User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Automatically Adjust In-Game Strategy...
Page:
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
to What's Working and away from What's Not Working?

NO

I need to gripe with this, I set 0% short passes, I set 0% pass to the HB, I set 0% run up the middle.

And every game it continues to do each of these resulting in TFL's, or inconsequential gains.

Why can't it just do what I ask?

The last game despite having 0% short passing set, the AI still chose to throw near 50% of the ball short.

Long 2 for 31.5
Medium 6 for 59.5
Short 7 for 31.5 (46%)

HB's targeted 6 times in total, for a total of 2.5yrds.

I don't mind losing, but when I lose and it seems its because my commands are being ignored I hate it. Automatically adjust to what works by all means, but not to the things that never ever work!

/rant
 
vtech9
offline
Link
 
ditto
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
I doubt your reading abilities. It clearly says on the tactics page that %s will not be exact.

not a bug. not a bug. not a bug.
 
vtech9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
I doubt your reading abilities. It clearly says on the tactics page that %s will not be exact.

not a bug. not a bug. not a bug.


I doubt your reading abilities. He didn't mention it being a bug anywhere in his post. He said he wanted to gripe about it. Whether or not he posted it in the right forum is another question, but to attack his reading ability is childish.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I'm not going to argue about runs up the middle, but I assume there are times in a game where a run up the middle is called for.

Short passes are a result of check downs or pressure on the QB, and will happen at times regardless of your settings b/c you can't predict exactly what will happen in the game.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vtech9
Originally posted by jeffgarcia

I doubt your reading abilities. It clearly says on the tactics page that %s will not be exact.

not a bug. not a bug. not a bug.


I doubt your reading abilities. He didn't mention it being a bug anywhere in his post. He said he wanted to gripe about it. Whether or not he posted it in the right forum is another question, but to attack his reading ability is childish.


This is the bug forum. He posted it here. So I'm telling him, it is not a bug.
 
Sulfadias
offline
Link
 
I had runs set for 70% inside last week and I ran it 19 times outside, 3 times inside.... with auto adjust off.



This week.. I had it set for 65% run... with auto adjust off.


Score is 13-13 at half time. Nice balanced offense.

1st drive of 3rd quarter 3 passes and out. ???

Other team scores a TD.

2nd drive of 3rd quarter 3 passes and out. ???

Other teams scores a FG.

1st drive of 4rd quarter 1 run and 2 passes then punt.

Other team scores a TD.

Now trailing by 17 points we abandon the run completely and pass pass pass.


Something is fundamentally wrong with this sim. When we are set for 65% run, there is NO reason why we should have passed it 6 times in our 1st two drives of the 2nd half with the score tied.

That never even gave our offense a chance to get moving by deviating from the game plan, then the other team scores twice and we scrap the game plan entirely.

Grr very frustrating.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sulfadias0
I had runs set for 70% inside last week and I ran it 19 times outside, 3 times inside.... with auto adjust off.



This week.. I had it set for 65% run... with auto adjust off.


Score is 13-13 at half time. Nice balanced offense.

1st drive of 3rd quarter 3 passes and out. ???

Other team scores a TD.

2nd drive of 3rd quarter 3 passes and out. ???

Other teams scores a FG.

1st drive of 4rd quarter 1 run and 2 passes then punt.

Other team scores a TD.

Now trailing by 17 points we abandon the run completely and pass pass pass.


Something is fundamentally wrong with this sim. When we are set for 65% run, there is NO reason why we should have passed it 6 times in our 1st two drives of the 2nd half with the score tied.

That never even gave our offense a chance to get moving by deviating from the game plan, then the other team scores twice and we scrap the game plan entirely.

Grr very frustrating.


If you took any time to read about the new AI coming, you'd realize that there will be a checkbox that will allow you to force the SIM to use your tactics at all times (with the subtext: use with caution, and a warning message) - so when you do that and still lose, please don't post another Bug.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vtech9
Originally posted by jeffgarcia

I doubt your reading abilities. It clearly says on the tactics page that %s will not be exact.

not a bug. not a bug. not a bug.


I doubt your reading abilities. He didn't mention it being a bug anywhere in his post. He said he wanted to gripe about it. Whether or not he posted it in the right forum is another question, but to attack his reading ability is childish.


Bug forum-
Report bugs here. Warning: repeated posts about something that is not a bug may get you a warning.

Ergo, he must have thought it was a bug. Or he just doesn't care about the guidelines, in which case, fuck him.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Sulfadias0

I had runs set for 70% inside last week and I ran it 19 times outside, 3 times inside.... with auto adjust off.



This week.. I had it set for 65% run... with auto adjust off.


Score is 13-13 at half time. Nice balanced offense.

1st drive of 3rd quarter 3 passes and out. ???

Other team scores a TD.

2nd drive of 3rd quarter 3 passes and out. ???

