User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > KICKOFF SPECIAL TEAMS
FersherHeheh
offline
Link
 
It seems that when the kicking team kicks the ball past the carrier on kickoffs that the tacklers will be caused to stop at the 40 yard line and wait for the ball carrier to pick up the live ball.
I have been informed by a moderator that this is not a bug, it is done intentionally and with good reasoning.

What I suggest is that the tacklers be allowed to progess a little further downfield, more slowly the usual, instead of stopping completely at a certain point. This would allow players to "game" more fairly while still allowing the admins to keep tabs on things too.

I hope this suggestion allows for perspective and clarity towards keeping us all grinning.

Thank you for your time,
Edited by FersherHeheh on Dec 4, 2010 11:38:17
Edited by FersherHeheh on Dec 4, 2010 11:37:56
Edited by FersherHeheh on Dec 4, 2010 09:40:00
Edited by FersherHeheh on Dec 4, 2010 09:39:53
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
+1 i understand why it is coded as such (since onside kicks aren't coded for), but i would add to the suggestion that all coverage players continue, and if they reach the ball before the returner that it is just downed like a punt.
 
ford351c594
offline
Link
 
I like it, and it seems kinda normal to be honest....
 
scottyxWINx
offline
Link
 
+1
 
iStoner
offline
Link
 
-1, there is a lot more to it than this seems to assume, if it worked without the stop they wouldn't have added it.
 
simpathia
offline
Link
 
+1, I don't see why the coverage team couldn't aim for the point where the ball is going to land
 
FersherHeheh
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1484133&pbp_id=9423627
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1484058&pbp_id=7591467
Edited by FersherHeheh on Dec 12, 2010 21:32:02
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by simpathia
+1, I don't see why the coverage team couldn't aim for the point where the ball is going to land


at least keep to their lanes as they do now, and then if there is a muff have them all converge on the ball rather than sitting at the 30. Maybe have them make a beeline for the ball but stop within 5 yards or something?
 
TKAlex
offline
Link
 
+1
 
ig
offline
Link
 
+1

I just saw it for the first time in my own team's game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1487121&pbp_id=11389283

I get why it's coded how it is, but the current code is not just avoiding exploits. Teams with decent coverage are being penalized by allowing players to get 5 or 10 yards out of position before the ball carrier finally decides to run with the ball. I know the sim isn't necessarily structured to replicate reality, but it's hard to see that it is merely "working as intended" when there would be no reason on a kickoff for a player to run 10 yards past the ball and the deepest player on the return team.

I think Clarka3's suggestions are right on point here.

1) Treat the kickoff as a punt
- If the goal is merely to minimize exploits, this may make the most sense to me. It's probably the easiest to implement and GLB has already introduced an artificial rule set by not allowing onside kicks. Treating the kickoff as a punt and allowing the kicking team to down the ball doesn't really cause any loss of reality, but doesn't penalize the team for good coverage by the gunners.

2) Place a halo around the ball but direct players towards the bouncing/resting ball.
- Alternatively, place a 2-5 yard halo around the ball and allow players to run towards the ball, but stop or slow down as they approach the ball. All or some of the players can keep their lanes until: (a) the ball bounces on the ground ; or (b) the ball stops moving downfield. At that point they can run towards the ball but stop if they reach the halo. Once the KR picks up the ball, they go back to the tackling/pursuit logic.
 
Jaxon Voom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ig
+1

I just saw it for the first time in my own team's game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1487121&pbp_id=11389283

I get why it's coded how it is, but the current code is not just avoiding exploits. Teams with decent coverage are being penalized by allowing players to get 5 or 10 yards out of position before the ball carrier finally decides to run with the ball. I know the sim isn't necessarily structured to replicate reality, but it's hard to see that it is merely "working as intended" when there would be no reason on a kickoff for a player to run 10 yards past the ball and the deepest player on the return team.

I think Clarka3's suggestions are right on point here.

1) Treat the kickoff as a punt
- If the goal is merely to minimize exploits, this may make the most sense to me. It's probably the easiest to implement and GLB has already introduced an artificial rule set by not allowing onside kicks. Treating the kickoff as a punt and allowing the kicking team to down the ball doesn't really cause any loss of reality, but doesn't penalize the team for good coverage by the gunners.

2) Place a halo around the ball but direct players towards the bouncing/resting ball.
- Alternatively, place a 2-5 yard halo around the ball and allow players to run towards the ball, but stop or slow down as they approach the ball. All or some of the players can keep their lanes until: (a) the ball bounces on the ground ; or (b) the ball stops moving downfield. At that point they can run towards the ball but stop if they reach the halo. Once the KR picks up the ball, they go back to the tackling/pursuit logic.


All this.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.