User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Southeast Asia AAA Leagues > Southeast Asia AAA #2 > Pro Bowl/MVP ideas for this season here
Page:
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Since last season took awhile to get everyone to agree, and then we didn't get full participation, wanted to get this started early this season.

How do you guys want to run this this season? Same as last? For those that weren't here this is what we did.

Two threads (one for alpha squad, one for zeta) and 1 vote per team per position for 2 pro bowl squads. Votes were counted the day of the first playoff game. All votes were placed in the threads so that no funny business could go down and I counted all the votes before the playoff game as said.

MVP voting didn't have enough interest so we didn't do it.

What's the ideas for this season? Any new ones or staying with last years formula?
 
Raider Nation
offline
Link
 
And there was no voting for players on your own team.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Raider Nation
And there was no voting for players on your own team.


good catch forgot to add that
 
Coach_Schaar
offline
Link
 
What about each team should be represented
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
tough to do that if its like last season, some teams get gutted or are just begining and don't really put up pro bowl numbers all the time. not a bad thought, just don't know how it could be done fairly. Any suggestions on how to? Did you guys run a vote in A last season? How'd you do that one if you did? the ballots looked like this last season just so the new guys know

QB
HB
FB
TE
WR
WR
T
T
G
G
C


DT
DT
DE
DE
LB
LB
LB
CB
CB
SS
FS

K
P
KR
PR

I had asked peopel to try to pick people for there positions(example MLB for a MLB, NT for a NT) but if they thought someone else(say a DT at NT) was more deserving they could vote for that person.

Any ideas on if we want to change these? Last season was a bit difficult for some teams so would be nice to make it a tad easier. We got plenty of time just wanted to get this discussion rolling earlier this season as last season had some problems when we started late.
Last edited Jun 21, 2008 16:33:14
 
Raider Nation
offline
Link
 
I kind of like having a player from each team represented, because it gets people to look at teams they would normally look at.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Raider Nation
I kind of like having a player from each team represented, because it gets people to look at teams they would normally look at.


its a good idea but how do you implement it into a vote? It was a pain in the ass just getting people to vote AT ALL last season. I want to make this easier not harder. If there's a good way to do it and make it easy i'm all for it as it's a good idea.
 
Link
 
Well Is it just a fill in Ballot or do people nominate players and then we all vote or what?
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
was just a fill in ballot last year for owners(aka 1 ballot per team, not voting for your own players) last season
 
Link
 
Well the fill in Ballot will require a good bit of research. If each team nominates players from its own team that narrows it down as well as allows owners to reward certain players and get them recognition as well as makes it easier to vote on.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
If we were going to do a nomination ballot I wouldn't run a whole Pro Bowl squad for each league then as each team would just nominate it's starters most likely IMO.

So it depends if you guys want full Pro Bowl squads or just MVPs, or certain positions etc. Let me know, I personally like Pro Bowl squads, but will count votes for whatever the league decides, doesn't really matter to me
 
Link
 
No matter how u do it not everyone will be happy. This will reward the more active players but will definitely leave out those who are active but do not post much or do a whole lot so they might get overlooked. We just need several ideas and narrow it down.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by damngooddawg23
No matter how u do it not everyone will be happy. This will reward the more active players but will definitely leave out those who are active but do not post much or do a whole lot so they might get overlooked. We just need several ideas and narrow it down.


exactly.

So looks like as of now(and we got weeks to figure this out no rush)

Pro Bowl vote as last year

or

MVP vote(nominated by the teams)

or

Top players per position(nominated by the teams for QB/ Runner(Fbs/hbs)/ pass catchers(te/wr's) lineman/ Dlineman(1) Lbers(1) CB's(1) Safeties(1) return man/ k or p)?

or

other ideas as they come in

my main goal is to make it EASY for everyone. Last year was much to hard for me to get the amount of votes we even had and took too much time away from my team(luckily we had an easy ending schedule) Trying to make this easy for everyone involed is the main goal.
 
Link
 
I say you can handle every one of those without a problem. I see no reason not to have all three of those ideas.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by damngooddawg23
I say you can handle every one of those without a problem. I see no reason not to have all three of those ideas.


I ran the voting last year, trust me on this, we will have enough problems running one of these ideas
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.