User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Farm system revisited
Page:
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
While this has been brought up, I think it wouldn't be the worst thing in the world to revisit the whole idea of an official farm team for each team.

Why I think this is a decent idea...

#1) Parity
- If each team had a farm team, we would not have to add as many new leagues every season and worry about parity being an impossibility (or taking a very, very long time). If we let the existing leagues stablize before adding new teams, we would be doing this league a service. For example, most players would come out of the D-leagues and sign with a farm team. Instead of players always wanting to go to the best team (system), players would now be more inclined to sign with a farm team that isn't drastically over-leveled so that they would be more likely to move up in a shorter time-frame. It might also help remove these unofficial farm teams from messing with league parity.

#2) The D-leagues could be phased out - As Bort mentioned, a new idea out there is to get rid of the D-league. This league is frought with complaints and issues that will probably be put second to the issues associated with game play/strategy of the real leagues.

#3) Add more depth to talent scouting/player development - While there will usually be a large free-agent market after every season no matter what, owners that ignore their subsidiary would have to pay more to do so. I envision that more new players would sign on to multi-year deals as part of a farm team (the owners would demand this). After a couple of seasons, the owner would get a better idea of how this player is being built, if they will fit into their system, and whether or not they boost. If things are not working out, they can look for a trade or release them. Scouting becomes more important as it would be cheaper to move a player up from the farm team on their existing contract than to go after a free agent.

#4) More revenue - Double the amount of teams, maybe implement this slowly. Perhaps offer these teams at a slight discount and offer a team owner the right to appoint a GM or trusted friend to run this team. If they do not do so or cannot find anyone in a certain time frame, it would go to the waiting list.

Go ahead. Fire away. There are always holes in suggestions and I am just asking for honest input. I am sure there are a lot of problems with this being implemented. I know rolling this out would be a huge deal and result in more teams than there are players, but this would be worked out after a few seasons (seeing as how fast this game is growing).
Last edited Jul 6, 2008 19:55:01
 
Mavfatha
offline
Link
 
This is really a good idea my players finally got past the d-league but now they are lowly backups on human owned teams having a kind of intermediate place to play and grow and maybe learn more would be great.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
I've already made my team into a "human development team" because there is no chance i'll ever be able to compete in the league i'm in.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I know that I would rather place my newly-created player on a human-owned farm team than in the GD-league. It sucks down there.
 
Rick James18
offline
Link
 
I like it, I haven't heard of a better solution to speed up parity development, and I think that's a big issue.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Yep have Farm system with its own league seperate. No promotion/relegation. I really could support this idea. It is what farm teams are supposed to be.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Hurray! Support from not only a Mod, but bigtisme! I will count my blessings.

Maybe I could contribute to this game, aside from responding to posts that violate the "never gonna happen" restrictions.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
There might need to be some more to this suggestion. There has to be a way to gurantee playing time for everyone. Maybe make it so people have to be on the DC somewhere. And subs are still 98/99 or something.

Something to keep people from rotting on the bench. A solid human solution would be a great thing to see imho.
 
Alex44
offline
Link
 
We will always need the D-Leagues.

A level one guy coming in not knowing anyone is going to have a hell of a time finding a human team even if they have a farm league.

I do love the idea of a farm league, but I think the D-Leagues play an important part for new players.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Alex44
We will always need the D-Leagues.

A level one guy coming in not knowing anyone is going to have a hell of a time finding a human team even if they have a farm league.

I do love the idea of a farm league, but I think the D-Leagues play an important part for new players.


Granted. I am no expert on systems thinking and I have no idea what the forecsting tells about the influx of players. Most would want to play on a human team. If the GD-league is ALL CPU players, so be it. Eventually, the league will fill out and the GD-league will become necessary. It would be great if this league was treated as an emergency plan for a lack of human-owned teams, rather than the default starting place for new players.
 
Alex44
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Alex44

We will always need the D-Leagues.

A level one guy coming in not knowing anyone is going to have a hell of a time finding a human team even if they have a farm league.

I do love the idea of a farm league, but I think the D-Leagues play an important part for new players.


Granted. I am no expert on systems thinking and I have no idea what the forecsting tells about the influx of players. Most would want to play on a human team. If the GD-league is ALL CPU players, so be it. Eventually, the league will fill out and the GD-league will become necessary. It would be great if this league was treated as an emergency plan for a lack of human-owned teams, rather than the default starting place for new players.


I think it would be a great option for decreasing the number of players within the D-Leagues, which would make it easier for guys to get playing time and leave those leagues faster.

I also think it would be great to develope your own talent instead of having to sign free agents every year.

One problem I see are contracts. You would have to be able to call guys up or send them down. If you couldn't and just signed guys to one year deals they could use you and bolt.

I have an idea to add in that respect:

1) Add no send down clauses in contracts. That way your guy couldnt get sent down simply because the owner didn't like you.

2) Have double contracts for the farm league players. Like for example they have a farm salary of 10k, but a call up salary of 40k. When called up their salary switches to the pro salary, and even if they are sent down the salary remains.

I think you have a really great idea here, but it would have to be really planned out and well done.

 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
It would absolutely have to be well planned out. Owners would have to jump on board and sign level 1 players to long-term deals. This could result in some pissed off nOObies, but if your contract rules were enforced, it would work out from a player's perspective.

I just F'in hate the D-leagues...continually turning down offers and waiting so that I can find a team where I am at least second string FB.
 
Satans_Pimp
offline
Link
 
I love the idea..
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
There needs to still be some D leagues so every newbie who starts the game has a contract the minute they create a player. But this idea is still something i can support. I would rather sign with a human farm team with my new players than that D leagues.

I also think the call up salary would be a good addition as well.
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
Isn't this the same thing as humans controlling the d-league teams? why dont we just do that..

humans could buy d-league teams and set depth charts there and do the finances and everything just like a regular team, that way we wouldnt have to waste time creating new teams and getting rid of the d-leagues
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.