User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Punting stats in box score don't match actual results - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Punker2p2
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1680342&mode=pbp

My Punter has two punts in this game:

10:59 4th & 5.5 OPP 41.5 Punt by Alfredo Tate, 37 yd, fielded by Sheldon J. Plankton (15.5 yd return) [Big Hit diving tackle: Tau Jackson] Replay

4:04 4th & 4 OPP 33.5 Punt by Alfredo Tate, 35.5 yds (touchback) Replay

However, when you look at the box score, it says:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1680342

P Alfredo Tate 2 52 26

(ie, 2 punts for 56 yards, as opposed to the 2 for 72.5 yards it actually was)
Edited by Sirwin on May 31, 2011 10:42:01
 
amace
offline
Link
 
First punt: 37 yards
second punt, 15.5 yards

Total: 52.5 yards,

Seems right.

Punting stats count a touchback against your average. Dumb, I know but it's how it works.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by amace
First punt: 37 yards
second punt, 15.5 yards

Total: 52.5 yards,

Seems right.

Punting stats count a touchback against your average. Dumb, I know but it's how it works.


This is a correct assessment. The touchback negates yardage from the net.
 
LT56
offline
Link
 
It's always been like that.

It is statistically incorrect and been suggested numerous times to be corrected.
 
LT56
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Originally posted by amace

First punt: 37 yards
second punt, 15.5 yards

Total: 52.5 yards,

Seems right.

Punting stats count a touchback against your average. Dumb, I know but it's how it works.


This is a correct assessment. The touchback negates yardage from the net.


Stat line doesn't say "net" though.

That's why this gets posted in bugs every now and then...because the stat is flawed.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LT56
Stat line doesn't say "net" though.

That's why this gets posted in bugs every now and then...because the stat is flawed.


So your saying that if a Punter punted the ball 300 yards out of the stadium, he should get credit for those 300 yards?

I beg to differ. This stat is showing what it should show.. A punt resulting in a touchback is and always will be defined as the punt only reaching the 20 yard line. It's like that everywhere I have ever seen it.
 
amace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
So your saying that if a Punter punted the ball 300 yards out of the stadium, he should get credit for those 300 yards?

I beg to differ. This stat is showing what it should show.. A punt resulting in a touchback is and always will be defined as the punt only reaching the 20 yard line. It's like that everywhere I have ever seen it.


No, if a punter boots the ball from the 45 through the back of the endzone, his punt should count for 55 yards. 45 yards at the least.

No professional football leagues takes touchbacks off gross average.

It SHOULD be called net average. Because the touchback is basically like a free 20 yard return. If a guy boots the ball 99 yards tot he opponent goal line, and it's returned for a TD, should he get credit for kicking it 99 yards? or hurt his average for giving up a TD?

Again, no pro football league counts TB's off of a gross average.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by amace
No, if a punter boots the ball from the 45 through the back of the endzone, his punt should count for 55 yards. 45 yards at the least.

No professional football leagues takes touchbacks off gross average.

It SHOULD be called net average. Because the touchback is basically like a free 20 yard return. If a guy boots the ball 99 yards tot he opponent goal line, and it's returned for a TD, should he get credit for kicking it 99 yards? or hurt his average for giving up a TD?

Again, no pro football league counts TB's off of a gross average.


Hmm. I must be mistaken. So for punts, there are how many ways to calculate the yardage?

I thought NET yardage was about the only way. In my opinion its the only way that makes much sense.

I wouldn't care to know how far my punter punts the ball if it's not helping his team any.

Nobody wants to punt into Touchbacks all day. You want coffin corner punts..
 
amace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Hmm. I must be mistaken. So for punts, there are how many ways to calculate the yardage?

I thought NET yardage was about the only way. In my opinion its the only way that makes much sense.

I wouldn't care to know how far my punter punts the ball if it's not helping his team any.

Nobody wants to punt into Touchbacks all day. You want coffin corner punts..


Then call it net yards, and count it as such.

If they want to do net ayrds, fantastic. but you have to count return yards against Net as well.

If not, then keep it at gross yards, and get rid of the TB's from counting against it.

Or, best case, have both.


in the NFL, they grade punters by gross yards for the most part. When they say "so and so averaged 47.5yards per punt", that doesn't take into account touchbacks or returns, here in GLB, it takes into account touchbacks, but not returns.

Either do both, or don't do any at all. That is the issue.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by amace
Then call it net yards, and count it as such.

If they want to do net ayrds, fantastic. but you have to count return yards against Net as well.

If not, then keep it at gross yards, and get rid of the TB's from counting against it.

Or, best case, have both.


in the NFL, they grade punters by gross yards for the most part. When they say "so and so averaged 47.5yards per punt", that doesn't take into account touchbacks or returns, here in GLB, it takes into account touchbacks, but not returns.

Either do both, or don't do any at all. That is the issue.


Gotcha. Since I am not a shareholder, script writer, or even a real Mod/Admin in GLB I cannot decide or make rules or do any of the a fore mentioned activities. I take it that this has been suggested on numerous occasions and Bort has decided that it is not a priority. So that leaves us without a Bug Report and hanging in the limbo.
 
amace
offline
Link
 
GLB has shareholders?!
 
LT56
offline
Link
 
Pwned IRL, you are correct. It's been decided many times that it's "not a bug". And suggested many times and ignored.

However, that doesn't change the fact that it is an incorrectly worded stat. So you will continue to get bugs posted until it is fixed to reflect either "net yards per punt" or "gross yards per punt". As it is now, you have a combo of the two stats, which gives false data.
Edited by LT56 on May 24, 2011 15:13:44
 
Punker2p2
offline
Link
 
Thanks for clarifying everyone. Agree that it should either use net (yards punted minus returns/TB) or gross yards, but I guess it isn't a bit deal.
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Closing and marking as Not A Bug
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.