User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > FILED BUGS > Caught, Spin, Knocked loose? - BUG FILED - #696
Page:
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1663724&pbp_id=5450187

Seems like this should be a fumble to me, but I could be wrong.

Or at least the missed tackle on the play should not count.
Edited by Lensar on Jun 7, 2011 20:35:09 (assigned bug)
Edited by Pwned IRL on Jun 4, 2011 14:08:01 (needs to be filed)
Edited by TruthHammer on May 31, 2011 21:29:29 (Verified likely a bug)
Edited by Mike Rogers on May 30, 2011 19:33:16 (1st)
Edited by Mike Rogers on May 29, 2011 10:25:52 (likely a bug)
 
Androth
offline
Link
 
That seems fishy...it might be possible that those things all happened at the same time?

This is probably going to be hard to find more of, but lets give it a shot.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
This is pretty rare, but the order of events would probably be
- Defelection
- Missed tackle
- Knocked loose

The missed tackle happened so quickly that the knocked loose could and did still happen.

I think I agree that the missed tackle shouldn't count as a stat though, that part mkes no sense.
But purely as a description of what happened in the play, its accurate.

Looks like thats his only missed tackle in the game?, and it counted in his stats, so it should be considered a bug imo.

So its just the way the stats are pulled from the PBP thats an issue, which would need an IF play results in incomplete negate missed tackles type of fix.

Might be the case that it cant be or wont be fixed any time soon though. I dont know if the intent is to depict every event in game where possible, to provide better feedback to the user on Dot performance That dot still missed a tackle, and people are always complaining about not having enough stats.

Sticking with the Needs More Info, for now, if this is widespread enough it should be fixed regardless, if it is very isolated, it drops way down the priority list I guess?
 
bigg987
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1702512&pbp_id=6030798

it happens quite often tbh,
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
What I don't like about the play is a missed tackle occurs, and a different defender gets the knocked loose.

An incomplete pass happens before a football move is made after a completion attempt.

These plays are screaming fumble to me.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
The play in the OP had 3 defenders in the PBP text. One missed tackle, One deflection, and One knocked loose. That's funky for sure, and something needs to be rehashed in the timing of the Knocked-loose occurances.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
yep, its a weird one alright
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigg987
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1702512&pbp_id=6030798

it happens quite often tbh,


How does the SPIN happen without possession?
Knocked loose should be pre-possession.
Edited by rocomo on May 28, 2011 16:31:21
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Knocked loose is pre possession.

However the (failed) tackle attempt can also occur "pre possession" as long as its initially declared "Caught" in the PBP, otherwise a knocked loose would be impossible, if a Defender had to wait for a catch AND possession before attempting a tackle he cant very well knock it loose.

And if a Defender can make a tackle before possesion is secured, we get into the dice game of rolls and re-rolls.
If you eliminate those break tackle actions pre possession for the reciever, then almost all of those tackles pre possesion will be made, unless there is a huge build/level inbalance.

That scenario would have a huge impact on the balance of the game, and also Nerf a lot of VAs and current builds.

There is also nothing 'unreal' about Spin firing pre possession, as someone who coaches football in real life, I spend at least 4 nights a week screaming at WRs because they are trying to make a tackler miss before securing possession.


The fact is, two tackle attempts were made almost at the same time, one failed due to a Spin move, the other suceeded and resulted in the knocked loose.

The Bug here is that the missed tackle/broken tackle were reported to the stats for that play, which is not logical.

(edit for 5 am spelling)
Edited by Mike Rogers on May 28, 2011 22:10:25
Edited by Mike Rogers on May 28, 2011 22:09:41
 
MileHighShoes
offline
Link
 
More examples for you. As already stated it's not too rare.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1657488&pbp_id=1444160
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1657478&pbp_id=381522
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
Ive seen this before and I remember catch22 disregarding it and saying that's how the sim is and it will stay that way.
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IIAMLEGEND
Ive seen this before and I remember catch22 disregarding it and saying that's how the sim is and it will stay that way.


Catch22 owns this game, what he says goes.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Knocked loose is pre possession.

However the (failed) tackle attempt can also occur "pre possession" as long as its initially declared "Caught" in the PBP, otherwise a knocked loose would be impossible, if a Defender had to wait for a catch AND possession before attempting a tackle he cant very well knock it loose.

And if a Defender can make a tackle before possesion is secured, we get into the dice game of rolls and re-rolls.
If you eliminate those break tackle actions pre possession for the reciever, then almost all of those tackles pre possesion will be made, unless there is a huge build/level inbalance.

That scenario would have a huge impact on the balance of the game, and also Nerf a lot of VAs and current builds.

There is also nothing 'unreal' about Spin firing pre possession, as someone who coaches football in real life, I spend at least 4 nights a week screaming at WRs because they are trying to make a tackler miss before securing possession.


The fact is, two tackle attempts were made almost at the same time, one failed due to a Spin move, the other suceeded and resulted in the knocked loose.

The Bug here is that the missed tackle/broken tackle were reported to the stats for that play, which is not logical.

(edit for 5 am spelling)


That is not 100% right...

I have made a bugs thread on this before... also got Bort to address this in a Q&A... here is a better way to explain..

KL roll is the make tackle roll.

To get a KL roll the ball actually has to be caught (gained possession as far as dotball is concerned... no football moves in GLB to define possession)... if the wr is still bobbling the ball and the ball is jarred loose then it is just a pass deflected. Following a caught pass there is x amount of ticks where the KL roll will be active (you can not roll a FF roll during this period).

That said, since KL is part of the make tackle system then naturally the anti-KL is the break tackle roll. This is why Spin fired on a missed tackle and then another player rolled a successful KL roll (essentially the receiver broke the first player attempt at a KL but so few ticks had gone before a second player was able to make contact and therefore able to roll a KL instead of the make tackle / FF progression).

So in short... caught pass (possession) > make tackle vs break tackle > successful make tackle results in KL (so long as it is within predetermined x amount of ticks)... successful break tackle results in missed/broken tackle... if still within predetermined ticks than another defender will roll KL instead of tackle... if not then tackle / ff progression.

That said, the missed/broken tackle should be reported considering the events technically take place after possession is determined (successful catch pass roll).

 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
You would think some sort of clean up rule at the end of a pass play could simply say if knocked loose remove any missed tackles.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Yeah, also the broken tackle.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.