User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Trying to figure this one out. - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
silkrunner
offline
Link
 
Why did we stop pushing at the 50 and not pursue the ball back to the 5, it's a casual league so we don't really have a lot of control, and the owner is just as clueless as we are. But the entire team just stopped pushing at the 50 and waited for him to come back up with the ball. What was a beautiful kick turned out to be a horrible play.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1759449&pbp_id=4005621
Edited by Sirwin on Jul 20, 2011 12:19:32
Edited by Sirwin on Jul 20, 2011 08:30:06
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Since the ball was kicked over the returner's head, the kicking team stops until the KR gets the ball. But I did think that they were supposed to stop at the 35 and not the 50. Let me look for some more info.

115: Kickoff coverage unit stops and/or does not pursue the ball. This is not a bug. This is currently coded as Bort intends it to be so we can not call any of these issues bugs. When the kick returner misses the catch on the kickoff, the coverage team will either stop still around the 35 yard line or continue in their lanes until the returner recovers the ball. Which action the coverage team does is dependent on the angle, path, and velocity of the kick, but they currently are acting in a fashion that Bort intends and will not converge on the ball until it is recovered. These issues are not considered Bugs and will be closed as such if posted. They will be recoded down the line, but for now it is working correctly as coded.
Edited by Sirwin on Jul 20, 2011 06:49:27
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
strange thing is, why did they stop at the 50? They're supposed to keep going to about the 35 and then stop. Can't see it well in the flash but i had java version on by mistake and saw the kicking team all stop early.
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
strange thing is, why did they stop at the 50? They're supposed to keep going to about the 35 and then stop. Can't see it well in the flash but i had java version on by mistake and saw the kicking team all stop early.


yeah that's why I didn't close it. I thought it was the 35 as well. Yes the kick team stayed in their lanes, but why stop at the 50??
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Here's another kickoff from the team from above http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1754205&pbp_id=4643435

It appears that when the ball comes to a stop, the players also come to a stop. Not instantly of course but as fast as their agility would allow i guess. It's not quite as dramatic as the OP but they do appear to be stopping before the intended 35 yard line barrier.

Here is another one http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1754205&pbp_id=4643738

Yep looks like that is why they are stopping. Once the ball stops moving, the entire kicking team came to a stop as well no matter where they were at the time. I think the combination of an amazingly long kick off-center and very slow players are showing this issue off.

Edit* Oh and i think my eyes just skipped right over your first line when i saw the 115 error paste sorry bout that
Edited by alindyl on Jul 20, 2011 08:21:35
Edited by alindyl on Jul 20, 2011 08:18:52
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
I went back and looked, in java, at the original replay in the OP and by the "on-screen representation" the fastest player on the kick team (OU1) does make it down to close to the 35 before the rest of the team stops. It looks like he stops at the 37 while the rest of the team is at stops between the 40 and 50.

On the 1st replay that alindyl posted, it is basically the same thing. However, on the 2nd replay, OU1 starts to move out of his lane at the 40 when the ball stops therefore he stops at the 40 as well.

By looking at these more closely, I have to go with LIKELY NOT A BUG since it seems it seems to go off of the 1st person reaching the stopping point (35 yd line) when the ball stops.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
It's not always the 35 yard line. Sometimes the players run beyond the ball even resulting in some easy ST scores.

Most of the time when the kick is not caught you will see two things. Players stop when the ball stops bouncing, players run beyond the ball, or when the ball is still in the air from the kick the players will stop at the 35-ish yard line.

This is NOT A BUG from where we stand right now. We do however have it filed in numerous ways, shapes, and forms, and are thankful for you taking the time to post this in the Bugs Forums..
 
silkrunner
offline
Link
 
There's gotta be a better way tho, for instance having everyone continue in their lanes until they reach the 35 possibly, because right now that is allowing teams that really shouldn't to get a decent field position after a good kick. Especially in the lower levels, this probably corrects its self as you get up into the higher leagues and EVERYONE has speed, but in the beginning some of the ST guys won't have that speed, so while it's probably not actually a bug possibly could use some recoding?
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
On somewhat of a tangent to this post, it might appear that the 35 yard line point in that common error #115 might need a slight modification. It should probably also include that there is a third outcome in addition to stopping at the 35 or continuing in their lanes, they can also just come to a complete stop when the ball stops.

Looking through some old replays used in previous bug posts about the subject i found this one http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1758138&pbp_id=2929430 which no player managed to cross the 40 yard line due to the ball stopping.

It's still not a bug, but people might be confused since that condition isn't mentioned in the #115 commonly falsely reported bugs.

As for a better way silk- perhaps but ST hasn't had a lot of focus on it, and this was about the best patch he could put into place to make ST not cause players to miss play time due to ST getting all the plays in a game. Though this is largely irrelevant currently with the 1 play max XP change but that would be more of a suggestion.
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Marking as Not A Bug and closing.
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.