User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
As promised, the top 25. In future editions (i.e. when it's not 6am) I'll do a more detailed ranking. Maybe a playoff preview. For now, most of these are self-explanatory.

1. Springfield Atoms
2. Halifax Hellions
3. North Delta Grizzlies
4. Jetnation Dream Team
5. Montreal GSP's
6. London Angels
7. Windsor Knights
8. Newfoundland Thrashers
9. Crotch Lake Prairie Oysters
10. Thunder Bay Blue Jays
11. Scotstown Highlanders
12. Langley Lightning
13. Pacific Pedobears
14. Clemson Tigers
15. Renegade Nation
16. Vancouver Thunderbirds
17. North Chicago Maulers
18. Ottawa Bears
19. Nanaimo 9ers
20. Fort St. John Time Bandits
21. Charlottetown Cobras
22. Montreal Mean Machine
23. Toronto Blitz
24. Niagara Slugs
25. Moose Jaw Marauders/Denver Demons (play-in game)

Now go ahead and argue over which teams you're better than that I ranked ahead of you. I'll start.

"The Angels could beat at least 3 or 4 of the top 5 teams."

*edit: Swapped Scotstown and Thunder Bay, since Thunder Bay beat Scotstown.
Moved Pedobears ahead of Clemson
Last edited Jul 9, 2008 08:55:39
 
GuardB
offline
Link
 
Nope. Looks good. I'm worried about the 4 teams above us and about twice that below us. Anyone of them could take another out.
 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
Ok kinda confused here... Are you basing this on how great you think London is? Cause your not going by record thats for sure. Cause you have yourself ahead of Windsor for some reason when they have a better record then you and I think beat you and then you have Scotstown so low and ahead of Thunder Bay. Just does not make sense. I have no problem with Scots being ahead of us but geez be consistant with where you put teams and give a reason why you put them where you do. I think you just made these Rankings so you can see London near the top of someones rankings. I love rankings as much as anyone but take some time to really do them like some of the other ones in the past.
 
coreyls18
offline
Link
 
in all due respect, this is a dumb list and we already have a list like this...thought you were going to do something special and make an actual list with a little description...this is just a double post basically, lol.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Several teams could be flip-flopped, and some groups of three could be randomly placed.
Maybe next time I'll use a tier-system. London SHOULD be near the top of any ranking, since we're one of the best teams. I tried to make these rankings, as best as I could, based on overall team strength instead of just win-loss record. I believe that we would beat Windsor if we played today, and thus I placed us ahead of them. If there is a team ranked ahead of you that you think you could beat, today, given your current chemistry, players, etc. then make a case for who you would beat that's ahead of you, because I refuse to make my power rankings based on stupid things like "who beat who game 2 of the season", when so much has happened since then, including boosting, chemistry changes, player signings, trades, etc.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coreyls18
in all due respect, this is a dumb list and we already have a list like this...thought you were going to do something special and make an actual list with a little description...this is just a double post basically, lol.


Post the link to the power ranking, like this, that was composed by a human being. I'd like to see it.

Instead of acting ungrateful, why can't you say "thank you, Spear, for spending your own time composing something for everyone to look at and spark some healthy debate"? I spent almost an hour looking through individual teams to come up with these rankings. It was my first time making a power ranking, and I said at the very top that I would give more detail next time. I'm trying really hard to be nice here; my instincts are saying to cuss you out. But I'm trying to be nice.
Last edited Jul 9, 2008 07:36:42
 
coreyls18
offline
Link
 
*poot*
 
endomosis
offline
Link
 
The only qualm I would have is how the Pedobears are below Langley and Clemson when we have beaten them this season, other then that I've got no issues.
 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
Several teams could be flip-flopped, and some groups of three could be randomly placed.
Maybe next time I'll use a tier-system. London SHOULD be near the top of any ranking, since we're one of the best teams. I tried to make these rankings, as best as I could, based on overall team strength instead of just win-loss record. I believe that we would beat Windsor if we played today, and thus I placed us ahead of them. If there is a team ranked ahead of you that you think you could beat, today, given your current chemistry, players, etc. then make a case for who you would beat that's ahead of you, because I refuse to make my power rankings based on stupid things like "who beat who game 2 of the season", when so much has happened since then, including boosting, chemistry changes, player signings, trades, etc.


Well power rankings are based on what you think would happen if you played right now. I mean in any power ranking London would not be number 6 until they prove it. I mean thats like me saying that Thunder Bay should be near the top because of 4 games that we should have won but did not. I apprechiate the work that goes into doing this but do it without being super biased like Mstickball used to do.

 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by endomosis
The only qualm I would have is how the Pedobears are below Langley and Clemson when we have beaten them this season, other then that I've got no issues.


I've kind of got those 3 all in the same range, but you're probably right...I could just as easily have had the Pedobears first of that group. I'm not as familiar with the western teams as I am with the east, but I'll be sure to give you guys a better look next time.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Unspoken
Originally posted by SpearSrai

Several teams could be flip-flopped, and some groups of three could be randomly placed.
Maybe next time I'll use a tier-system. London SHOULD be near the top of any ranking, since we're one of the best teams. I tried to make these rankings, as best as I could, based on overall team strength instead of just win-loss record. I believe that we would beat Windsor if we played today, and thus I placed us ahead of them. If there is a team ranked ahead of you that you think you could beat, today, given your current chemistry, players, etc. then make a case for who you would beat that's ahead of you, because I refuse to make my power rankings based on stupid things like "who beat who game 2 of the season", when so much has happened since then, including boosting, chemistry changes, player signings, trades, etc.


Well power rankings are based on what you think would happen if you played right now. I mean in any power ranking London would not be number 6 until they prove it. I mean thats like me saying that Thunder Bay should be near the top because of 4 games that we should have won but did not. I apprechiate the work that goes into doing this but do it without being super biased like Mstickball used to do.



I'm trying to balance my bias with my actual logic, and I honestly believe that we have one of the best teams in the league. We've won 6 games in a row, and have a chance to cement ourselves at the top tomorrow against Jetnation. Why should I penalize our team, just because I'm the one doing the power ranking? It's not like I said we're #2 or #3. I think that we would beat all the teams below us, as of right now, and I think that come playoff time we could possibly beat the teams above us also. Instead of worrying about how good I think London is, you should try to make a case for why your own team should be higher.
 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
I dont think we should be higher. We have 5 losses but we have beaten two teams that are above us in your ranking and both of those teams only have one more win then us. Plus you have Jetnation to play still which is a tough game. We also have a very tough game against Montreal still as well. Should be a interesting race down the streatch.
 
JayKwaz
offline
Link
 
since its almost the end of JetNation according to some Spear, you should flip flop my team and yours.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
I moved you ahead of Scotstown before you posted, actually. That was an oversight. I consider your teams comparable, but you should be ahead of them since you beat them.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JayKwaz
since its almost the end of JetNation according to some Spear, you should flip flop my team and yours.


Not until after tomorrow's game, lol. I'm not THAT biased.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.