User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Safeties set to -100 (all the way passive) pass rush aggressiveness cannot read a screen when blitzing. - NOT A BUG - #396
Page:
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
All the safeties on our team have assured me they've been set to -100 pass rush aggressiveness as requested since before the preseason began. All of these safeties have at least 85 effective vision. Here are the replays of all the screen passes thrown against us so far in which a safety was blitzing through the target area.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1401954 (SS is blocked early in the play for the whole play)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1404117 (FS runs right by the FB and does not react until the pass is caught)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1404953 (FS is chipped by HB, then blocked by LT, no direction change towards the FB)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1405012 (FS is chipped, then continues towards the QB as the ball is headed to the FB)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1406486 (FS is blocked by the LT during the blitz, block is held until FS is caked, after the completion)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1406506 (SS blitzes, breaks a block by the TE and continues toward the QB until the ball is caught)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1407329 (not sure what happens to the FS here, he freezes for some reason as the ball is thrown, then continues to the QB for a sec, then freezes again as the ball is caught...)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1407389 (SS is gang blocked... pointless)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521200&pbp_id=1407424 (FS blows by the FB again)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521199&pbp_id=783072 (FS pauses again as the pass is thrown, but continues to the QB)

It was my impression that -100 rush aggressiveness means they are looking for a screen pass first and foremost. This probably needs to be tested more thoroughly, but high quality safeties that helped their team earn its way into the WL should be able to read a screen when they're specifically trying to.
Edited by VolBrian on Jan 17, 2011 11:51:07 (Title Edit)
Edited by TruthHammer on Jan 17, 2011 11:23:32 (Needs coordinator. If there's not a bug with the sim, then there's one with the slider.)
Edited by rocklee711 on Jan 16, 2011 22:17:48 (2nd Verification - Agree, can't blitz a player and also expect them to read a screen.)
Edited by Rikkhen on Jan 16, 2011 20:43:52
Edited by Rikkhen on Jan 16, 2011 20:38:37 (Working as intended imo. Screen pass goes over blitzers head)
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ratphlegm
It was my impression that -100 rush aggressiveness means they are looking for a screen pass first and foremost. This probably needs to be tested more thoroughly, but high quality safeties that helped their team earn its way into the WL should be able to read a screen when they're specifically trying to.


Screens are designed to bust a blitz. It's the DE's that need to be set at -100 pass aggressiveness to recognize a screen. You're specifically trying to blitz, not read a screen. I'm not sure why you think they should be able to do both things.


 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Screens are designed to bust a blitz. It's the DE's that need to be set at -100 pass aggressiveness to recognize a screen. You're specifically trying to blitz, not read a screen. I'm not sure why you think they should be able to do both things.
If I'm not trying to read a screen, why am I posting this, or had our safeties set to -100 in the first place? If it must be explained, I decided to try this because setting a defender to cover these screen targets in man just made them stand around waiting on the other side of the line of scrimmage... I thought maybe I could convince them to cover a screen in the backfield this way.

If only DE's are supposed to have the ability to read a screen, why does every defender have a pass rush aggressiveness slider?
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ratphlegm

If only DE's are supposed to have the ability to read a screen, why does every defender have a pass rush aggressiveness slider?


I don't think pass aggressiveness in regards to screen recognition ever really applied to players in the secondary. That would totally defeat the purpose of running screens. It only seems to work for DE's as far as screens go from what I have seen.



 
Bloodfart
offline
Link
 
it's retarded. if he sets it to -100 cause he's looking to shut down screens, and the fucking setting doesn't do shit, this brings into question what exactly is the setting for?
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
I don't think pass aggressiveness in regards to screen recognition ever really applied to players in the secondary. That would totally defeat the purpose of running screens. It only seems to work for DE's as far as screens go from what I have seen.

The whole reason the pass rush aggressiveness slider was implemented was because screens were overpowered. The other thing the slider does is reduce your player's chance of breaking a block while pass rushing (they really suck at it on -100)... so why would anyone want to use it if it doesn't provide anything positive for their player? Any player with the slider should be able to read a screen pass if set all the way passive.

