User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Weird audible to block - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Only one replay, (for now)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1597637&pbp_id=8374668

The play is set to have the FB stay to block and HB + TE run a route. The AI allow for the QB to call the HB and TE to pass block if he sees a blitz.

The issue: this is a 5 man rush, so why the QB calls for 8 blockers ?
Also if the FB missed a vision check to see the blitz the QB should not know about it to call for and extra blocker.
Edited by VolBrian on Apr 11, 2011 07:17:33 (Title edit)
 
Link
 
The QB called for 8 blockers because he thought more than 5 were going to rush -- bummer he was wrong.

And .. when FB's (or anyone else for that matter) make a vision check, I seriously doubt they holler out to the QB: "Hey, I made my vision check so no need to call for additional blockers.


Not a bug in my opinion.

Fish
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
The QB called for 8 blockers because he thought more than 5 were going to rush -- bummer he was wrong.

Are you inventing this, or know ? there are vision check for the QB to see blitzing dots, but I never heard of a vision checked to see false blitzes. (no problem if this is a part of the sim, just something new to me).


Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish

And .. when FB's (or anyone else for that matter) make a vision check, I seriously doubt they holler out to the QB: "Hey, I made my vision check so no need to call for additional blockers.


I do hope you are correct on this one.
 
Link
 
Semi-inventing (hey, I don't lie)

But - if there is a test to see if he can spot a blitz, then it makes sense to me that at times, the QB would call for additional protection, even when it was not necessary.

We really need more replays of this exact thing before we can make a determination.

Can you find us some more Traq?

Thanks!

Fish
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
I will if I have any.

Very hard to find such examples since it depends on a defense specific play and knowing how the offense is set up.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Yea. Not sure what to say on that one. Need more replays.
 
Androth
offline
Link
 
Everyone of those players does end up blocking someone. I'm not sure how many people get held back is strictly based on just the number of blitzers. If the QB felt his O-line wasn't going to hold I'd imagine he would hold back as many as he felt necessary.

However, I also agree with the first 2, that to determine if this is an issue, or if he just panicked we'll need to see it happen more.
Edited by Androth on Apr 7, 2011 16:26:58
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish
And .. when FB's (or anyone else for that matter) make a vision check, I seriously doubt they holler out to the QB: "Hey, I made my vision check so no need to call for additional blockers.


But the QB shouldn't be assuming the FB will miss his vision check just because it's a possibility. That's ridiculous.
 
Link
 
TreyJo,

Where are you getting this idea from?

Originally posted by TrevJo
But the QB shouldn't be assuming the FB will miss his vision check just because it's a possibility. That's ridiculous.


 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
I don't think the FB missing a vision check has anything to do with the play.

What that tells me is that the FB was assigned to block to begin with.

So really we need to see proof of how this play was set up in your AI's to determine maybe you had designed for them all to say in. I wouldn't think a FB would miss a vision check on a route running assignment when he's then audibled to be a blocker.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
I don't think the FB missing a vision check has anything to do with the play.

What that tells me is that the FB was assigned to block to begin with.

So really we need to see proof of how this play was set up in your AI's to determine maybe you had designed for them all to say in. I wouldn't think a FB would miss a vision check on a route running assignment when he's then audibled to be a blocker.


Due to the time lapsed, you will have to take my word that the only dot that was set to block was the FB and auidble was on for the TE and HB.

I can post more instances of the play where the TE an HB do go on route. But at the end you will need to believe me that I didn't changes the AI.

I know people don't like going to the test sever with one replay (and I respect that). The situation in the OP can be regenerated quite easily (set the defense more or less the same, set the offense exactly the same, make sure you have high vision QB and low vision FB and walla).
 
Link
 
Traq,

I trust you on the settings, so we're cool there.

In the OP you state "The issue: this is a 5 man rush, so why the QB calls for 8 blockers ?"

My answer to that question (and it is just my opinion) is that the QB felt he needed all 8 blockers.

Here's how I arrived at that:

During the pre-snap read the QB has to make a determination as to which defenders are going to rush the QB. QB Feels the three down linemen will rush him. He scans the Linebackers, and takes a guess that two out of the three will blitz him - and he properly picks up the QB blitz coming from the weak side. That's 6 defenders. He wants a blocking advantage, so he asks for 8 blockers. I think without 8 blockers this play ends up in a sack.

OH -- I just thought of something else!

The TE is on the weak-side. Only way to get him there is to select "pass block weak side". So -- FB in to block, TE is pass-blocking by design -- QB picks up the Weak-side CB Blitz, or the RO and holds the HB in to help.

To me both of those scenarios make sense.


Peace,

Fish
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish


The TE is on the weak-side. Only way to get him there is to select "pass block weak side".


This sums it up. So the only audible was the HB.

Edited by Pwned IRL on Apr 8, 2011 14:02:29
 
Yard Dog
offline
Link
 
The thing I'm more concerned about is the WR still coming down with the catch in a quadruple team
 
Link
 
Move along -- nothing to see here

Not a bug, I'm going to ping the OP and if they are satisfied, I'll button this up.


Fish
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.