User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > What the frick? This CPU teams coachs must be doing drugs... - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
thathaway
offline
Link
 
WHY in the heck is my QB not getting any pass attempts... He is #2 on the depth chart (he is level 16) and far better build and higher level than the #3 QB (lvl 4!!!) yet the #3 QB is sharing the snaps with #1. ALSO my QB seems to be being used and has pretty much been our STAR special teams tackler.... make sense of that.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1847085

This is like the 4th game in a row this exact situation has happened.

MY QB is Motherlover Mclovin on the New Jersey team.


My QB flattens their RB blocker on this special teams play and goes in for the kill. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1847085&pbp_id=2032647
Edited by TruthHammer on Nov 3, 2011 10:58:05 (Not a bug - Closed)
Edited by thathaway on Nov 2, 2011 16:56:39
Edited by thathaway on Nov 2, 2011 16:55:27
Edited by thathaway on Nov 2, 2011 16:47:48
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
 
thathaway
offline
Link
 
Has anyone else seen a cpu team behave like this before? I've been trying to find a home on a human team for my QB but there are hardly any teams in need of QBs. I wish i could somehow drop from this cpu team and just join a different one.
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thathaway
Has anyone else seen a cpu team behave like this before? I've been trying to find a home on a human team for my QB but there are hardly any teams in need of QBs. I wish i could somehow drop from this cpu team and just join a different one.


Unfortunately CPU teams always behave that badly.

Keep shopping for a team.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Same thing is happening with my QB. Good news is that it doesn't hurt your player's development. In my case, that is all I am looking for in a team, so while I would like to see my guy make some plays, I can live with it. Thus, I am not adding a complaint to this thread...rather just confirming that this is not uncommon behavior for a CPU team.

If you want intelligent usage of your player, you will need to find a human owned team. Switched CPU teams is no guarantee to fix it. I was selective in which CPU team offer I accepted and was the only QB when I accepted with his current team. However, 2 more guys joined later and messed the whole thing up.
Edited by Plankton on Nov 2, 2011 17:00:06
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
I have a rookie Casual team that is a storage team (for now) and this season is all CPU if one of you guys is just looking for a place to get tons of playing time at the actual position, without worrying about winning.

 
thathaway
offline
Link
 
im not to worried about winning just think its silly my guy isnt getting any snaps and is being used on special teams. Like Plankton said either way he is getting xp but its just odd and what i would consider a bug so thought id post it.

I've pmed several other human teams looking for a spot for my qb but if you would like to send me a contract offer i'll accept it if i dont hear back from them.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
If you are talking about your level 16, 41 d old QB that is on a CPU team, he is only able to sign with Sophomore teams.

Rookie teams cannot even send him a contract........

 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TaySC
I have a rookie Casual team that is a storage team (for now) and this season is all CPU if one of you guys is just looking for a place to get tons of playing time at the actual position, without worrying about winning.



Thanks for the offer. I'm fine where I am, unless you just want a scrambler QB that cant really scramble yet. My build is kind of janked at the moment since he is a scrambler but i am pumping Throwing and Vision first. Thus he is not a great thrower nor a good scrambler yet. Once the build actually starts resembling what I envision, I am going to try to find him a more permanent home, but for now I just need to be able to get XP and train, which I am getting from his CPU team.
 
Link
 
Not a bug?


TaySC?
 
Ali Khaman
offline
Link
 
I'd say it's some sort of a bug.

The player in question is MotherLover McLovin.

If you look at preseason (other than game 1 where he was the only or possible 1 of 2 QBs), he has thrown exactly 1 pass attempt, despite the fact that he's had just about as many plays as the starter. The 3rd QB is a MUCH lower level than these guys, so he's getting a lot fewer snaps, but I suspect that is a low-level player stamina thing - so that part makes sense.

I could see the possibility (if it's just calling things based upon stamina as to who is in the play) that you might have a game every once in a while where the dice rolls all lined up so you happened to be the "fresh guy" in a majority or even all of the situations where the team opts to run. But...

This team passes 70% of the time based upon the scouting report. First game of the season plus 3 preseason games (where he had zero attempts) totaled 199 passing attempts. The odds of any given play being a running play is just under 1 in 3. The odds of a single player rolling a 1 on a 3 sided die 200 times in a row is mind bogglingly huge. Even if you complicate the formula by figuring in game situations that change based upon the success of the previous play and that increased the chances of him getting a running play 100 times more often, you've still got mind bogglingly huge odds against him going 4 games without a pass attempt.

ADDED: Ugh

First - let me start by suggesting to the OP that you do a better job of describing the situation so people don't have to spend an hour going out on a while goose chase. If you know the situation, it's easy to spot the problem.

Second - the issue is because the QB isn't playing QB. For some reason he doesn't have a single snap as QB - he's playing all kinds of crazy position on special teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_replays.pl?player_id=2513016&game_id=1847085

He leads the team in Special Teams tackles. lol

So - while it might actually work out that on a team that is stocked with almost all CPU players that his player is the best for the job, it doesn't really hold up to a lot of logic. Something is funky in the way CPU is prioritizing players for special teams. I suspect his relatively high level and the fact that he's a QB and doesn't get very tired are coming into play here - but that's the problem. Special Teams assignments.
Edited by Ali Khaman on Nov 3, 2011 07:39:49
 
Antonine
offline
Link
 
A similar thing happened to a QB of mine on a D league team last season. Guys below him (and lower levelled) on the dc would get plenty of snaps at QB, but he got not a single snap, 8 games in a row. Even a level 1 that joined the team in the last couple of days of regular season got QB snaps. I was told it is an energy settings thing - but the only way I can see that that makes sense is if he was constantly getting exhausted on ST, and therefore was always passed up in the 98/99 rotation for QBs. If that is the case, then that is something that needs to be adjusted, surely? As I said to an admin at the time, it's not a problem for me, but this kind of thing is guaranteed to put new players off the game.
 
Ali Khaman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Antonine
I was told it is an energy settings thing - but the only way I can see that that makes sense is if he was constantly getting exhausted on ST, and therefore was always passed up in the 98/99 rotation for QBs..


I suspect that is part of the problem. But also, on that team - that guy is SPECIFICALLY assigned to special teams on the depth chart. It's one thing if he's freshest and best for the job in a moment to moment decision, but the fact that he is assigned to special teams for some reason (blocking and speed positions, no less) is definitely an issue. If it was a CB or a WR getting assigned to the OU spots, then I could buy the "energy" thing. Or a big blocker type guy on the IN positions. But his build doesn't even remotely resemble anything useful for those slots other than that he has decent strength (because of his desire to be able to pass longer than 10 yards).

This may not really be a "BUG" - but adjusting how the CPU assigns people to special teams is definitely something that should be addressed as a very very very strong suggestion.

 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ali Khaman
First - let me start by suggesting to the OP that you do a better job of describing the situation so people don't have to spend an hour going out on a while goose chase. If you know the situation, it's easy to spot the problem.

Second - the issue is because the QB isn't playing QB. For some reason he doesn't have a single snap as QB - he's playing all kinds of crazy position on special teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_replays.pl?player_id=2513016&game_id=1847085


Ummm... he did...

The fact that in the one game he played QB, he did so early in the game, after only 1 special teams play, lends credence to the notion that it's an energy issue. As for why you're on the STs chart in the first place, every position is available to play STs, and the CPU has determined your dot to be among the best suited to play them. Since you're leading the team in ST tackles, I'd say it's pretty accurate. This is not a bug, but you might be able to build a decent suggestion for distributing playing time on special teams.

PS. I know a place where you could hold that QB for the season and get some plays. I'll send an offer.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.