Warrior General Games

http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/135218/1372836

Inches from a TD and the HB loses a fumble. That's the craziest defensive play I've seen yet! And it was in rookie! They followed that up with a 99 yard rushing touchdown. Hey, at least we still won!

Challenge flag!

He was clearly across the goal line.

Tick 102.5 clearly shows the ball has jettisoned BEFORE the Goal Line.

Instant Replay confirms that the ruling on the field was correct.

First Down Miami Sharks!

Originally posted by Xars
Tick 102.5 clearly shows the ball has jettisoned BEFORE the Goal Line.

Instant Replay confirms that the ruling on the field was correct.

First Down Miami Sharks!





Go Back and look at tick 100 and 101. The ball is clearly across. Then it is magically in his pants at tick 102. Freeze it at 101.5 and you will see.

Originally posted by Rob.
Go Back and look at tick 100 and 101. The ball is clearly across. Then it is magically in his pants at tick 102. Freeze it at 101.5 and you will see.

That's inconclusive. The ruling on the field stands.

/sarc

its like those 3rd and shorts where your HB clearly gets the first Down by 1 or yards but the defender knocks him so hard backwards that its suddenly a 4th and inches^^

The ruling on the field stands. The ball carrier fumbled at the 6" mark and instant replay of JSON view has validated this.

["ball","4.25","329.5","2.5","-0.95","fumble","0","1",0,0,""]]

The value is in feet so 0 is end of back of left endzone and 360 is back of right endzone with the goallines 30 and 330 respectivally.

This is the first instance where fumble activates and looking at prior ball positions, it never crosses 330.

Play JSON info is here if you want to research yourself http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/135218/1372836/JSON

JSON can suck it!
It doesn't match up visually.

This isn't a touchdown: http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/135218/1372836
But this is? http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/141246/1479882

Originally posted by Rob.
JSON can suck it!
It doesn't match up visually.

This isn't a touchdown: http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/135218/1372836
But this is? http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/141246/1479882

Using logic, he was on the ground and although that one foot is bent, in reality his foot would already been grounded when cathing the ball like that. Its because he was coming of the turn and in the running motion when the ball was thrown to him. On the first one however, he was diving and fumbled up reaching (or even before reaching) the ground, which in the NFL would not be counted as a TD. Even in Madden (and they always try to let the CPU win) it would've counted as no TD.

Originally posted by Rob.
JSON can suck it!
It doesn't match up visually.

This isn't a touchdown: http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/135218/1372836
But this is? http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/141246/1479882

Quit watching my games

Originally posted by Rob.
JSON can suck it!
It doesn't match up visually.

This isn't a touchdown: http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/135218/1372836
But this is? http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/141246/1479882

This shows that it's more about body position and less about ball position to the GLB refs.

Originally posted by Rob.
JSON can suck it!
It doesn't match up visually.

This isn't a touchdown: http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/135218/1372836
But this is? http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/141246/1479882

This is something everyone really needs to understand that the replays are at best representations, but frankly are not 100% accurate.

JSON had the ball at the GL for 3 iterations.

[
"ball",
"41.25",
"30",
"3",
"0",
"held",
"92810",
"1",
0,
0,
""
]

Originally posted by Stobie
This is something everyone really needs to understand that the replays are at best representations, but frankly are not 100% accurate.

JSON had the ball at the GL for 3 iterations.

[
"ball",
"41.25",
"30",
"3",
"0",
"held",
"92810",
"1",
0,
0,
""
]

Just makes me wonder where the ball actually is when we are watching players. A player is diving across the goal line and his arms and body are clearly across the line before getting hit, but it's a fumble. Does the ball reside in their pants?

Freeze this play at 101.5 http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/135218/1372836
The only way this is a fumble is if the ball resides in this guys pants or feet. Or if there is a delayed fumble animation.

Originally posted by Rob.
Does the ball reside in their pants?

They wear those new uniforms, with a hip pocket.

The HBs stuff the Rock into the hip pocket so when they dive towards the end zone, they fake out all the defenders with their outstretched hands.