User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Farm system master thread (a bit long)
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I put this idea out there and so did thunderdoozer and we both received positive feedback, overall. Farm teams may well happen one day. This is my attempt to put the finishing touches on this and incorporate all of the earlier suggestions.

I will edit this first post with new ideas/potential problems as they come up.

The way I see it, every idea needs to address 5 major issues:

1) In-game finances
2) Administrative feasibility and ROI
3) Player satisfaction
4) Owner satisfaction
5) Parity


With that said, here it goes...

The introduction of these teams will be announced one full season before it goes into effect, giving owners the chance to get their affairs in order before this massive change hits. The price to own a team will increase by 80%, but you also get a farm team in the deal. Owners can appoint existing GM(s) to run the farm team or run it themselves. These GMs would be able to transfer flex points to pay for the whole team or part of the team (and no more...I am aware that the transferring of flex points is highly frowned upon).

Every pro team at every level has a farm team. The farm league will mirror the pro-league exactly at the start. There will be no relegation/promotion in the farm league, however (at some point this may need to be addressed, as to keep younger players happy in their time in the farm league).

You can move guys up and down with no penalty and no need for a new contract (chemistry-wise, financially, etc.). You could pull a guy up for one game, then send him back down. You just cannot go over the roster limit.

There would be a pro and farm D-League. There will be a level limit on these leagues (as is currently in place, only the pro D-League would have a bumped up level cap and only be available after 2 seasons of play).

If a player does not want to stick with a team and wants to risk entering free agency, it is a very real possibility that he ends up in the pro D-League for a while. This would encourage team loyalty, but not limit the player from switching teams (as it would still be likely he or she could find a good "home").

The money would be pooled between the two teams. This would encourage owners to develop their farm teams/stadiums. Farm teams, however, would only make about 50% that of pro teams.

The five major issues

1) In-game finances
The rich would get richer. However, teams would now be looking at putting all of their money into their pro-team and buying talent, or spending money on developing a good farm team to recruit from.

2) Administrative feasibility and ROI This would mean a huge windfall without having to do an insane amount of work. It would not be easy, but keep in mind that this means an immediate influx of cash and more satisfied new customers that will potentially spend more time/money here. The D-Leagues are a bad experience and do not reflect this game in a positive light.

3) Player satisfaction This idea is more out of dissatisfaction with the D-Leagues. I would rather play on a human team any day. I would pay my dues and wait for the shot to move up to the pros (all while staying competitive and interacting with actual humans that have the power to make game changes).

4) Owner satisfaction Well, I am not an owner. I would imagine, however, that it would be better (scouting-wise) to have an idea of how a player is progressing than to enter a hectic free-agent market every year. It also adds a bit of depth to your ownership skills.

5) Parity It might just be me, but I think that I would rather join the farm team of a somewhat worse team that does have promise and a quality owner AND a more realistic chance to start, than join a dominant team and spend my time rotting in the farm league. Maybe worse teams would have the edge in recruiting players.
 
SkierLegend
offline
Link
 
Here is my constructive criticism, great job though.

First of all, I think team buying prices should go up way more than 80%. I would go as far as to say that they should be 500% of what they are now, possibly more. A $35 price tag would ensure (or at the very least encourage) Owner commitment and keep the ridiculous waiting list down so only those who really want a team get one.

I think that D league players should be accustomed to smaller contracts. If they are being pulled up for a game or two, they can talk to their Owner about a bonus, but the contract should stay the same. However, if they are being brought up for a good lump of time, I think the contract should have to be re-negotiated to a more pro-worthy one. This would keep players on the D League from having more money than they could ever need and keep the team's bank more stable.

I agree with the rest of what you said. The only problem I see is that once the lower end of the pro level players reach level 60, that leaves a huge gap for a D league team to fill. The only solution I see is adding another tier of farm teams with a lower level cap to try and keep the levels somewhat similar and get playing time for the new players. I'm sure there is a better solution, but it eludes me.

There should probably be some sort of advantage to a successful farm team as well, to keep Owners from neglecting them.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.