User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #2 > Interesting ranking system i'm stealing from SA AA #1
Page:
 
husker4life
GBR
offline
Link
 
This system is not subjective and is based upon what the teams have proven on the field. The way that I did this is that teams "capture" the wins of the teams they have beaten and "absorb" the loses of the teams they have lost to. I will use the Sooner Stomping Grounds as an example. They are currently 3-2. The teams they beat had 1, 4, and 0 wins for a total of +5. The teams they lost to had 0 and 1 loses for a total of -1. 5-1=4, so they have 4 points. Another example is the Guadalahara Water Works who are 4-1. They beat teams with 0, 0, 0 and 1 win for +1 and lost to a team with 1 loss for a total of -1. 1-1=0. Then you take the answer and add the teams win total. I ranked all 32 teams using this system. Here it goes. This system is heavily weighted toward strength of schedule and wins and loses to determine rankings. Point differential means nothing in this system. However i will come up with a point differential system, i will start posting my power rankings, this forum will be 1/3 of my power rankings, margin of victory will be 1/3 and then my personal opinion, i will rank each one 1-32 and then add up the scores each team got and divide that by 3 and that is where the team is on power rankings

i will post SA AA #2 below.......tell me if you like this method and i'll tweak it to make it our own
Last edited Jun 21, 2008 05:07:04
 
husker4life
GBR
offline
Link
 
1. Shaolin KillahBeez +11 Zeta
2. Death Valley Fightin' Tigers +10 Alpha
t3. Demon Llamas + 8 Zeta
t3. Fortaleza Underdogz +8 Alpha
t3. Maracaibo Stingrays +8 Zeta
6. Vegemite Orchestra +7 Alpha
t7. Lima Vipers +6 Alpha
t7. Maracaibo Maulers+6 Alpha
9. Montevideo Storm Vermin +5 Zeta
10. Sao Paulo Knights Templar +4 Zeta
t11. Belo Horizonte Kings +3 Alpha
t11. Guayaquil Iguanas +3 Zeta
t11. South Shore Slammers +3 Zeta
t11. Cusco Incas +3 Alpha
t11. Panama City Painrainers +3 Zeta
t11. Columbia Cartel +3 Zeta
t17. Galicia Nunca Mais +2 Alpha
t17. Salvador Dalis +2 Alpha
t19. Tenochtitlan Revenge +1 Alpha
t19. Medellin Massacre +1 Zeta
t19. La Paz Sentinals +1 Alpha
t19. Serious Business +1 Zeta
23. Manaus Piranhas 0 Alpha
t24. Nazca Liners -2 Alpha
t24. The Swamp -2 Zeta
26. Sao Paulo Pollinators -2 Alpha
27. Santa Cruz Banana Slugs -3 Zeta
t28. São Paulo Sharks -4 Zeta
t28. Sao Paulo Scientologists -4 Zeta
30. Lima Gigantes -5 Alpha
31. Bogota Snow Blowers -7 Zeta
32. Montezuma's Revenge -8 Alpha
 
RyguyRB
offline
Link
 
hrmmm not sure how I feel about this. Would be interesting to look at throughout the season, but pretty inaccurate too. it is almost entirely based on SoS, which is entirely out of the players hands. undefeated teams are ranked below teams with losses (stingrays, maulers). Still, if its done, id look at it
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
I guess I can deal with 2nd place
 
masqu3rade
offline
Link
 
I'm okay with a tie for third...

I agree with RyguyRB though; this will be pretty inaccurate until the end of the season. (DEMON LLAMA! should not be third in the whole league and the killerbees should not be first)

Demon Llama?
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Actually, as the season plays out, I think that this method will prove to be pretty close to how the team rankings play out... As each week goes by the system will be more and more reliable.

Its not a system designed for a few games, but a cumulative effect of taking a big sample from everyones quality of wins and quality of losses...

Works for me..

Can't think of anything else that wouldnt require Husker to spend hours on it...

Good work..

Thanks..
 
RyguyRB
offline
Link
 
not sure if i agree with that though tiger. Look at, for instance, the stingrays schedule. For the next 4-5 weeks we play teams that have 1 or 0 wins. Even if we win out and are 10-0, theres a good possibility that we would be ranked... not even in the top 10 until week 13 or so? Im just using the rays as an example because I know their schedule, Im sure the same type of thing would happen with other teams
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
Same for the Iguanas, RyguyRB.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyguyRB
not sure if i agree with that though tiger. Look at, for instance, the stingrays schedule. For the next 4-5 weeks we play teams that have 1 or 0 wins. Even if we win out and are 10-0, theres a good possibility that we would be ranked... not even in the top 10 until week 13 or so? Im just using the rays as an example because I know their schedule, Im sure the same type of thing would happen with other teams


The only ranking you need to worry about is your ranking in Zeta which will probably be 1st.
Last edited Jun 21, 2008 22:26:46
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyguyRB
not sure if i agree with that though tiger. Look at, for instance, the stingrays schedule. For the next 4-5 weeks we play teams that have 1 or 0 wins. Even if we win out and are 10-0, theres a good possibility that we would be ranked... not even in the top 10 until week 13 or so? Im just using the rays as an example because I know their schedule, Im sure the same type of thing would happen with other teams



I can see where there might be a few instances this doesnt work right... But like MRIGUY said.. you will be 1st in Zeta... all of us Alpha boys already know that

Regardless of the records in Zeta your team would be right in the thick of it in Alpha too.. you have built a great team...

A few others in Zeta as well... however, not to knock the other good teams, but the Stingrays.. Like the Maulers... are the cream of both Divisions...
 
RyguyRB
offline
Link
 
Yea I didnt mean that as a "omg the stingrays have to be 1" kinda thing. Just used us as an example of how the system is a little flawed
 
husker4life
GBR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by RyguyRB

not sure if i agree with that though tiger. Look at, for instance, the stingrays schedule. For the next 4-5 weeks we play teams that have 1 or 0 wins. Even if we win out and are 10-0, theres a good possibility that we would be ranked... not even in the top 10 until week 13 or so? Im just using the rays as an example because I know their schedule, Im sure the same type of thing would happen with other teams



I can see where there might be a few instances this doesnt work right... But like MRIGUY said.. you will be 1st in Zeta... all of us Alpha boys already know that

Regardless of the records in Zeta your team would be right in the thick of it in Alpha too.. you have built a great team...

A few others in Zeta as well... however, not to knock the other good teams, but the Stingrays.. Like the Maulers... are the cream of both Divisions...


hahaha, who are you kidding there in death valley? everyone knows it's
1. Death Valley Fightin' Tigers
2. Lima Vipers
3. Maracaibo Maulers

the computers rankings like the BCS are flawed but you guys as i have said many times are the team to beat, this year and next, all the way up to the pros
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Mark it down Husker.. This is how it plays out by year end...

1. Maracaibo Maulers
2. Lima Vipers
3. Cusco Incas
4. Death Valley

One year away

Maulers are flawed like a Bo Pelini Defense! There are no flaws... Still pissed that we lost him, but he deserves his chance to be the head man....


 
dshban
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Mark it down Husker.. This is how it plays out by year end...

1. Maracaibo Maulers
2. Lima Vipers
3. Cusco Incas
4. Death Valley


O rly? The Orchestra might have something to say about that.
 
RyguyRB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by husker4life


the computers rankings like the BCS are flawed but you guys as i have said many times are the team to beat, this year and next, all the way up to the pros


Im absolutely speechless. You just related your own ranking system to the BCS... how bad is that?! lol. With all fairness to you, I dont think any system could ever be as bad as the BCS.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.