?


I will admit I was wrong about this particular set of rankings, sure! I've got no problem with that.
If Arsenal wins, will you admit that you're HEAVILY slanted towards Alpha?
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
That #6 seed pairing... hm, I don't know. I think I'll actually take the 49'ers in that contest. But it may be closer than you think. I'll go 49'ers 20 Machu Picchu 14
 
brookjacoby5
offline
Link
 
I have always admitted that my rankings favor Zeta.
It is pretty obvious to see in the rankings.
I know nobody in Alpha would dispute that.
You could call it bias if you want, but these are how I honestly see the teams stacking up. If I were truly biased I would just put my team at the top every week
I will admit my rankings have an unfounded favoritism if Arsenal wins.
 
rotharek
offline
Link
 
rofl we hold our own against a higher level 1# team and the game kind of proved how evenly matched we are yet that drops us to 5? Seriously, these rankings make no sense.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Very solid rankings, good job brookjacoby5.
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
There is no such thing as an "unbiased" opinion or an "unbiased" set of rankings. If you have researched or studied a subject, you will inherently become involved in the subject, create a bias, and form an opinion. Either you blindly pick teams or you choose based on some form of bias. To say that BJ is creating a biased ranking is patently obvious, seeing how every intelligent ranking ever made contains bias one way or another.

 
rotharek
offline
Link
 
I don't care about the bias but I just ask for things to make a bit more sense. I don't know if he watched the game we had against the Ridgerunners, but it was an even match that could have gone either way. I mean, 1 flip of the coin would have had us winning that game by 3. So it pretty much proved we're just about even with the ridgerunners but for some reason he felt the outcome of that game made us drop to 5th? It's like he didn't even watch the game.
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
You're right rotharek, but things at the top are so close that it would be much easier to just say 1(a), 1(b), 1(c), 1(d) and 1(e) for the top 5 teams in the league. Kudos to BJ for posting his rankings and taking the flak. This will all be settled in the next 12 days or so, but the rankings are always fun to look at.
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Oh, absolutely, kudos to brookjacoby for putting this out there. It's a brave opinion and I respect him for posting it. Harden, I understand your point about there being an inherent bias in any ranking, my point is that it is an incorrect bias.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.