User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Effective Level Not Dropping - NOT A BUG - #562
Page:
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
This team has 6 total players. Two QBs level 14 and 17, three RBs level 19 and the other two level 20, and a kicker at level 17.

They just played a game at a team effective level of 21 against a team who has one player at level 21, one player at 20, and the rest below. How does that happen?

The roster pages show the average level of player for the team in question at 20 compared to the team they just played at 17. If the CPU's level to the opposing team, why is the leveling so much different?

Is it possible that this team full of CPU players isn't leveling to the team they are playing? Every time I have scouted their games they have been effective level 21 and I would say I've scouted roughly half of their games this season and have never seen a team with any higher than an effective level of 18.. They have played ONE close game this season. The rest have been blowouts in their favor, and most not high scoring blowouts the way you would expect to see with a defense made up of all CPU players.

Here is the team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2759
Edited by Hikariu on Feb 17, 2011 06:56:24
Edited by RMiller517 on Feb 17, 2011 06:53:46
Edited by Androth on Feb 16, 2011 21:27:28 (NOT LIKELY A BUG)
Edited by Androth on Feb 16, 2011 01:01:04 (NEEDS MORE INFO)
Edited by Androth on Feb 15, 2011 21:00:59 (ADMIN ATTENTION)
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
How exactly are you monitoring effective levels of the CPU players?

The CPU players will match the opposition minus a percentage..

Also, The effective level of the linked team is based off of their Human players only. It wouldn't be hard for them to have an effective level of 21 honestly. Those key point Offensive players they have are easily the reason for the success.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
I thought that the CPU effectiveness was determined at game time and not beforehand?
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Also, The effective level of the linked team is based off of their Human players only. It wouldn't be hard for them to have an effective level of 21 honestly. Those key point Offensive players they have are easily the reason for the success.


I was unaware of this. I thought it included the CPU players as well. In that case the effective level issue makes sense, but the outcome of many of their games still do not.

It just seems very out of the ordinary that they're defense being all CPU shuts down teams as much as it does. With an all CPU defense it seems they should be winning their games by 21 or less.

There are a few members of our league who are left scratching their heads about what is making this team as good as it is.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by John Waylon
I was unaware of this. I thought it included the CPU players as well. In that case the effective level issue makes sense, but the outcome of many of their games still do not.

It just seems very out of the ordinary that they're defense being all CPU shuts down teams as much as it does. With an all CPU defense it seems they should be winning their games by 21 or less.

There are a few members of our league who are left scratching their heads about what is making this team as good as it is.


I think it was Androth who PM'd me and told me that the averaged that teams Effective Level and it was 18 if you look at only the players that are not CPU's. So I'm not sure where to go with this or how to verify. I'll be honest.

Anyone else gathering anything from this thread to make a verification with?
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
I think it was Androth who PM'd me and told me that the averaged that teams Effective Level and it was 18 if you look at only the players that are not CPU's. So I'm not sure where to go with this or how to verify. I'll be honest.

Anyone else gathering anything from this thread to make a verification with?


I understand that it's kind of an odd issue. But in my 18 seasons of playing I've never seen such a team filled with CPU players and only players at HB and QB just dominate a league the way they have. The few other teams I have seen try to make this work only had mild success with it. They were able to win some close games, but against the leagues top teams the CPU defensive players just couldn't hold up.

I'm sure they have a great D AI, but even that shouldn't be able to make up for the fact that they have CPU players on D.

Some of the point totals that they have held teams to are quite odd for an all CPU defense.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by John Waylon
I understand that it's kind of an odd issue. But in my 18 seasons of playing I've never seen such a team filled with CPU players and only players at HB and QB just dominate a league the way they have. The few other teams I have seen try to make this work only had mild success with it. They were able to win some close games, but against the leagues top teams the CPU defensive players just couldn't hold up.

I'm sure they have a great D AI, but even that shouldn't be able to make up for the fact that they have CPU players on D.

Some of the point totals that they have held teams to are quite odd for an all CPU defense.


They're still giving up 37 ppg including one game where they gave up 105 points and another with 83. That's not exactly lights out D. On offense, they're running the same 7 pitch plays over and over again, and nobody can stop them because their HBs out-level everybody. I'm questioning the effective level of 21 and the Avg player value of 391, but I'm not questioning why this team is winning.
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TruthHammer
They're still giving up 37 ppg including one game where they gave up 105 points and another with 83. That's not exactly lights out D. On offense, they're running the same 7 pitch plays over and over again, and nobody can stop them because their HBs out-level everybody. I'm questioning the effective level of 21 and the Avg player value of 391, but I'm not questioning why this team is winning.


Why is it that these CPU players are sufficing on defense?

Sure, they have let a few teams score tons of points, but they have had two games within 21 points. IMO using the points allowed per game as an argument doesn't really have much merit because points in the current state of the sim at this level aren't hard to score. And ontop of that, with a CPU defense, shouldn't most of, if not all of their games be closer than they have been? If the CPu's are averaged to the opponents why is the points gap so great?

