User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Kickoff coverage team runs past the ball rather than recovering it - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Sly
offline
Link
 
Until recently, when a kick returner missed the ball the coverage guys would just stop and stand in their tracks till he ran back and picked the ball up. I see they are no longer stopping but now an even bigger problem has loomed!

Here you will see that my kick coverage guys get to the ball first and, in fact, should recover it since it's a "live" ball (and they can even advance it). Instead, they run past the ball, so that when the kick returner finally gets there, they are past him and in no position to make the tackle. Instead of my possession, as it should have been, it's a TD the other way! Ugh!
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1801335&pbp_id=5028525

Edit: even if they don't recover the ball they shouldn't run past it. Since based on below comments it seems that Bort is unwilling to add logic to run to the ball for now, I'm just asking for a fix so they defenders don't run 5-10 yards past the ball! Defenders should stop running forward once they've reached the ball!
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 18, 2011 08:53:28 (Closed)
Edited by Sly on Sep 17, 2011 18:15:38
Edited by Sly on Sep 17, 2011 18:14:57
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
You can see the difference in punts, where the logic works correctly:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1801335&pbp_id=5028940
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1801335&pbp_id=5030958

Punts seem to be fine, but kickoffs are a mess!
Edited by Sly on Sep 17, 2011 18:03:30
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Hate to say it, but they stayed in their lanes, so technically, working as intended.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4736609
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Ouch! Well obviously it needs to be fixed to get the game out of "Beta" so while it may be what Bort coded for now it's clearly a "bug" in the sense of a game that is intended to simulate football.

However, I would still argue that this is a bug because they run PAST the ball. They should, at a minimum, stop at the ball. Running past the ball just gives up an easy TD to the other team, which is something that should be addressed.

It would be easy to prevent them from running PAST the ball for now, and still address the full problem later, so I guess I hope that someone still is willing to push this up the food chain.

P.S. I have to admit that just because something is coded clearly incorrectly in terms of football rules and behavior, that the argument is made that, "well that's how it's coded so it's ok" sort of seems like a false argument. I mean, the entire game is coded, and ALWAYS operates according to how it's coded, so this argument could be applied to everything and nothing would get fixed. The argument should be that the coding is reasonable, or the best that can be reasonably done, but not, "well we coded it unreasonably but it's not a bug because it's actually coded that way." Of course it's coded that way, or else I wouldn't have watched it unfold that way! But it's not reasonable!
 
fogie55
offline
Link
 
I suspect 90% of users will agree this is broken, but unfortunately I also suspect the answer you're going to get is that this only happened here because this is a rookie team... the coding of the game is designed almost entirely to work correctly for World League/Pro levels and not necessarily before. It has to fail there to be considered broken.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fogie55
I suspect 90% of users will agree this is broken, but unfortunately I also suspect the answer you're going to get is that this only happened here because this is a rookie team... the coding of the game is designed almost entirely to work correctly for World League/Pro levels and not necessarily before. It has to fail there to be considered broken.


Not really, it can happen anywhere depending on how the ball is kicked/speed of players etc.

However as the post linked above quoted:

115: Kickoff coverage unit stops and/or does not pursue the ball. This is not a bug. This is currently coded as Bort intends it to be so we can not call any of these issues bugs. When the kick returner misses the catch on the kickoff, the coverage team will either stop still around the 35 yard line or continue in their lanes until the returner recovers the ball. Which action the coverage team does is dependent on the angle, path, and velocity of the kick, but they currently are acting in a fashion that Bort intends and will not converge on the ball until it is recovered. These issues are not considered Bugs and will be closed as such if posted. They will be recoded down the line, but for now it is working correctly as coded.

From Quirks of GLB, Common Complaints & Commonly False Bugs http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4340520



 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Not really, it can happen anywhere depending on how the ball is kicked/speed of players etc.

However as the post linked above quoted:

115: Kickoff coverage unit stops and/or does not pursue the ball. This is not a bug. This is currently coded as Bort intends it to be so we can not call any of these issues bugs. When the kick returner misses the catch on the kickoff, the coverage team will either stop still around the 35 yard line or continue in their lanes until the returner recovers the ball. Which action the coverage team does is dependent on the angle, path, and velocity of the kick, but they currently are acting in a fashion that Bort intends and will not converge on the ball until it is recovered. These issues are not considered Bugs and will be closed as such if posted. They will be recoded down the line, but for now it is working correctly as coded.

From Quirks of GLB, Common Complaints & Commonly False Bugs http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4340520


This is correct. No need to rehash it again.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.