User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > WTF is the QB doing (Fails to throw to open receiver) - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Loonzilla
WAR
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1931001&pbp_id=6628196

Fails to throw to a wide open TE, that he has spotted.
Edited by Lensar on Feb 14, 2012 12:02:43
 
Link
 
Sorry - -he was just simply unable to pull the trigger before he got sacked.

Not a bug.

Fish
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
looks fishy to me
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Does look odd... however, it's not unusual for a QB to wait a second or two before pulling the trigger on a pass. And in this case, that pause gave the DT enough time to get close to the QB... close enough that the QB may have been tied up trying to break the sack and was unable to get the throw off because of that.

I'd still feel a lot more comfortable with someone higher up taking a look at it, or at least someone without a history of trying to shut down every bug report he sees so that he can go back to fly-fishing. *cough*
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
The player definitely is wide open and the QB appears to see him as the pocket is collapsing, but doesn't pull the trigger.

Remember a few things here though:
- even great players (well built) won't be perfect 100% of the time.... players make mistakes, bad passes, bad decisions, etc.
- with the Visual on GLB we all know that it is not 100% accurate, so there are things that we do not really know.... were one of the defenders closer than we thought? did they maybe hit his arm? when he scrambled into the pocket, was it even possible for him to throw a pass even to a wide open player when he was surrounded by trees (tall players) in a collapsing pocket?
- for something / anything to be a bug it has to have numerous examples to prove that it is a repetitive and reproduceable error (i.e. not "working as intended) and not just an imperfect player error since no one can play at 100% all the time.

Now, I'm not saying that there isn't a possible issue here, but these are some questions that would need to be answered, along with a good many more examples for us to really classify this as a bug.

 
Dr. E
online
Link
 
Notice the LOLB. He drops off the TE, (I assume he's covering the TE) and heads the other way as if the ball was already thrown. Lots we don't know, was the LOLB covering the TE, what is the QB build, what was the check down? I'd say there's a bug, if not with the play, then the visual.
 
Link
 
Bert has perfect the virtual Tony Romo dot
 
Apallyon
offline
Link
 
Tay, I appreciate that you've obviously had a look at this and given it some thought.. but some of the scenarios you've put in there are just silly...

it almost bring to mind the following scenarios

- could it be possible that a fan in the 10th row looked at his watch which may have glinted the sunlight directly into the QB's eyes and therefore he missed the pass....?

LOL

Its almost like having a "is there a God" argument trying to find a bug in GLB...none exist must be an "external factor"

Why not just take it away and have a look at it....? that TE was WIDE OPEN and it takes 18 -19 FRAMES after both defensive guys are headed in the opposite direction (obviously being "LOOKED OFF"/"PUMPFAKED) as otherwise the defenders are broken (Who leaves a TE wide open in coverage 10 yard down the field and runs the opposite way)

Either way this play is fail on so many levels......unless you belong to the Packer Secondary ....
Edited by Apallyon on Jan 16, 2012 11:05:19
 
Apallyon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Big Cack Envy
Bert has perfect the virtual Tony Romo dot


 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Apallyon
Tay, I appreciate that you've obviously had a look at this and given it some thought.. but some of the scenarios you've put in there are just silly...

it almost bring to mind the following scenarios

- could it be possible that a fan in the 10th row looked at his watch which may have glinted the sunlight directly into the QB's eyes and therefore he missed the pass....?

LOL

Its almost like having a "is there a God" argument trying to find a bug in GLB...none exist must be an "external factor"

Why not just take it away and have a look at it....? that TE was WIDE OPEN and it takes 18 -19 FRAMES after both defensive guys are headed in the opposite direction (obviously being "LOOKED OFF"/"PUMPFAKED) as otherwise the defenders are broken (Who leaves a TE wide open in coverage 10 yard down the field and runs the opposite way)

Either way this play is fail on so many levels......unless you belong to the Packer Secondary ....


OK, sorry for taking the time to mention possibilities that do affect the sim that aren't visible to us.

Maybe next time I should just follow it up with "one replay isn't enough to determine something a bug" and close it at that?

 
glwarriors
offline
Link
 
Have to agree with Ap on this one. We have all seen QB's complete passes with a lot more pressure than this - at least as it is represented visually. If we blame this on the the gap between dotball visuals and what really happens in the sim then the visual must be declared broken and worthless.

And along with the above questioning of Tays well-meaning explanations, I have serious doubts that dots have arms.
Edited by IdRatherFlyFish on Jan 16, 2012 12:18:24 (added (Fails to throw to open receiver) to title, moved to NMI)
 
Link
 
We will need more than just this one replay to call this a bug.

Moving to "needs more info"


Peace,

Fish
 
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 
Loonzilla
WAR
offline
Link
 
Just a weird play. Not sure if it's a bug or not, but it needed to be looked at....

The biggest issue I believe is the LOLB, Gman has a very nice QB build, but his look offs aren't that good. Hopefully this is a one time issue and nobody else has an example.
 
Loonzilla
WAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish
Sorry - -he was just simply unable to pull the trigger before he got sacked.

Not a bug.

Fish


I have a hard time with the can't pull the trigger statement. If you look at the area around the QB when he spots the TE, the QB is free and clear.

The QB has 100+ vision, 8 in pocket presence, 87 in confidence, 6 in quick read and 9 in field general. I believe these are all the categories that could positively/negatively effect a pass that is not thrown.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.