Thought I'd flesh this idea out since people seemed to respond well to it in the other thread. It's somewhat similar to Bort's idea in the sticky, in quickly moving gutted teams down, but avoids the problems inherent in automatically moving teams down when they are sold - specifically, if the team is sold but not gutted. It also expedites the relegation of mismanaged and poorly run teams. It would allow much more movement up and down without compromising the league structure and continuity.
This is going to be a little confusing, so bear with me.
Instead of strictly relegating the four teams with the worst records and promoting the two championship teams, a possible way to move bad teams to the bottom of the pile faster (and to solve mid-season gutting issues where a team has won enough games to remain in the league, but is clearly the worst team in the league), would be to basically take the following steps.
1. Designate the bottom two teams in each conference for relegation, they deserve to be relegated anyway.
2. Run a check of the rest of the teams against the median level of the league, and potentially relegate further teams based on this.
I'll give an example with numbers, but don't bother debating the numbers I use because it's just an example. Lets say the median league level is 20. The four bottom teams are already set to be relegated. Now, say, you make it so that any team averaging under, I don't know, 14 or 15, gets automatically relegated as well. Perhaps you could also relegate teams from 15-17 IF their record is bad enough relative to how low their levels are - so like a team with average 16 level players that went 3-13 gets relegated, while a team with average 16 level players that went 10-6 does not. Not sure what kind of equation I'd use there, but there's a way to do it.
So for the sake of this argument, lets say there are 2 teams (beyond the automatic relegations) in the western conference (lets call this a USA AA league) that qualify to be relegated, and 1 in the eastern conference. Just to make it complicated. So, they get relegated. If it's one team, which A league they go into is selected randomly. If it's 2, they get split.
3. Move extra teams up. The teams in the championship are already set to move up. But for a conference getting an extra relegated team, the second conference finalist gets moved up as well. In the (relatively unlikely) case that a conference has 3 teams qualify for relegation beyond the 2 automatic ones, one of the second round teams from the league below receiving 2 extra relegated teams would be promoted, the tiebreaker being the regular season standings.
4. (possible) - Check the newly relegated teams against the median level of their new league. If they still qualify for relegation, send them down another level.
Please feel free to offer criticism and (especially) tweaks and suggestions, and I will update this post as time goes on.
This is going to be a little confusing, so bear with me.
Instead of strictly relegating the four teams with the worst records and promoting the two championship teams, a possible way to move bad teams to the bottom of the pile faster (and to solve mid-season gutting issues where a team has won enough games to remain in the league, but is clearly the worst team in the league), would be to basically take the following steps.
1. Designate the bottom two teams in each conference for relegation, they deserve to be relegated anyway.
2. Run a check of the rest of the teams against the median level of the league, and potentially relegate further teams based on this.
I'll give an example with numbers, but don't bother debating the numbers I use because it's just an example. Lets say the median league level is 20. The four bottom teams are already set to be relegated. Now, say, you make it so that any team averaging under, I don't know, 14 or 15, gets automatically relegated as well. Perhaps you could also relegate teams from 15-17 IF their record is bad enough relative to how low their levels are - so like a team with average 16 level players that went 3-13 gets relegated, while a team with average 16 level players that went 10-6 does not. Not sure what kind of equation I'd use there, but there's a way to do it.
So for the sake of this argument, lets say there are 2 teams (beyond the automatic relegations) in the western conference (lets call this a USA AA league) that qualify to be relegated, and 1 in the eastern conference. Just to make it complicated. So, they get relegated. If it's one team, which A league they go into is selected randomly. If it's 2, they get split.
3. Move extra teams up. The teams in the championship are already set to move up. But for a conference getting an extra relegated team, the second conference finalist gets moved up as well. In the (relatively unlikely) case that a conference has 3 teams qualify for relegation beyond the 2 automatic ones, one of the second round teams from the league below receiving 2 extra relegated teams would be promoted, the tiebreaker being the regular season standings.
4. (possible) - Check the newly relegated teams against the median level of their new league. If they still qualify for relegation, send them down another level.
Please feel free to offer criticism and (especially) tweaks and suggestions, and I will update this post as time goes on.
Last edited Jul 1, 2008 23:49:00






























