User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > allow 'fan' voting to count for half of MVP determination
darncat
offline
Link
 
even in the NFL they do this.
it already seems to be consensus that the MVP calculations are not very realistic.
this would improve that without requiring any script change on that part.
basically, the only difference would be that each season after game 16,
every agent with at least one player in the conference can vote on the MVP,
just like players do in the NFL, and the vote counts for half of the MVP determination,
with the computer ranking counting for the other half.

this would increase player interest and interaction within GLB,
while at the same time adding the human element and logic to the selection process
which would be very complex for a script to contain.
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Sounds great but it will not work. I have tried this before and what will happen is all the agents from a handful of teams will vote and agents with the rest of the teams will basically go without any representation due to lack of interest. Obviously the results will be skewed. I can promise you that the players in contention will be from the same few teams regardless of how they actually performed.

Not only that, but some teams will also not be represented due to the fact they have only a few agents that own all the players. Some teams have 1-5 agents while others have 40+.




Edited by Dub J on Dec 16, 2010 21:01:26
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
thats why it only counts for half the vote.

in addition to that, i can't see 40 agents on one team all voting for the player on their team.
if they did, they would be a lot more involved in the game then i believe they are now.

in addition, you'd only be able to vote for the top 5 from the computer rankings, or something to that effect.
Edited by darncat on Dec 16, 2010 21:19:06
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
If someone can start a thread in the team forum telling everyone to go to the league forum and troll a specific user and many with the team complying (which happens quite frequently), I'm sure someone will start a thread in the team forum telling everyone "let's all vote for ____ to make sure he is the top contender".
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
it would still only matter if the player was good enough in the first place to be in contention.

and was tom brady an MVP cuz he is the best or has the most fans?
thats how it goes sometimes...
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
i never said its a perfect solution. there is no perfect solution period to determine MVP.
but, i think it'd make a vast improvement.

in addition, you could allow each teams no more than say 10 votes.
that would keep away the possibility of it being skewed.
Edited by darncat on Dec 16, 2010 21:29:14
 
ManOgwaR
offline
Link
 
popularity contests are BS! ...the MVP would always be one of 3 or 4 glamour players on each team which dun need the acknowledgement
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
the MVP will always be one of 3 or 4 glamor players regardless...
the point is to have a check and balance for the sometimes nonsensical outcomes of the MVP rankings
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
ah forget it.
Edited by toobad4u_00 on Dec 17, 2010 10:32:53
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
I don't think this would enhance the game at all.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.