I mean that could tell you a lot more than with no replays, it can tell you if you need more vision or strength, don't wanna keep taking 50 yarders when you max 30. I'm a visual person so seeing the replays kind of helps me like that. My QB needs more strength if he under throws a receiver...etc...
Yeah, it looks like the ball goes "through" the uprights, but keep in mind, the field is not a truly 3-D image. The goalposts are just a flat 2-D representation of where the actual goalposts should be. Think of it as someone painting a picture of the goalpost there flat on the grass so that it would simply LOOK like a real 3-D set of goalposts when viewed from overhead.
When you think of it that way, that means that the football is always going to look like it's above whatever is painted on the ground. So, the football in this case only crossed the painted IMAGE of the crossbar on the grass below. The actual crossbar in this case was above the football.
Doesn't look short. If Novus' explanation were true, the goalpost crossbar should be "on top of" the football when it passes under it, but if you pause the frame, the football is still visible when it is "over" the crossbar.
Also, I've seen replays that were short, and they simply stop before they get there.
Originally posted by gocincinnati Doesn't look short. If Novus' explanation were true, the goalpost crossbar should be "on top of" the football when it passes under it, but if you pause the frame, the football is still visible when it is "over" the crossbar.
Actually, you've got my explanation reversed.
Keep in mind: THE FIELD IS NOT 3-D, and the goalposts are not 3-D either. It's a flat 2-D image that uses perspective tricks to LOOK like it's 3-D. Therefore, even if the football is just an inch off the ground, it will look like it's above everything: including the goalpost.
The actual goalpost is not there for you to see.
Originally posted by gocincinnati Also, I've seen replays that were short, and they simply stop before they get there.
Yes, you have... in cases where the ball hits the ground in the end zone. In THIS case, the ball crossed the back of the end zone but under the crossbar (the real crossbar that we don't actually see, not the fake 2-D flat drawing of the crossbar that we do see), and hit the ground about a yard behind the back of the end zone. Since it went under the real crossbar, that means the kick was short. No good.
in that one the ball does not even travel as far over the bar as it does in the OP. I think short is probably the correct answer but really there's no way for us to know, since this looks just like a made FG.
And as far as removing the replays, no thanks. I'd rather have the occasional bad one than not at all.
The crossbar is not 3d rendered, so if a dot gets near it you'll probably see the dot "higher" than the crossbar, but that does not mean it jumped 3 feet.
Novus has described the way this occurred about as well as possible. That explanation is far more comprehensive than just PBP > Replay, but both are accurate. I understand how it looks and why it can be so upsetting, but it's just not a bug.