User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Shouldn't #1 CB line up against #1 WR?
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
I think the engine needs to be updated to match up players better. Look at the play below. #2 CB went against the #1 WR. Shouldn't my #1 CB go against their #1 WR (using the depth chart)?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10482006
 
Thechosen3
offline
Link
 
i think so +1
 
naraic
offline
Link
 
Lets presume there is 5 CBs on the depth chart

if #1 CB is tired and #4 and #5 CB is tired then #2 will behave like #1CB and #1 will take the last CB spot in the field in a nickle formation and behave like the #3CB for that play
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by naraic
Lets presume there is 5 CBs on the depth chart

if #1 CB is tired and #4 and #5 CB is tired then #2 will behave like #1CB and #1 will take the last CB spot in the field in a nickle formation and behave like the #3CB for that play


But that didn't happen in this game.

My #1 CB in the depth chart was in the game. Look at the Offense and Defense players on that play. My #1 listed CB was on the other side.

All I am saying is the engine should go by the depth chart we set.
 
naraic
offline
Link
 
Please pay attention,

say your energy settings are sub out at 70

say this is the energy of each player on the CB depth chart
CB1 65
CB2 71
CB3 80
CB4 65
CB5 60

Its nickle formation and since CB1 has too low energy CB2 plays at the CB1 spot
CB2 plays at the CB2 slot
Since no one on the depth chart is eligible for CB3 due to energy then the AI picks the best person CB1 who was tired hauls ass and gets on the field, because he when no one on the depth chart is eligible to play the AI picks the best pass defender available and puts in nickle
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
naraic hits it on the head.

I'm sure we'll see future depth charts that allow you to set up depth against...

the #1 WR, #2 WR, and so on.

So you could only allow your CB1 to cover the #1, maybe your CB2 and CB3 can cover the #2 WR, etc.

Just be patient. But right now, its working like it is supposed to.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by naraic
Please pay attention,

say your energy settings are sub out at 70

say this is the energy of each player on the CB depth chart
CB1 65
CB2 71
CB3 80
CB4 65
CB5 60

Its nickle formation and since CB1 has too low energy CB2 plays at the CB1 spot
CB2 plays at the CB2 slot
Since no one on the depth chart is eligible for CB3 due to energy then the AI picks the best person CB1 who was tired hauls ass and gets on the field, because he when no one on the depth chart is eligible to play the AI picks the best pass defender available and puts in nickle


Why would my #1 CB not sub-out completely if below 70 energy?

I can see your point if everyone was below energy. But I have 6 CB'ers. This was only the 2nd drive (me on D) and only 6th play on defense of the game. My #3 through #6 CB'ers would not have been below energy level. If my #1 was below energy after only 6 plays on D (only 3rd on this drive), then my other CB'ers would not have been tired.

Or am I way off base here?

Last edited Jul 10, 2008 09:49:17
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
we don't know what your sub settings are. Without knowing your energy tactics, it is really impossible to know why the CB1 was not playing against the WR1.

Actually, nevermind. This looks like a bug.

In the replay, the CB in the #1 CB slot was lined up against the WR is the WR#2 slot. Has nothing to do with sub settings.
Last edited Jul 10, 2008 09:54:03
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
we don't know what your sub settings are. Without knowing your energy tactics, it is really impossible to know why the CB1 was not playing against the WR1.

Actually, nevermind. This looks like a bug.

In the replay, the CB in the #1 CB slot was lined up against the WR is the WR#2 slot. Has nothing to do with sub settings.


Thanks. That is what I thought.

Only 6th Defensive play of the whole game. Only 3rd of this drive. Other CB'ers would have sub'ed in before moving my #1 CB down in the depth charts, as shown above.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
the time of the game doesn't even matter. Has nothing to do with that or the sub settings. The sub settings have to do with which player is in each of the "on the field" slots. If your complaint had been that your #2 CB on the depth chart was actually playing in the #1 CB slot, that would have been a sub setting issue, and we'd need more info.

But in reality, the replay shows the CB (regardless of depth chart position) in the CB#1 slot covering the WR in the WR#2 slot, which really doesn't make sense at all.
 
naraic
offline
Link
 
It could be that the WR had a 99/98 sub in setting and they were the onse scattered and the #1 WR was acting like a #2 and the #2 was acting like a #1 because of energy
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
They could have been lined up in different slots on offense. I use to run my Wr's in a 98/99 energy setting so they would get moved around alot and it caused an awefull lot of mismatches like the one above.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.