Just because they read it doesn't mean they will always break up the pass or make the tackle considering short yardage monster + Yac attack + bruiser/slippery + whatever else is going to be active right then... and just because I'm blitzing the safety in that situation doesn't mean they have to throw a screen pass.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
I'm leaving these defenses in place at least til the end of preseason, so if necessary to get a response from a bugs mod, I'll keep posting all pertinent replays...
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ratphlegm
I'm leaving these defenses in place at least til the end of preseason, so if necessary to get a response from a bugs mod, I'll keep posting all pertinent replays...


You wont get a response from a Bug Mods, because the sim is working as is intended to. If you don't like how the sim is working you need to post in the Suggestions Forum.

I am not in any way diminishing your situation, I am merely telling you the only avenue to fix it.
 
Rikkhen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Screens are designed to bust a blitz. It's the DE's that need to be set at -100 pass aggressiveness to recognize a screen. You're specifically trying to blitz, not read a screen. I'm not sure why you think they should be able to do both things.




This is what i am seeing. In every replay i watched it looks like the QB threw the ball over the head of your blitzer. I am going to say working as intended and not likely a bug here.

 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
So, you're saying the pass rush aggressiveness slider present on the individual tactics page of all defenders is intended to do nothing at all for most of them?
 
rocklee711
offline
Link
 
So here's the deal, checked your replays out , fact is all of your replays you're pointing out a safety (FS or SS) that unless I'm mistake was pretty much instructed in the D play created to blitz..... that's going to be their movement, just because they're on 100 passive pass rush doesn't translate to them stopping their blitz and recognizing the screen.

Neither of those safeties are going to be expected to sniff the screen out when you're asking them to blitz.... if anything if you're gonna blitz them you might as well have them 100 aggressive otherwise they just hesitate as you pointed out in some of those replays. If they're gonna blitz and be on 100 passive... that just makes them blitzing less effective.... it has no bearing on them reading a screen play as that's not their responsibility.

Agree with Rikkhen it's not likely a bug.
Edited by rocklee711 on Jan 16, 2011 22:18:52
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rocklee711
just because they're on 100 passive pass rush doesn't translate to them stopping their blitz and recognizing the screen.


Back in the early days of the pass rush aggressiveness slider, this is exactly what it did. It worked for DE's for sure, and every defensive player was given this same tactics slider.

I'm kind of blown away that you guys think the pass rush slider ends should read:
(intentionally sucks at pass rushing) -100 -------------- 0 --------------- 100 (Is as good as can be while pass rushing)

Currently the description reads: "How aggressive will this player be when blitzing the QB? The more aggressive he is, the more likely he will be to break blocks, but also more likely to be fooled by screen passes." Nothing can be more likely than always, so if he's always fooled on -100 on the slider, it is not working as intended.

If it makes it easier to understand, it could be rewritten as "The less aggressive he is, the less likely he will be to break blocks, but also less likely to be fooled by screen passes."

This thread isn't about should the safeties be able to read screen while blitzing, the pass rush aggressiveness slider's existence on their tactics page already confirms that.
 
Bluehaze
offline
Link
 
Maybe that FS needs more vision. 94+ vision, and 12 in Super Vision isn't enough.

I totally agree with Ratphlegm. If the setting to -100 is not able to stop a screen, why have it at all? At -100, the player should penetrate into the backfield, and watch for the play to develop while blitzing. Thus giving him (the blitzing safety) the option of continuing to blitz, or cover the screen (providing he has the vision to understand the unfolding play).

DEs are typically set up to blitz, and yet when they are set to -100, they can pick up the screen (with much lower vision than a safety typically has)?!?! Something seems broken here.
 
Azteaki
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bluehaze
DEs are typically set up to blitz, and yet when they are set to -100, they can pick up the screen (with much lower vision than a safety typically has)?!?! Something seems broken here.


This.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rocklee711
So here's the deal, checked your replays out , fact is all of your replays you're pointing out a safety (FS or SS) that unless I'm mistake was pretty much instructed in the D play created to blitz..... that's going to be their movement, just because they're on 100 passive pass rush doesn't translate to them stopping their blitz and recognizing the screen.


Then the slider should be removed from all but DEs tactic settings page. It's on every player because when it was released it was theoretically supposed to affect the blitz / screen recognition for all players. The response that "...was pretty much instructed in the D play created to blitz..." is lame. Every DE blitzes every single down and still can occasionally break off and "see" a screen when slider set to -100. The same is supposed to be the case for all blitzing players.

Did that now get removed as well?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.