Other teams scores a FG.

1st drive of 4rd quarter 1 run and 2 passes then punt.

Other team scores a TD.

Now trailing by 17 points we abandon the run completely and pass pass pass.


Something is fundamentally wrong with this sim. When we are set for 65% run, there is NO reason why we should have passed it 6 times in our 1st two drives of the 2nd half with the score tied.

That never even gave our offense a chance to get moving by deviating from the game plan, then the other team scores twice and we scrap the game plan entirely.

Grr very frustrating.


If you took any time to read about the new AI coming, you'd realize that there will be a checkbox that will allow you to force the SIM to use your tactics at all times (with the subtext: use with caution, and a warning message) - so when you do that and still lose, please don't post another Bug.


To me this new "checkbox" is a half-aced solution to the problem. So now if you want to eliminate HB/FB passing completely you will no longer be allowed to have the computer take over and run the ball to run out the clock with the lead or pass the ball to save time to make a comeback.

To those who say short passes in these situations are a result of good coverage down field or qb pressure... have you ever heard of the qb throwing the ball away. Im sure those who are complaining about this would rather their qb throw the ball away and waste the down or even force the ball to a wr/te than attempt to dump off to the hb. I can understand the discrepancies between set and actual percentages, but 0% should mean absolutely under no conditions and result in 0.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
in case of passes, 0% just means that the HB isn't the first option. As long as he is running a route, he is an option, just not the first option.

As for the advanced AI, you can set it, I believe (have to go back and check) to run exclusively when leading by X points with X time remaining in the game. And the same goes for passing to catch up. So no, you don't lose those options as long as you fill out your advanced tactics in full, you'll be fine using that checkbox and having the SIM follow your tactics.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
i happen to agree with you in regards to rushes - a 0% fullback rush means I don't want him rushing the ball - so far, I've never had the FB rush the ball for me when I've set it at 0%, always gives it to the HB, so not sure why others have this issue.
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by Sulfadias0


I had runs set for 70% inside last week and I ran it 19 times outside, 3 times inside.... with auto adjust off.



This week.. I had it set for 65% run... with auto adjust off.


Score is 13-13 at half time. Nice balanced offense.

1st drive of 3rd quarter 3 passes and out. ???

Other team scores a TD.

2nd drive of 3rd quarter 3 passes and out. ???

Other teams scores a FG.

1st drive of 4rd quarter 1 run and 2 passes then punt.

Other team scores a TD.

Now trailing by 17 points we abandon the run completely and pass pass pass.


Something is fundamentally wrong with this sim. When we are set for 65% run, there is NO reason why we should have passed it 6 times in our 1st two drives of the 2nd half with the score tied.

That never even gave our offense a chance to get moving by deviating from the game plan, then the other team scores twice and we scrap the game plan entirely.

Grr very frustrating.


If you took any time to read about the new AI coming, you'd realize that there will be a checkbox that will allow you to force the SIM to use your tactics at all times (with the subtext: use with caution, and a warning message) - so when you do that and still lose, please don't post another Bug.


To me this new "checkbox" is a half-aced solution to the problem. So now if you want to eliminate HB/FB passing completely you will no longer be allowed to have the computer take over and run the ball to run out the clock with the lead or pass the ball to save time to make a comeback.

To those who say short passes in these situations are a result of good coverage down field or qb pressure... have you ever heard of the qb throwing the ball away. Im sure those who are complaining about this would rather their qb throw the ball away and waste the down or even force the ball to a wr/te than attempt to dump off to the hb. I can understand the discrepancies between set and actual percentages, but 0% should mean absolutely under no conditions and result in 0.


you can specifically set this "half-assed checkbox" to run out the clock when you are up by a set amount of points. You also can tell it when you are down by X amount to go into the pass happy offense.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
in case of passes, 0% just means that the HB isn't the first option. As long as he is running a route, he is an option, just not the first option.

I still disagree with this... if it were option based then whats the point of the percentages? Why not just list them as #1 option, #2 option, and so on then? With the percentages it means that x% of the time the HB is going to be the #1 target. Just because he is running a route should it entitle him to being an option? I say no (think of him as just a decoy). Whatever happened to the option to throw the ball away before throwing to the HB?

As far as the checkbox... oh: looks like I used a bad example as to why I feel its not the appropriate solution to the problem (dont get me wrong I am happy there is going to be a solution even if its not the best, but...). It just concerns me that there is a warning label associated with this function and that in order for teams to be able to go 0% they must take some potential unknown risk. Again, why cant 0% just be 0?
Last edited Jul 4, 2008 21:05:32
 
Link
 
The sim doesn't run or recognize "throw away" passes yet. That is not a option in the sim so if your Qb is in trouble the sims idea of a throw away pass is a check down regardless of the %'s you have set.
Your not the only one that has this problem, every team has to deal with it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.