User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > #1 CB lined up against #WR...and #2 CB lined up against #1 WR
Page:
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
This post under suggestions made it seem like this may be a bug.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=565646

My #1 CB was in the game. He lined up against the #2 WR. My #2 CB lined up against the #1 WR. Shouldn't the #1 CB lined up against the #1 WR?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
The players line up where you tell them to. If you tell your #2 CB to line up on the left, he's gonna line up on the left.

The other team probably scouted your team, figured out which side of the field your #2 CB would be playing on, and lined up their #1 WR to be on the same side of the field.

You could've done the same thing: scouted them to see where their #1 WR was and then flipped your CBs around to make sure your top CB was covering their top WR.

Not a bug. Working as intended.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
The players line up where you tell them to. If you tell your #2 CB to line up on the left, he's gonna line up on the left.

The other team probably scouted your team, figured out which side of the field your #2 CB would be playing on, and lined up their #1 WR to be on the same side of the field.

You could've done the same thing: scouted them to see where their #1 WR was and then flipped your CBs around to make sure your top CB was covering their top WR.

Not a bug. Working as intended.


How do you tell your #1 CB (in depth chart) to be on the left or right? HOw do you tell your #1 WR (in depth chart) to be on the right or left?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Okay... I don't own a team. You do. How is it that I know this is possible and you don't?

Sounds like you need to research game mechanics a bit more.
 
MoneyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
The players line up where you tell them to. If you tell your #2 CB to line up on the left, he's gonna line up on the left.

The other team probably scouted your team, figured out which side of the field your #2 CB would be playing on, and lined up their #1 WR to be on the same side of the field.

You could've done the same thing: scouted them to see where their #1 WR was and then flipped your CBs around to make sure your top CB was covering their top WR.

Not a bug. Working as intended.


Ummm....no...that's not how it works. The OP is right, the #1 CB lines up against the #2 WR.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Okay... I don't own a team. You do. How is it that I know this is possible and you don't?

Sounds like you need to research game mechanics a bit more.


Does anyone see a certain amount of irony in his statements?

He may be partially correct though. The other team could have scouted you and flipped their receivers so their #1 was covered by your #2, and vice versa.

However, I've been a team owner (relatively successful team) for two seasons, and if there is a setting in the tactics window that allows you to select the side of the field for a WR or a CB, then you are playing a different game than I am.

PinTBC
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MoneyMan
Ummm....no...that's not how it works. The OP is right, the #1 CB lines up against the #2 WR.


I beg to differ. I've seen the DCs on my teams shuffle CBs and WRs around to try to create mismatches before.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Originally posted by MoneyMan

Ummm....no...that's not how it works. The OP is right, the #1 CB lines up against the #2 WR.


I beg to differ. I've seen the DCs on my teams shuffle CBs and WRs around to try to create mismatches before.


BY CHANGING THE DEPTH CHART JACKASS!

My point was that the #1 in the depth chart WR matched up against the #2 in the depth chart WR. To make mismatches you move players in the depth chart.

Maybe a suggestion should be that idiot jackasses cannot reply in the Bug forum.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Novus

Okay... I don't own a team. You do. How is it that I know this is possible and you don't?

Sounds like you need to research game mechanics a bit more.


Does anyone see a certain amount of irony in his statements?

He may be partially correct though. The other team could have scouted you and flipped their receivers so their #1 was covered by your #2, and vice versa.

However, I've been a team owner (relatively successful team) for two seasons, and if there is a setting in the tactics window that allows you to select the side of the field for a WR or a CB, then you are playing a different game than I am.

PinTBC


I am posting completely on depth chart settings. Their #1 listed in the depth chart WR lined up against my #2 in the depth chart CB, while my #1 in the depth chart CB lined up against their #2 in depth chart WR.
 
catspaw27
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Okay... I don't own a team. You do. How is it that I know this is possible and you don't?

Sounds like you need to research game mechanics a bit more.


Sounds like you need to get a clue and only comment on things you are 100% sure of. Whether I like joemalaka or not, he knows how to game plan and set tactics.

There is no option to tell ANY player where to line up. You cannot dictate where your #1 CB, WR or TE lines up. Not now, and not in the advanced Offensive AI.

The only options are to tell the AI who is #1 or #2 at CB or WR. And you are right, you can change the depth chart before game time as a cat-and-mouse game. More often than not, it's the #3 that's more important.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by catspaw27
Originally posted by Novus

Okay... I don't own a team. You do. How is it that I know this is possible and you don't?

Sounds like you need to research game mechanics a bit more.


Sounds like you need to get a clue and only comment on things you are 100% sure of. Whether I like joemalaka or not, he knows how to game plan and set tactics.

There is no option to tell ANY player where to line up. You cannot dictate where your #1 CB, WR or TE lines up. Not now, and not in the advanced Offensive AI.

The only options are to tell the AI who is #1 or #2 at CB or WR. And you are right, you can change the depth chart before game time as a cat-and-mouse game. More often than not, it's the #3 that's more important.


See we can get along after all. LOL! What were we upset about anyways?

Now back on track. Do others agree this is a bug? Should the #1 WR line up against the #2 CB and the #1 CB line up against the #2 WR?
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joemalaka

I am posting completely on depth chart settings. Their #1 listed in the depth chart WR lined up against my #2 in the depth chart CB, while my #1 in the depth chart CB lined up against their #2 in depth chart WR.


Not doubting you are using the depth chart settings.

I have though seen a couple teams that change their charts as late as they can before a game and then as soon as the game completes so they can keep some tactic or another secret.

Other than something like that, I have no explanation.

PinTBC

 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by joemalaka


I am posting completely on depth chart settings. Their #1 listed in the depth chart WR lined up against my #2 in the depth chart CB, while my #1 in the depth chart CB lined up against their #2 in depth chart WR.


Not doubting you are using the depth chart settings.

I have though seen a couple teams that change their charts as late as they can before a game and then as soon as the game completes so they can keep some tactic or another secret.

Other than something like that, I have no explanation.

PinTBC



But if you look at the play their #1 listed WR goes against the #2 listed CB. So right there it tells you their depth chart listing.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10482006

 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
NO, this is a bug. I thought the same thing before. That the team was playing a cat and mouse game. But I've faced even the worse teams that never change their depth chart. Yet still my #2 CB is matched up against their #1 WR. I'm the DC on my team and the owner agreed, but we only tracked about half a game in 4 separate games. The games ranged from a top tier team down to the bottom of the barrel. In all cases, the WR listed first on my opponent's depth chart was lined up across from the CB listed 2nd on my depth chart. I think he's correct.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Not a bug. It's a depth chart setting. If you want your best CB covering their #1 WR, move him to #2 on your depth chart. Problem solved.

I just don't understand the need for #1 to matchup against #1 when you can acheive the same thing by learning the depth charts and how to create the mismatches. Most people already know that #1 WR faces #2 CB and vice versa, so if everyone knows this (or can figure this out with minimal scouting), not sure why a change would need to be made.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.