User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
Very weird play just happened:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=8423562

Not only did the Cb go out of bounds but he then proceeded to catch the wayward pass and get awarded a INT, weird.
 
libertylane
offline
Link
 
happens a lot
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
Has Bort or anyone publically acknowledged this bug?
 
libertylane
offline
Link
 
You just have to remember the replay isn't always accurate, its a crude representation of the play.
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by libertylane
You just have to remember the replay isn't always accurate, its a crude representation of the play.


So, that still doesn't explain how a CB got a INT being out of bounds.
 
GSUFan513
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by etchedchaos
Originally posted by libertylane

You just have to remember the replay isn't always accurate, its a crude representation of the play.


So, that still doesn't explain how a CB got a INT being out of bounds.


Yeah, it kinda does, what he is saying is the play might have visually been out of bounds to you and me, but something gets lost in the translation from the actual SIM and the visual replay of the Sim, and he was actually NOT out of bounds. Does that make more sense? The real bug is cutting down on the visual inaccuracies.
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GSUFan513
Originally posted by etchedchaos

Originally posted by libertylane


You just have to remember the replay isn't always accurate, its a crude representation of the play.


So, that still doesn't explain how a CB got a INT being out of bounds.


Yeah, it kinda does, what he is saying is the play might have visually been out of bounds to you and me, but something gets lost in the translation from the actual SIM and the visual replay of the Sim, and he was actually NOT out of bounds. Does that make more sense? The real bug is cutting down on the visual inaccuracies.


In my view the replay is a visual representation of the play and how it got to the simmed result. If the simmed result is an out of bounds INT then to me the actual result was an out of bounds INT, which is a bonafide bug. If the Cb had gone out of bounds and then intercepted in bounds then I'd say 'yea, the visual representation is off,' but this is different.

Originally posted by
I.B. Boninem pass to Teddy Ginn II up the left side intercepted by Nick Uhlback, out of bounds


That is the result of the play, it is not a visual representation and it is not a correct play. It should have been an incomplete pass.
 
Byrney
offline
Link
 
Perhaps he gets his feet down and then falls out of bounds. Imo you're placing too much trust in the visual and misinterpreting the description.
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Byrney
Perhaps he gets his feet down and then falls out of bounds. Imo you're placing too much trust in the visual and misinterpreting the description.


There's no evidence that he was defending the sideline and caught it within inches and fell out of bounds. We have a single line description and the visual representation. To me he was out of bounds and intercepted it, I've never seen this play before and as such i believe its a bug. Bugs happen, and people are so quick to dismiss my view instead of saying 'ok, thats weird, it might be a rare bug, but a bug all the same.'

This is beta, I believe this to be a bug, I've posted such, we have incomplete information on the logistics of the sim and its visual representation, so for all intents and purposes the sim could have a starting point and a finish point and the visual representation fills in the rest and if it does, then this guy did not catch the ball in bounds and fall out.
 
oddibemcd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by etchedchaos
Originally posted by Byrney

Perhaps he gets his feet down and then falls out of bounds. Imo you're placing too much trust in the visual and misinterpreting the description.


There's no evidence that he was defending the sideline and caught it within inches and fell out of bounds. We have a single line description and the visual representation. To me he was out of bounds and intercepted it, I've never seen this play before and as such i believe its a bug. Bugs happen, and people are so quick to dismiss my view instead of saying 'ok, thats weird, it might be a rare bug, but a bug all the same.'

This is beta, I believe this to be a bug, I've posted such, we have incomplete information on the logistics of the sim and its visual representation, so for all intents and purposes the sim could have a starting point and a finish point and the visual representation fills in the rest and if it does, then this guy did not catch the ball in bounds and fall out.


:applause:
 
king1058
offline
Link
 
The dots mean nothing period. What the play is saying that he did not get tackled but ran out of bounds after the INT. People always bitch about this and it is really annoying. I repeat the dots are not excactly right even Bort has acknowledged that much.
 
oddibemcd
offline
Link
 
The problem that I could see is that at some point it looks like the CB went out of bounds. In American football (have no idea about CFL and the like), when a defender leaves the field of play he can't come back into the field of play and have any effect. Thus, this should be a penalty on the defender, not a turnover. However, there are no penalties in the game, so this can't be flagged.

Moreover, no one is claiming that the dots are a perfect representation, but it is not true to say that the dots mean nothing. If they didn't, there would be no reason to have them. This could be a text based game which we all just read like some sort of throwback to the ASCII games of the Commodore. So the dots at least are there for the players to have a visual representation of what happens with the play. Here, the CB disappeared from view. This is not a play where someone is claiming that the ball got over the goalline. Here, a defensive player is gone from the field of play and still has an impact. Even if the dots are not completely correct, no part of the CB is visible in the replay. Thus, it cannot be said that he dragged one foot or was pushed out of bounds.

I didn't think this was a bug either at first, but now I am curious about the coding of plays around the sidelines because there is no printed rule set for the game that is simulated. There is a link to wikipedia for "American Football," but American football has myriad permutations, thus I would like to know what the explicit rules are for plays around the sidelines.
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oddibemcd
The problem that I could see is that at some point it looks like the CB went out of bounds. In American football (have no idea about CFL and the like), when a defender leaves the field of play he can't come back into the field of play and have any effect. Thus, this should be a penalty on the defender, not a turnover. However, there are no penalties in the game, so this can't be flagged.

Moreover, no one is claiming that the dots are a perfect representation, but it is not true to say that the dots mean nothing. If they didn't, there would be no reason to have them. This could be a text based game which we all just read like some sort of throwback to the ASCII games of the Commodore. So the dots at least are there for the players to have a visual representation of what happens with the play. Here, the CB disappeared from view. This is not a play where someone is claiming that the ball got over the goalline. Here, a defensive player is gone from the field of play and still has an impact. Even if the dots are not completely correct, no part of the CB is visible in the replay. Thus, it cannot be said that he dragged one foot or was pushed out of bounds.

I didn't think this was a bug either at first, but now I am curious about the coding of plays around the sidelines because there is no printed rule set for the game that is simulated. There is a link to wikipedia for "American Football," but American football has myriad permutations, thus I would like to know what the explicit rules are for plays around the sidelines.

Any player cannot touch the ball after they have been out of bounds during a play until they have "established themselves" back in bounds. That's obviously a ref's judgment as to whether a player has established that they are in the field of play or not. It is a penalty for a player to remain out of bounds during a play and not attempt to get back in, which is separate from the illegal touching penalty which is called when a player steps out of bounds and then comes back in and is the first to touch the ball.
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
The sideline isn't really the sideline, it's just the end of the viewable screen area of the sim.. if it's an INT then it's an INT stop whining
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
The sideline isn't really the sideline, it's just the end of the viewable screen area of the sim.. if it's an INT then it's an INT stop whining


Then why is it called "out of bounds"?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.