User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > game XP - ADMIN RESPONSE - NOT A BUG
fogie55
offline
Link
 
seems to be a bug in how/when players cross the threshold early in their careers from 625 XP per game to 500 XP per game that can result in playoff matchups 2 seasons later where one team has a full level advantage for 2 days over another team

is this working as intended?
Edited by IdRatherFlyFish on Apr 2, 2012 09:25:24
Edited by IdRatherFlyFish on Mar 30, 2012 19:50:44
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Not sure where you're seeing this, could you explain more specifically how you think it's happening?

The way the system is set up right now the only way a player will switch from 625 to 500 XP is if they boost before the end of the season (day 40 or later).

You can look at my spreadsheet to see how XP works. You will hit level 16 on day 40 if you boosted in creation season 0 (starting at level 4 on day 1) so by day 32 when you are no longer gaining game XP you will hit exactly level 16 by day 40.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AoODEuYeUBrBdHlPbUp2VmkxLWVtYmJIakk2ZEdtSXc&hl=en_US#gid=0

Obviously this does not come into play for peewee players since they cannot boost in S0.

So if players are a level behind, it's most likely due to them boosting early in the season- even before any playoffs since they would have to actually play a game for 500 XP which doesn't happen in the playoffs.

So if you boost in pre-season for example you will reach level 16 (level the XP change happens) by around day 24/25 and play a few games at reduced xp.

All that said, i don't see there being a bug but perhaps i didn't understand where you think the issue is happening.
 
fogie55
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Not sure where you're seeing this, could you explain more specifically how you think it's happening?

The way the system is set up right now the only way a player will switch from 625 to 500 XP is if they boost before the end of the season (day 40 or later).

You can look at my spreadsheet to see how XP works. You will hit level 16 on day 40 if you boosted in creation season 0 (starting at level 4 on day 1) so by day 32 when you are no longer gaining game XP you will hit exactly level 16 by day 40.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AoODEuYeUBrBdHlPbUp2VmkxLWVtYmJIakk2ZEdtSXc&hl=en_US#gid=0

Obviously this does not come into play for peewee players since they cannot boost in S0.

So if players are a level behind, it's most likely due to them boosting early in the season- even before any playoffs since they would have to actually play a game for 500 XP which doesn't happen in the playoffs.

So if you boost in pre-season for example you will reach level 16 (level the XP change happens) by around day 24/25 and play a few games at reduced xp.

All that said, i don't see there being a bug but perhaps i didn't understand where you think the issue is happening.


this assumes that boosting is a mandatory element for the game to "work as intended" and not an optional enhancement to enrich the gaming experience--not quite sure what the official line on boosting is...

the bug clearly exists in non-boosting players/teams... two teams of non-boosting players can often match up and have a one level difference between them--during the regular season its not a huge issue but seems there should be something to keep it from happening in the playoffs
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Day: Ending XP
0: 13+0/13+0
1: 13+50/13+675
2: 13+725/13+725
3: 13+775/14+400
4: 14+450/14+450
5: 14+500/15+125
6: 15+175/15+175
7: 15+225/15+850
8: 15+900/15+900
9: 15+950/16+575
10: 16+500/16+625

I see what you're saying. In their second season, teams that play on odd days will be level 15 when they play their 5th game, and will get 625 XP for it. Those that play on even days will level from over night XP the night before their 5th game, and will only get 500 XP.

However, this is working as designed, and so I don't believe it is a bug. I'll leave it open to let the other guys weigh in though.
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TruthHammer

However, this is working as designed, and so I don't believe it is a bug. I'll leave it open to let the other guys weigh in though.


It looks as an oversight, even though working as designed.
 
GroupOh
offline
Link
 
not really a bug, but its a bummer that even day, fully boosted peewee teams get their level 16 upgrades for their championship while odd day teams are 50 xp shy. paying the same amount of flex but getting slightly less in return. i understand the team you are playing is the same, but i would really appreciate the extra sp's, level gain, and eq upgrades.

 
Link
 
I've ask Catch to look at this thread. This does seem unfair to me.


Fish
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
This is working as intended and there's not really anything we can do about it. We're not going to artificially give people XP just so they are on equal terms. Really the only thing that could probably be done is to have all games for an age group to be scheduled on the same day throughout a player's career but I'm not sure that's something Bort wants to do.

I don't see how this impacts Pee Wee leagues though? Every team within a league should play games on the same day and have the same game XP.
 
fogie55
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Really the only thing that could probably be done is to have all games for an age group to be scheduled on the same day throughout a player's career but I'm not sure that's something Bort wants to do.
.


this seems like a reasonable solution--why wouldn't Bort want to do it? also would eliminate the occasional problems when a player is cut by one team and signed by another but can't be put on the depth chart so sometimes ends up missing a game
 
Gambler75
offline
Link
 
Having whole age brackets stick to even / odd day would be a godsend.

Annoyed that two of my level 79 dots got screwed hardcore by losing a game of XP due to the odd / even thing as it relates to hitting Day 281.

(Yes, I shouldn't have figured the bonus token window so tightly ... still, if the odd/even wasn't random I'd have a finished AEQ there instead of that irritating 270 staring at me.)

So a big +1 from me, if you can eliminate the randomness in the even/odd thing, would be a very great change IMO ... keep everyone on an even playing field, make the tournament scheduling a no brainer, etc. etc.
 
sicarius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gambler75
Having whole age brackets stick to even / odd day would be a godsend.

Annoyed that two of my level 79 dots got screwed hardcore by losing a game of XP due to the odd / even thing as it relates to hitting Day 281.

(Yes, I shouldn't have figured the bonus token window so tightly ... still, if the odd/even wasn't random I'd have a finished AEQ there instead of that irritating 270 staring at me.)

So a big +1 from me, if you can eliminate the randomness in the even/odd thing, would be a very great change IMO ... keep everyone on an even playing field, make the tournament scheduling a no brainer, etc. etc.


Seconded. Dots shouldn't have their XP distribution limited by factors as random as which day their games sim. Equal dots receiving equal opportunity shouldn't end up different. Glitch in the matrix.
 
numone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Really the only thing that could probably be done is to have all games for an age group to be scheduled on the same day throughout a player's career


sounds like a pretty good idea to me, at least during the minors.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by numone
sounds like a pretty good idea to me, at least during the minors.


It sounds like a good idea, however since minors league sizes (number of leagues) changes each season it could be a logistical nightmare for them if they are not set up to be able to do it.

For example, and i don't know how they have it set up right now, if they can run 8 leagues per hour what do they do when rookie age group has 12 leagues. And do you put peewee at the same time? What about casual? And what do you do when you get to an age level where there are 5 leagues to run. That ends up being an inefficient use of that hour since it's unlikely you can find another age level to put into that same slot to run.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4846510&page=2 This has been suggested before but as stated, it may not be as simple as giving a "Make it so" order. The nat pro/WL leagues being static can have the same day/time each season, but the other leagues are likely just tossed into the scheduling somewhat at random right now and trying to make an automated way to organize dynamic sized leagues into the same time slots may just not work.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
This is working as intended and there's not really anything we can do about it. We're not going to artificially give people XP just so they are on equal terms. Really the only thing that could probably be done is to have all games for an age group to be scheduled on the same day throughout a player's career but I'm not sure that's something Bort wants to do.

I don't see how this impacts Pee Wee leagues though? Every team within a league should play games on the same day and have the same game XP.


Sounds like we need to head to the suggestions forum.

But as of now, this is WAI.

Peace,

Fish
 
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.