User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > QB run- not waiting for blockers - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508912&pbp_id=14749849 Try that. Thanks for the patience y'all.....
Same as last season. The runners usage of blockers is just terrible/non-existant everywhere. KO's anyone? The backs are constantly looking for and going after blocking targets up the middle instead of getting to the edge being the priority. The QB has got to get on a blockers butt first for a couple of steps at least. Outside QB running is limited to just a few plays that occasionally work mostly because of bad blocking code.
Edited by TruthHammer on Jan 14, 2011 11:31:23 (OP took VolBrian's advice and took this discussion to the suggestions forum. Closing.)
Edited by VolBrian on Jan 5, 2011 12:46:42 (Reason in thread)
Edited by dbreeze on Jan 5, 2011 09:55:53
Edited by dbreeze on Jan 5, 2011 09:38:41
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Wrong link again.
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
turn off ur gresey monkey
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
I honestly don't think this is necessarily a bug. I know it's been determined as such before I would like to know the speed on the FB, but it really just looks like a good defensive call to me.

Without that SS blitz and with a faster FB, this is likely a TD. The only that doesn't like quite right compared to the play diagram is that the HB doesn't quite get to the edge, but he really is just looking for the nearest threat which in this case is the LOLB that is stuck in the line of scrimmage.

With all that said, maybe the blocking scheme on this will be included in the revision being down with the DPC adjustment, but as of right now it resembles the play diagram to me.

Not likely a bug
 
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I honestly don't think this is necessarily a bug. I know it's been determined as such before I would like to know the speed on the FB, but it really just looks like a good defensive call to me.

Without that SS blitz and with a faster FB, this is likely a TD. The only that doesn't like quite right compared to the play diagram is that the HB doesn't quite get to the edge, but he really is just looking for the nearest threat which in this case is the LOLB that is stuck in the line of scrimmage.

With all that said, maybe the blocking scheme on this will be included in the revision being down with the DPC adjustment, but as of right now it resembles the play diagram to me.

Not likely a bug


could also relate to the FB blocking bug: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4253748
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
could also relate to the FB blocking bug: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4253748


I don't really think so considering the players in this particular replay are following the design of the play while the FB's in that filed thread just run in circles looking for someone to block.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
There really is no "throttle back" mode for players. So if you have a QB with 120 speed and you use a HB and FB with 70 speed, the QB is going to outrun them.

As for what the HB was doing. If you step by step watch the OT/DE interaction the frame before the play ends the DE moves closer to the OT while the OT doesn't move. The HB may have been reacting to the OT about to fail his block but since the play ended there we can't really know. The QB outran the FB and as Volbrian said, without the SS blitzing and a faster FB, he would have had a good shot at the end zone.

 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
There really is no "throttle back" mode for players.


^^^ Well said.

It would make a nice suggestion though.
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Here's the FB's #'s. The HB is our fastest.
The problems are that if there's not a blitzer sitting in a gap waiting to shoot the back field then the FB/HB need to just get to the edge ASAP.
And, I don't care how fast the FB is, the first thing I want my QB to do is get on his butt for a second. Then it's my bad if I don't get a fast enough FB in there. Without logic to get the runner behind the blockers first instead of shooting out without a care for where the blockers are this is just a bad play design. It'll never happen like that IRL. A FB may be too slow for the play to work IRL, but the QB will never say "the heck with him, I want a grill full of LB/SS/CB...NOW".
I've seen and discussed this on QB runs and also KR's for a while. There appears to be no decent logic to get a runner to use his blockers more effectively. Give the blockers more of set route to take if there's no pre-snap reads to handle and let the QB read and react some more instead of face-planting a defender because he's stuck on a path.
Strength:
97.74 (+12)
Blocking:
56.74 (+1)
Speed:
95 (+20)
Tackling:
18.16
Agility:
78.74 (+6)
Throwing:
8
Jumping:
27
Catching:
34.16
Stamina:
46.16
Carrying:
61.74
Vision:
59.16
Kicking:
8
Confidence:
47.16
Punting:
8
Edited by dbreeze on Jan 5, 2011 13:45:58
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dbreeze
Without logic to get the runner behind the blockers first instead of shooting out without a care for where the blockers are this is just a bad play design. It'll never happen like that IRL. A FB may be too slow for the play to work IRL, but the QB will never say "the heck with him, I want a grill full of LB/SS/CB...NOW".
I've seen and discussed this on QB runs and also KR's for a while. There appears to be no decent logic to get a runner to use his blockers more effectively.


This would be very difficult to program. Bort seems to have handled it on outside HB runs by giving the FB a head start, like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1503520&pbp_id=12917748. The HB doesn't move for 6 ticks. On the QB run, the FB doesn't get the head start, and the QB catches him too quickly.

This is still a suggestion and not a bug though.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
FB has decent speed for sure, but what's the QB's?
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
FB has decent speed for sure, but what's the QB's?

Nothing extraordinary but my point is there's some initial logic failure by not forcing the QB to chase a spot 1/2 yard behind the FB for his first few steps. The FB should determine the play path by leading instead of immediately looking for someone in the middle materializing when they weren't there pre-snap. Maybe not a bug because "that's how it's s'posed to work" but a crappy play design nonetheless.
I'll also take this opportunity to say that if Bort would push more blocking controls/options out to us we could fix this and we could likely keep the full DPC also.

Strength:
46.41
Blocking:
8
Speed:
97.46 (+28)
Tackling:
8
Agility:
74.13
Throwing:
92.08 (+16)
Jumping:
14.95
Catching:
14.95
Stamina:
43.9
Carrying:
49.46
Vision:
74.08
Kicking:
8
Confidence:
48.41
Punting:
8
 
Rikkhen
offline
Link
 
What is the HB's blocking at if i may ask?
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rikkhen
What is the HB's blocking at if i may ask?


It's in the teens. Strength in the 50's. He's there for his speed to try to get in front of the QB make this play work. But it's not working. It's just a poorly designed play due to the logic that has the blockers looking for targets immediately after the snap while the QB is immediately heading on his "path" with no regard for the blockers.
I'm thinking there should be pre-snap reads for everyone to try to pick up blitzers sitting in gaps to shoot the backfield. Let the FB take any of those reads first and then the HB if there's more to pick up. If there's no threat read pre-snap then send the blockers immediately on their path towards a spot nearer the edge where they can resume looking for targets. Have the QB chase the HB for a few steps unless he reads multiple gap blitzers pre-snap also.
Part of the solution could be in a slider for runners with "follow a lead blocker until the blocker contacts a defender" at one end and "ignore blockers completely and just freelance" at the other end.
 
Rikkhen
offline
Link
 
I was just thinking that the low blocking could have something to do with him choosing to block the wrong dot.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.