User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Distance Runner and Second Wind - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
TheGreatAus
offline
Link
 
Im pretty sure they dont actually work. So maybe I should make this a suggestion to make them work...? Guys on my team that have them show no discernable difference in energy levels when they are both supposed to kick in, over several games I have noticed this.
Edited by VolBrian on Jan 3, 2011 11:33:30 (Closed)
Edited by VolBrian on Dec 20, 2010 15:22:14 (Needs lots of evidence)
Edited by VolBrian on Dec 20, 2010 10:07:06 (Closed)
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
you're probably right...
 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
i have distance runner on my LB and it seems to work just fine. Previously by the 2nd half his energy would be kaput and he wasnt any faster then the other LB's. Since adding distance runner he's able to maintain his speed for most if not all of the game.
Edited by Mavooo on Dec 18, 2010 08:40:52
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mavooo
i have distance runner on my LB and it seems to work just fine. Previously by the 2nd half his energy would be kaput and he wasnt any faster then the other LB's. Since adding distance runner he's able to maintain his speed for most if not all of the game.


got proof?
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatAus
Im pretty sure they dont actually work. So maybe I should make this a suggestion to make them work...? Guys on my team that have them show no discernable difference in energy levels when they are both supposed to kick in, over several games I have noticed this.


Yep, I agree. I have one center with 15 in the VA and the other Center with none. The Stamina and Strength of the Centers is pretty close, yet and game end, with the same number of plays, the center with no VA had one point more energy. Checking several games shows the same results.
 
crims
offline
Link
 
Distance Runner
Playing on kickoffs can take a lot out of you. Each level of Distance Runner lessens this player's energy usage on kickoffs and punts by 5%, except when playing KR/PR.
So it should only work on Kick Offs.

Second Wind
Crunch time brings out the best in some players. Each level of Second Wind gives the equivalent energy refill of an extra 10 seconds spent on the bench at the start of the second quarter, fourth quarter, and each overtime quarter.
Im not sure how much Energy goes up in Ten Seconds.
Edited by crims on Dec 18, 2010 14:11:02
Edited by crims on Dec 18, 2010 14:09:33
 
Greenday4537
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crims
Distance Runner
Playing on kickoffs can take a lot out of you. Each level of Distance Runner lessens this player's energy usage on kickoffs and punts by 5%, except when playing KR/PR.
So it should only work on Kick Offs.

Second Wind
Crunch time brings out the best in some players. Each level of Second Wind gives the equivalent energy refill of an extra 10 seconds spent on the bench at the start of the second quarter, fourth quarter, and each overtime quarter.
Im not sure how much Energy goes up in Ten Seconds.


Come on man, don't expect people to really read or analyze anything here.
 
MC_Hammer
offline
Link
 
can you provide examples of games that have players with and without it?
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
If you truly feel this is the case, you will need to provide substantial evidence supporting your claim including replays of players with and without the VA's in question, replays from different teams showing different positions, and replays showing differing levels of players.

This forum is not the place for a general discussion like this claim always leads to. Maybe try main and you'll get help with the evidence.

Re-opened to needs more info to allow for extensive evidence posting.
Edited by VolBrian on Dec 20, 2010 15:22:40
 
TheGreatAus
offline
Link
 
This was my first post in the builds forum I mod about Endurance based VA's that are not attribute based.

Originally posted by TheGreatAus
Im curious to see who has used these and had success.

On my power WR that is used on punt's and is a decent blocker has stamina of 39 and has 5 points in distance runner to prevent too much stamina drain.

My zone SS that is faster and made 8 tackles in his last game has 5 points in second wind, and his stamina is 41.

Both players in the last game played approximately the same amount of plays (WR had 42, SS had 39), but the finishing energies were 78 for the SS and 52 (!!!) for the WR. I know there stamina is still lowish, but it seems like the data is sound. I know they are on opposite sides of the ball and do different things, but the SS is about 14 points of speed faster and tackled a ton...

Thoughts? Anyone else use these?
 
TheGreatAus
offline
Link
 
Data for Distance Runner

QUOTE=TheGreatAus

A quick examination of Distance Runner:

Kickoff play:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1483080&pbp_id=6336038

The FS Tatanka B. Jonesin on the far left, and a SS on the middle right (I wont give away the build AND the name simultaneously, the build is below)

The FS does not touch anyone on the play. The SS gets some resistance and it looks like a block in the back, which both take down energy more than just running I would guess and have heard from people here...(if anyone else knows, chime in)

Start of play: The FS has 71 energy, the SS starts with 70.
End of play: The FS has 55 energy (16 dif), and the SS has 56 (14 dif)...
The FS has 47 stamina and the SS has 34 stamina.

Guess who has the 5 points in distance runner? The FS. Doesnt make sense, he lost even more energy than a SS who has LESS stamina AND no distance runner AND he gets blocked??? WTF is with that??

Another play: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1483080&pbp_id=6335952

Same guys, the FS does not get blocked, the SS does, and for a good amount of time.

FS starts with 74 energy, SS with 75 energy.
FS ends with 58 (16 dif), SS with 56 (19 dif).

The energy loss difference is almost the same as the previous play! Clearly blocking has an impact on energy loss. The AVERAGE for the two plays is 16 for the FS and 16 for the SS. This is simply bullshit. A FS with 47 stamina AND 5 points of distance runner should not lose the same amount of stamina as a guy with 34 stamina.

Here are the builds:

SS
Height: 75in. (6'3") Weight: Similar to Tatanka B. Jonesin
Speed: 104.56 (+24)
Agility: 57.45
Stamina: 34.45
Strength: 59.56 (for purposes dealing with blocking)

FS
75in. (6'3") Weight: 214lbs (He is lighter than the SS as well)
Speed: 101.52 (+15)
Agility: 62.45 (+13)
Stamina: 47.41
Strength: 65.6

So speed and agility are very close to the same, meaning top speed AND acceleration for both players are basically the same and shouldnt affect the overall energy loss on the characters any differently.

I know its a small data set, but this data shows that something is clearly fishy with energy loss on kickoffs and that Distance runner is basically bullshit.
Edited by TheGreatAus on Dec 20, 2010 16:39:03
 
TheGreatAus
offline
Link
 
Data for Second wind. Something of an effect is observed, albeit, quite small.

QUOTE=TheGreatAus
I just checked two plays of two defensive backs on my team to test the second wind VA. (small data set I know, but I have seen nothing else on this.)

I know you cant see the energy numbers, but maybe the admins can? These plays are literally back to back on the cusp of the 3rd and 4th quarter.

Q3 :http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1483104&pbp_id=3856226
SS Schooluv NRG: 74 at end of play
FS Raylan NRG: 71 at end of play
The SS has 5 points in second wind and 41.81 stamina, the FS has 40.84 stamina.

Q4 15:00: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1483059&pbp_id=6944760
SS at beginning of play: 80
FS at beginning of play: 75

The SS got 6 energy, the FS got 4 energy. Hmmm....is this trait even worth it...? Maybe at 15 it will give 10 energy back instead of only 6? Even then, is that worth it?

It would seem that this VA would compound with stamina. If a player with higher stamina gets more energy back on the bench in a given time than a player with less stamina, this VA would be more beneficial to guys with higher stamina anyway, and they are the ones who wouldnt even need it because they have higher stamina. Seems like a retarded ass VA to me, the rich get richer, and the tired stay, well, more tired...no?
Edited by TheGreatAus on Dec 20, 2010 16:39:14
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Been a while on this one and it's not really possible to prove this works or doesn't not conclusively hear.

Closed
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.