User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Premature Field Goal Helped Cost Us the Game Tonight!
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
This is likely an AI bug (at least in my mind), note the sequence here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9162983
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9162990 -- down to the 1, 27 seconds left
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9162991

field goal kicked.

all that time left. The clock stops on the first down while the chains are moved. There was all the time in the world - even with no timeouts - to spike the ball and then take at least one shot at the end zone.

instead, our kicker shanked the kickoff, and 3 plays later we lose on a 52 yard field goal.

Maybe regardless of this we lose anyway, but this strikes me as awfully unrealistic.

Last edited Jul 2, 2008 19:36:01
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
I think the goal line offnesive AI/play calling is pretty lousy in general.

Earlier in the game on 3rd and 6 from the 9, our opponents ran the ball. LOL, as if that had ANY shot at working.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
there is no spiking of the ball yet, so the SIM played for the win vs. any chance at a turnover. If the SIM had gone for it and you'd turned it over, you'd be pissed as well I'm sure. Or if the sim had tried to run it in and you had no timeouts and you lost due to time expiring, also pissed.

So, the FG at that time, given the current abilities of the SIM, was the right call.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
there is no spiking of the ball yet, so the SIM played for the win vs. any chance at a turnover. If the SIM had gone for it and you'd turned it over, you'd be pissed as well I'm sure. Or if the sim had tried to run it in and you had no timeouts and you lost due to time expiring, also pissed.

So, the FG at that time, given the current abilities of the SIM, was the right call.


No real football team kicks a field goal to tie the game when there is time left to try winning it. Obviously you don't run it with no timeouts left. Then again, the way this awesome offensive goal line AI is, it probably would have run the ball, got stuffed, and ended the game.

 
Qunqun24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by SCACE

there is no spiking of the ball yet, so the SIM played for the win vs. any chance at a turnover. If the SIM had gone for it and you'd turned it over, you'd be pissed as well I'm sure. Or if the sim had tried to run it in and you had no timeouts and you lost due to time expiring, also pissed.

So, the FG at that time, given the current abilities of the SIM, was the right call.


No real football team kicks a field goal to tie the game when there is time left to try winning it. Obviously you don't run it with no timeouts left. Then again, the way this awesome offensive goal line AI is, it probably would have run the ball, got stuffed, and ended the game.



Yeah they do. Baltimore Ravens s. the Miami Doplphins. The Ravens were on the 3 with only a few seconds left. Instead of going for the win, they kicked the field goal. Although they did lose in the end, they played it safe
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
i don't disagree with you overall, the AI needs improvement, but without a spike the ball option, the SIM made the safe choice.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Yeah, you need to do better than "We lost" to convince people there's a bug.

You're lucky you had a shot to tie it, considering (as above) how sporadic the sim can be.
 
dv8edflip
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Qunqun24
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by SCACE


there is no spiking of the ball yet, so the SIM played for the win vs. any chance at a turnover. If the SIM had gone for it and you'd turned it over, you'd be pissed as well I'm sure. Or if the sim had tried to run it in and you had no timeouts and you lost due to time expiring, also pissed.

So, the FG at that time, given the current abilities of the SIM, was the right call.


No real football team kicks a field goal to tie the game when there is time left to try winning it. Obviously you don't run it with no timeouts left. Then again, the way this awesome offensive goal line AI is, it probably would have run the ball, got stuffed, and ended the game.



Yeah they do. Baltimore Ravens s. the Miami Doplphins. The Ravens were on the 3 with only a few seconds left. Instead of going for the win, they kicked the field goal. Although they did lose in the end, they played it safe


Have to agree here. If you got a suck ass offense but a decent kicker and awesome defense you get the tie and try to win in overtime. If your offense don't get the ball first you can at least believe your D will get it back for you so that your suck ass offense has a chance to win it.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Qunqun24
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by SCACE


there is no spiking of the ball yet, so the SIM played for the win vs. any chance at a turnover. If the SIM had gone for it and you'd turned it over, you'd be pissed as well I'm sure. Or if the sim had tried to run it in and you had no timeouts and you lost due to time expiring, also pissed.

So, the FG at that time, given the current abilities of the SIM, was the right call.


No real football team kicks a field goal to tie the game when there is time left to try winning it. Obviously you don't run it with no timeouts left. Then again, the way this awesome offensive goal line AI is, it probably would have run the ball, got stuffed, and ended the game.



Yeah they do. Baltimore Ravens s. the Miami Doplphins. The Ravens were on the 3 with only a few seconds left. Instead of going for the win, they kicked the field goal. Although they did lose in the end, they played it safe


The Ravens are a pathetic excuse for an offense, have been for their entire existence.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
every post, you just come across as bitter. Take this out of the Bugs thread and into the Whiners thread
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Yeah, you need to do better than "We lost" to convince people there's a bug.

You're lucky you had a shot to tie it, considering (as above) how sporadic the sim can be.


I'm not solely blaming it for the loss. Pay attention.

27 seconds left. That's a lifetime in this game.
Even without timeouts. A pass incompletion stops the clock.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
every post, you just come across as bitter. Take this out of the Bugs thread and into the Whiners thread


That's because I am bitter. We had a 12 yard catch down to the 1 with half a minute left, and the game folded up the tent and kicked a field goal with lots of time to spare.

In the time it took them to run the field goal team out there, it could have executed a passing play. We weren't at the 7 yard line, we were at the 1.

Next season, hopefully we have control over this in the offensive AI in this situation.
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 20:17:09
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by oldskool

Yeah, you need to do better than "We lost" to convince people there's a bug.

You're lucky you had a shot to tie it, considering (as above) how sporadic the sim can be.


I'm not solely blaming it for the loss. Pay attention.

27 seconds left. That's a lifetime in this game.
Even without timeouts. A pass incompletion stops the clock.


And an interception ends the game, or maybe noone is open, and there is currently no "throw the ball away" option for the QB, so maybe he checks down and tosses to the halfback who gets stuffed before the goalline and the game ends. The SIM made the safe choice to give you the best chance to stay in the game. Get over it, its the way it is now.

I agree things need to be changed, but everyone is dealing with the same SIM right now (Beta game) and this stuff has been discussed many times.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Fair enough. (re: everyone dealing with the same stuff). If something like this has been reported before, my mistake. I haven't been here to report bugs too often thus far.

Even if I want to go along with your interception argument, there's no reason to not run the clock down.

If the opponent takes a timeout, then again, it's a null issue, you can run a play. I just feel how this went down is - not necessarily a true bug - but an example of subpar AI that I'd like to either see improved, or given full control over in the offensive AI (if its not there already).

I'll have to check that, actually. I only focus on the defense.
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 20:20:25
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
its not so much what you posted but how you posted it

Sometimes its best to wait until the emotions die down and then post about what you think needs to be fixed w/o linking it to your loss - it will be much more accepted that way - just too many people who blame the SIM for their losses.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.