There has been much praise heaped on the passing game changes by the World League elite (see http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4380780) - but what about the rest of us? I decided to do some quick stats on the passing game in the other leagues - and the quick summary: it looks like a disaster.
I selected 5 leagues, APL, AA#1, EM#46, EM#38 and EM#30 (basically, the lefthand league in the list and taking every other cap). Since this includes the Elite Minor leagues each time it should show the outcome for reasonably good teams. I excluded games where the margin of victory was greater than 70 points and just did the most recent pre-season week of games.
The results are:
APL (Africa Pro)
Average completion percentage: 45%
Average passes complete per team per game: 14.9
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 38%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 33%
AA#1
Average completion percentage: 42%
Average passes complete per team per game: 14.1
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 10%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 25%
EM#46
Average completion percentage: 42%
Average passes complete per team per game: 12.71
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 28%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 47%
EM#38
Average completion percentage: 39%
Average passes complete per team per game: 10.1
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 21%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 32%
EM#30
Average completion percentage: 37%
Average passes complete per team per game: 9.8
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 10%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 45%
ANALYSIS
Passing does not work properly. It is unrealistically bad in APL but declines almost smoothly as you go down the leagues. NONE of these leagues has an average completion percentage of over 45% and the pass completions per game are a real shock - given that GLB has far more plays per game than a 'real' game for teams to be averaging between around 10-12 completions per team per game in the upper minors means that passing is massively underpowered.
What is even worse is that, from AA down, you are more likely to complete less than 35% of your passes than to complete more than 50%. Is JaMarcus Russell playing for everyone??
A few things to note:
1. Lower level teams were LESS likely to be following the old WL practice of throwing deep constantly since this approach required elite builds and, in particular, stacking AEQ which lower level teams do not have at the same levels. Therefore, although co-ordinators may change their gameplans a bit in response to the changes, I would guess that they were more likely to have been running a balanced gameplan anyway.
2. I did not have the time to work out yards per attempt etc, but there is not a great deal of point. If it did show that yards per completion were high and offset the low completion percentage it would just prove that the recent changes did not work, since they were mainly designed to stop people heaving the ball deep all the time.
3. Watching the gamefilm, it seems to me that the timing of the passing game is out. Obviously Bort tested all his changes on the WL builds, but the relative speeds are completely different than for other leagues. From what I have seen, QBs are still throwing too late, leading their receivers into coverage, ignoring open receivers on short patterns and going through their progressions in an unrealistic manner.
4. I should have gone down below level 30 but ran out of time, but the trend was pretty clear by then. I am sure that Bort and Catch could do these sorts of analyses in far more detail in just a few minutes. Are they actually doing this?
In summary, the passing changes have reduced scores across the leagues to slightly more sensible levels (there were actually not that many games decided by more than 70 points). However, it seems to have achieved this by simply murdering the passing game to keep the scores down - so the outcome is frankly no more realistic than before. The game balance for passing needs urgent attention before the start of the season.
I selected 5 leagues, APL, AA#1, EM#46, EM#38 and EM#30 (basically, the lefthand league in the list and taking every other cap). Since this includes the Elite Minor leagues each time it should show the outcome for reasonably good teams. I excluded games where the margin of victory was greater than 70 points and just did the most recent pre-season week of games.
The results are:
APL (Africa Pro)
Average completion percentage: 45%
Average passes complete per team per game: 14.9
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 38%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 33%
AA#1
Average completion percentage: 42%
Average passes complete per team per game: 14.1
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 10%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 25%
EM#46
Average completion percentage: 42%
Average passes complete per team per game: 12.71
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 28%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 47%
EM#38
Average completion percentage: 39%
Average passes complete per team per game: 10.1
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 21%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 32%
EM#30
Average completion percentage: 37%
Average passes complete per team per game: 9.8
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 10%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 45%
ANALYSIS
Passing does not work properly. It is unrealistically bad in APL but declines almost smoothly as you go down the leagues. NONE of these leagues has an average completion percentage of over 45% and the pass completions per game are a real shock - given that GLB has far more plays per game than a 'real' game for teams to be averaging between around 10-12 completions per team per game in the upper minors means that passing is massively underpowered.
What is even worse is that, from AA down, you are more likely to complete less than 35% of your passes than to complete more than 50%. Is JaMarcus Russell playing for everyone??
A few things to note:
1. Lower level teams were LESS likely to be following the old WL practice of throwing deep constantly since this approach required elite builds and, in particular, stacking AEQ which lower level teams do not have at the same levels. Therefore, although co-ordinators may change their gameplans a bit in response to the changes, I would guess that they were more likely to have been running a balanced gameplan anyway.
2. I did not have the time to work out yards per attempt etc, but there is not a great deal of point. If it did show that yards per completion were high and offset the low completion percentage it would just prove that the recent changes did not work, since they were mainly designed to stop people heaving the ball deep all the time.
3. Watching the gamefilm, it seems to me that the timing of the passing game is out. Obviously Bort tested all his changes on the WL builds, but the relative speeds are completely different than for other leagues. From what I have seen, QBs are still throwing too late, leading their receivers into coverage, ignoring open receivers on short patterns and going through their progressions in an unrealistic manner.
4. I should have gone down below level 30 but ran out of time, but the trend was pretty clear by then. I am sure that Bort and Catch could do these sorts of analyses in far more detail in just a few minutes. Are they actually doing this?
In summary, the passing changes have reduced scores across the leagues to slightly more sensible levels (there were actually not that many games decided by more than 70 points). However, it seems to have achieved this by simply murdering the passing game to keep the scores down - so the outcome is frankly no more realistic than before. The game balance for passing needs urgent attention before the start of the season.






























