User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Promotion/Relegation Thread with Numbers...
CoachB05
offline
Link
 
I know that people are upset about promotion/relegation and stuff. I'm here to explain the current system, and what would happen if we changed the # of teams affected. I'm a math major, so I wanted to look into it. For starters, in every conference of every team, only one team (if possible) can be promoted to a higher league, and two teams (if possible) are relegated to a lower league. Those are the basics.

Now we get into details. For USA, on average 12.1% of teams move to a different league, for Canada/E. Europe/W. Europe, an average of 11.6% of teams move to a different league, and for Africa/Oceania/South America an average of 10.7% of teams move to a different league. I will get to how I got those numbers later, but these percentages are an AVERAGE. It varies much more depending on where you are at in a league structure.

In the lowest leagues of a region, only the winner of each conference in the playoffs move up a league. So that's 1/16 (6.25%). In the middle league(s), the winner moves up and the bottom 2 teams move down. That's 3/16 (18.75%). In the Pro Leagues, only the bottom two teams move down, so that leaves 2/16 (12.5%). In a sense, the middle leagues have the highest chance of moving either up or down out of all the leagues (twice as likely to move down than up). It is really hard to move out of the bottom leagues, and just hard to drop out of the Pro Leagues.

So, the second paragraph's percentages are a weighted average of the precentages of the low leagues, the middle leagues, and the high leagues. If this sounds too complicated, it's just the complete version of what is really happening. You could just as easily find out how many teams total in a region move up or down and divide that by the total number of teams. For example, 120 teams total move in USA (32 in BBB, 48 in A, 24 in AA, 12 in AAA, and 4 in Pro), but there are 992 teams (31 leagues * 32 teams).

It looks to me like any teams in the lowest leagues (whether it be BBB, A, or AA) are just screwed, and Oceania/Africa/South America REALLY get screwed because their teams are less likely to move.

I have made a suggestion before about raising the numbers to 2 up/4 down (I'm not making the suggestion here, I am just doing the math behind it here). That effective doubles the numbers that are now in place. This would mean that while almost a quarter of USA teams would move up or down, 6 out of 16 teams would be moving in A, AA, and AAA, while still only 2 out of 16 teams at the bottom league move.

Seeing as how every lowest league has more teams in it than the ones above it combined, this is a major problem. You could make the argument that half of the teams are getting screwed in relation to moving up or down. The way to answer this would be to most likely reorganize the leagues, whether that means changing the regions, losing the pyramid system entirely, or the number of teams in every conference (like moving it up to 17 from 16.) I repeat, I AM NOT making any suggestions, as the pyramid system works the way that it was planned. We might just need to fiddle with some things. I don't know where to start, so I will work on it. Thanks for your time, and I would love to hear suggestions/thoughts.
 
Link
 
Certain leagues shouldnt have people move up this season. There's teams, like the Canadian A #7 team I'm on, that have a great chance of winning it all. If they get promoted from a level capped league to a non-capped league, they'll be screwed. Ya know? The newer leagues shouldnt move up this season.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Under current system I was relegated last season and still can not compete
 
BuddyHorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
Under current system I was relegated last season and still can not compete



This is because they just stuck brand new teams in the middle of established conferences. Also we could use a dump league, or a league that they ship the gutted messes to.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
No offense, but it doesnt take a math major to do 4/32, 6/32 and 2/32 to get 12.5%, 18.75% and 6.25% team movement in the 3 types of leagues

You are combining promotion and relegation into one term "Move"

but really, every league, bar the pro league, has 6.25% of its team moving up at the end of the season, and every league, bar the bottom league, has 12.5% of its teams moving down at the end of the season.

I really don't understand the purpose of combining these two numbers to create a "movement" statistic as I don't see what it is attempting to prove. Where do you expect the last place team in the bottom league to "move" to? Should we be kicking them out of the game?
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Yeah a gutted team in a higher league is gonna plumet. My chemistry is still screwed after trying to improve to compete in my new "lower" league.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.