User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Knocked loose isn't possible on interceptions - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
I'm pretty sure I remember a Bugs thread on this back in the day. In any case, here's another example of a ball being knocked loose immediately after an interception that was interpreted by the sim as a fumble: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1839626&pbp_id=4716788
Edited by TruthHammer on Nov 24, 2011 01:13:54 (Closed - not a bug)
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
That's not what the text says. The text says INT, then fumble. Nothing wrong with that.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
2nd Quarter - 12:12

2nd & 11.5 OWN 16.5 Robert G. Johnson pass to Straight Cash or Straight Cash Homy up the left side intercepted by Demarcus Merriman (12 yd return)[forced fumble: Straight Cash or Straight Cash Homy], fumbled , recovered by Leroy Washington Jr. [TD] (30.5 yd return)


Looks like it was actually INT, then after the INT was complete he fumbled it.

What am I missing here?

 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
If I understand the OP, defenders can't fumble interceptions, and if they "fumble" it, it's not an interception. However, I don't remember that being the case at all, much less a bug, so I can't add anything beyond my very-possibly-wrong interpretation of the OP.

Also, Merriman didn't have any yardage on the return. IIRC, that's another bug in progress.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
@TaySC http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4087581 is the thread that jdbolick references in the OP. It looks like a filed bug hiding in the resolved folder.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CDZYO
If I understand the OP, defenders can't fumble interceptions, and if they "fumble" it, it's not an interception. However, I don't remember that being the case at all, much less a bug, so I can't add anything beyond my very-possibly-wrong interpretation of the OP.

Also, Merriman didn't have any yardage on the return. IIRC, that's another bug in progress.


Not sure why an INT couldn't be fumbled tbh. If the defense catches it acquiring possession of the ball, then it is knocked out it would be a fumble no different than if the HB or WR had caught a pass and then went on to fumble it during the play.

I will see what other Bug Mods think, but I simply don't see a big here.

 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
I will save jd the effort and post...



What he is saying is that there is no "knocked loose" roll on ints. On regular receptions there is x time/ticks following a catch where a "KL" roll is active and a "FF" roll is not.

In other words, if that was an offensive catch there was no way enough time/ticks had elapsed for a ff ever to have been rolled... it would have been a knocked loose. Therefore, since a ff roll happened IMMEDIATELY following an INT one should conclude that a "KL" roll does not exist following an int.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TaySC
Not sure why an INT couldn't be fumbled tbh. If the defense catches it acquiring possession of the ball, then it is knocked out it would be a fumble no different than if the HB or WR had caught a pass and then went on to fumble it during the play.

I will see what other Bug Mods think, but I simply don't see a big here.


I'm not sure if it's a bug either, only because I can't tell from the thread history what's WAI and what's not.

"Defender has INT knocked loose but INT still counts?" (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3629727) is the earliest thread I can find, although the discussion alludes to earlier threads. Here's the first play: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=919671&pbp_id=12930460 A defender attempts an interception, but the ball is knocked loose. No big deal there. However, on the next play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=919671&pbp_id=12930460 possession has changed, as if the interception were successful.

Here's what thehazyone said about it at the time http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3629727&page=2#32199254 (emphasis added):
Originally posted by thehazyone
Bort has reviewed the filed bug and said it needs some investigation but that for now he will make it to where INT's can not be KL'ed which should solve this issue. Change should go into effect before tomorrow's games - not sure he'll make a changelog update for the fix so posting here.


(As noted, it doesn't appear a changelog update was made, although a likely related change ["Fix bug that could make ball carrier untackleable if a certain series of events happened followed by a turnover"] was made shortly thereafter.)

Disabling the KL on INTs led to the following bugs thread, "No knocked loose for defense " http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4087581, where the defender attempts an interception, but has a fumble forced instead of having it knocked loose. Here's the play: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1213361&pbp_id=4993806

There was some initial disagreement over whether THAT was really a bug or not. Catch22 said at the time http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4087581&page=1#36525589:

Originally posted by Catch22
guess I'm not seeing the same thing DB is seeing. I see the pass getting intercepted and the TE forcing the fumble. The problem is it's all instantaneous so it gives the appearance of doing what DB suggests...

I don't want to dismiss this, so I'm going to mark this as needing more info and hope we can get more examples of this type of behavior. If not, we'll dismiss this one as an anomaly for now.


Eventually, NiborRis found the first thread and convinced other bugs mods that there might be a problem http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4087581&page=2#36654839:

Originally posted by NiborRis
Originally posted by
Bort has reviewed the filed bug and said it needs some investigation but that for now he will make it to where INT's can not be KL'ed which should solve this issue. Change should go into effect before tomorrow's games - not sure he'll make a changelog update for the fix so posting here.

Looks like this is intentional, but it hasn't been revisited since. This was filed as Bug #48, but we cleaned out the old bugs and started fresh with the new bugs team. I'd like to refile a new bug on this to get Bort working on it again - from the Bugzilla report it's clear he always intended to go back and put a proper fix in place, and lack of knocked loose interceptions was an interim solution.


It looks like it was filed, as Bug #183, but somehow ended up in the Resolved Bugs subforum.

tl;dr version: the play cited in the OP needs to be added to bug #183.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Good timing. I brought this up in the Q&A 2 days before this post. I'll hold off on answering this here until we get an answer there.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4784083&page=1#44105362
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
It looks like it's by design for now.

Originally posted by Bort
Int's cannot currently be KL'ed. Just fumbled.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4784083&page=4#44198489
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.