The 105-112 win over Band of Brothers you mentioned really has to bring into question what's going on here IMO. BoB should have been able to beat them. I've played BoB and I know how good they are and how stout their AI is.

I just can not buy that the offense is making up for the insufficiencies on defense. Even with the best defensive AI ever created they should not be winning their games by 21+ points with a CPU defense.

But I'll go as far as to play devil's advocate here... I'll say that either they're offense is good enough to bail out a CPU defense, or their AI is good enough to only need CPU players, or it's even a combination a vote...

If any of those were to be true, shouldn't it be just a little alarming how much can be done with a roster of CPU players? Shouldn't a team be penalized for not having adequate human players? If two QB's, 3 RB's and a kicker are all it takes to win a league shouldn't that be looked at as a potential exploit? (I know it's not a literal exploit, it's more of a metaphorical exploit much the same way Sb and SSB teams have been labeled.)

No matter how you look at this team and what it's doing it should be raising some eyebrows for one reason or another be it that there is something wrong with these CPU players and they are too strong for the opponents they have been facing, or the potential exploit that lies within what they're doing with carrying 6 human players.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Let's not bring this to a rant thread.

Earlier this season an 8-0 team lost to a 0-8 cpu player team.

It's working as intended.

CPU teams are easily beaten with good game plans and owners of CPU teams can really turn up the heat with a stable of RB's specifically at the lower levels. Let's stay on topic here or this is probably going to get locked.
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Let's not bring this to a rant thread.

Earlier this season an 8-0 team lost to a 0-8 cpu player team.

It's working as intended.

CPU teams are easily beaten with good game plans and owners of CPU teams can really turn up the heat with a stable of RB's specifically at the lower levels. Let's stay on topic here or this is probably going to get locked.


I'm not ranting. I'm just pointing out the elements of my argument that there is more going on here than meets the eye, and that even if there isn't this is potentially an issue which won't be beneficial for the quality of the game.
 
Androth
offline
Link
 
I did the crude math, just using the effective levels I can see and not adding up the total skill points, and only came up with an effective level of around 19.

Originally posted by Bort
Yes, they have a base level and expected salary based on the avg level of human players in the league.


Originally posted by Catch22
cpu players are better now. They represent average builds with EQ and VA's for their archetype. They do receive a penalty to all their attributes and do not apply skill points or VA's over the course of a season.


This is all I could find on the subject in QA. Based on this, and a brief look at the league, I'd say it should probably be lower then 21. No one seems to know exactly whether effective level includes CPU players, or when a CPU level is calculated. I'm going to mark this to have Catch22 look at it, but also open a file for needs more info. Even if this is incorrect, we may need more then one example



 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Effective level calculations for a team do not include CPU players. Not sure if that's what you're needing. If you need more, please post exactly what you would like for me to evaluate.
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Effective level calculations for a team do not include CPU players. Not sure if that's what you're needing. If you need more, please post exactly what you would like for me to evaluate.


I was unaware of that when making the original topic but Pwned IRL cleared that up, though that's not to say the problem is cleared up.

These CPU players seem much too strong. I know CPU players are better this season, but like I've said in previous posts, they are blowing teams out and playing pretty good defense for a defense full of CPU players.

They have had only two games within 21 points: a 21 point win over a decent team, and a close game against one of the leagues top two teams.

With an all CPU defense shouldn't they be struggling to win, or at least winning in close games? If the CPU players are averaging to the opposing team wouldn't there be at least one or two cases of an average opposing team getting close to beating them?

It's just quite odd that this team is having the level of success that it is with an all CPU defense. I've never seen anything like it in 18 seasons....
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by John Waylon
This team has 6 total players. Two QBs level 14 and 17, three RBs level 19 and the other two level 20, and a kicker at level 17.

They just played a game at a team effective level of 21 against a team who has one player at level 21, one player at 20, and the rest below. How does that happen?

The roster pages show the average level of player for the team in question at 20 compared to the team they just played at 17. If the CPU's level to the opposing team, why is the leveling so much different?

Is it possible that this team full of CPU players isn't leveling to the team they are playing? Every time I have scouted their games they have been effective level 21 and I would say I've scouted roughly half of their games this season and have never seen a team with any higher than an effective level of 18.. They have played ONE close game this season. The rest have been blowouts in their favor, and most not high scoring blowouts the way you would expect to see with a defense made up of all CPU players.

Here is the team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2759


He is playing with an all CPU team to make a point. CPU players match the level of every dot. He is game planning every game and crushing you because he has scaled dots.

This isn't a "Bug" because it is set up just like GLB wanted it to be. Suggest CPU players get scaled down.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
I hate doing the research for all of you, but yes, the CPU players are out performing their real life counterparts. I don't get paid to do it.... so it's up to you. But it is real.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.