Originally posted by Uvas Finest
To VolBrian: I've only seen about 2 encroachment penalties when the QB is in the game in two seasons. I understand the point Farlig is making, but as others have commented, even 32% is a 1 out of 3 chance. Just a curious inquiry. Nothing more than that.
Um... that was just a math example. Farliq wasn't saying that there's normally a 20% chance of encroachment, which would increase to a 32% chance. He was saying that IF there's a 20% of SOMETHING happening and you increase the chance of it happening by 60%, it will mean that it will now happen 32% of the time.
I'm not sure what the baseline is for encroachment happening, but let's say encroachment normally happens 1% of the time -- 1 time every 100 plays. Your QB has Hard Count, which increases the baseline by 60%. So you take 1, multiply it by 1.60 (to add in the 60% increase), and it comes out to... drumroll please... 1.6%. So now instead of encroachment happening 1% of the time (1 out of 100), it will happen 1.6% of the time -- about 1 time out of every 63 plays or so. Not really all that big of an increase.
And again, that's only IF the baseline for encroachment is about 1%. I have no idea what the baseline really is. It could be higher, but based on how rarely I see encroachment in games, I doubt it. It could also be lower, in which case Hard Count would have even less of an impact.
Ya gotta do the math on these VAs. It's amazing how often people don't.
I'm not a Bugs Mod, but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night. In my opinion... "Not A Bug; Working As Intended."