User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > True Impact Players, Level Cap Exception
Page:
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Because no one clicks on the stickeys with 700 posts, or a generic thread title, I will put this here.

Bort had suggested a rule for level caps based on average level with some "wiggle room." I agree with this. However, I suggest each team should be allowed 3 "blockbuster" or "franchise" players that can excede the cap. Once a player is signed or traded for that excedes the cap, they are tagged as such. They will remain tagged until they leave the team. A team can NEVER have more than 3 of these players.

Might make strategy more interesting. Stellar OL, QB, LB? Its the GM's call. Any suggestions? Ways this will obviously be abused?
 
mickyj
offline
Link
 
I think that is a good idea.

Would also allow people getting a side in a expansion league to bring in their stud player who may be over the cap.

Some will complain as at present buys at level 20 are getting huge contracts will it just push them up more? Or will it only be people who have these players themselves or have freinds who do tat can use it?
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
+1...good idea
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Good point. I have no idea what would happen. This is already kind of a problem. Players that know the owner (or owners that are the player's agent) can sign for less anyway.

However, with a limit of 3, I think teams could afford it. Otherwise, they may choose to have overall better players and no studs.
 
Joe4Sure72
offline
Link
 
Yup. Franchise players would work. They could just be like the "captains" of a team.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
How would you tell XYZ team, that currently has 6 players over the limit, that their team is being pulled apart? Would it be that they couldn't resign a new contract (yea, I see 6 10-year contracts being written up the day before it goes into affect)? Would you just nullify all contracts and everyone has to reissue 50 new contracts to build a team from the ground up (I'm sure that people who paid real money and had already been working on building a team for 3 seasons would love that)?

If the level cap is based upon the league average.. as a team progresses, the average is going to change - thereby allowing teams to fire their low level Players and hire higher level ones, thereby increasing the cap again.. and again .. and again. And if the Caps are set at the beginning of each season - what happens if a player levels beyond the cap in the middle of a season? I'm guessing the cap only applies to accepting a contract.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Yes, this is based off Bort's stickey at the top of the page. Current players above the proposed newly instituted caps would remain on the team. This would go into effect for all trades and newly signed players. Eventually, players will be forced to retire and the "3 stud" rule would be a part of the league.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
The point of the level capped leagues is to have SOMEWHERE where players can compete against people their own level. This would defeat that.
 
lgoody
offline
Link
 
I like this idea actually...not everybody is on the same level, ya know.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
The cap's there so everybody in the league has as level a playing field as possible and was implemented to prevent over-leveled people from being introduced into a league and unbalancing it; this basically just says "Re-unbalance it because I have some good players that want to join my team and I should be able to bring them in to give me an advantage, but to 'balance' that out I'll allow every other owner the possibility to sign or trade for any one of the 0 level 20+ players in the game that would consider joining a level-capped, lowest-tier league so they could be buried with 'wow what a cheater' accusations every day they're in the league".
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
But the balance comes from the 3 player limit. Every team can sign 3 studs. There is a level playing field everywhere except for the 3 studs. That is the only unchecked variable. Those 3 studs are "prime time," marquee players that may or may not turn the tide of the game.

Don't want to go against the great one, but I firmly believe in this idea if the level cap is instituted (except for D Leagues, obviously). Parity is great and all, but there should be some serious key players on a team...if the GM wants to spend the money and go after them. If they don't, they deserve to lose. Just like in the NFL.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Boo.

No sandbagging your level 22s into a level 13 league. Weak.
 
raylewis22
offline
Link
 
i say lets do it, it sounds sweet
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SmithersOT
The point of the level capped leagues is to have SOMEWHERE where players can compete against people their own level. This would defeat that.


As far as matchups go, this would happen rarely. Its not like every team would choose to pick up a stud C. This would make some teams have a strong LB core and some a stud passing game. It would make things more realistic, gives teams real impact players, and adds some strategy to managing a team.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
In addition, I doubt that many top-level players would shoot down in the league just to pump up their stats. As in the NFL, many players will move to a team for a ring for less money, but very few would move to a worse team to be the stars. They may do it for the money, but, teams in lower leagues would have less money to spend on acquiring unbelievably over-leveled players.
Last edited Jun 22, 2008 23:43:56
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.