User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > OAI Got "Stuck" and only called 1 play from each package - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Just had a game with this team http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=728 and the AI play calling was completely off.

Scouting to show play calls. http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=728&m=offense&for_team_id=0

Each time either my power back or elusive back package was called it played a specific play. This play got called 14 times, mostly for the PB who as far as I could tell never ran anything else from this package call. It also meant depsite a normally balanced left/right strategy we ran 95% left, only running right when a separate package was called (my pitch package).

Now I figured I had messed up and left the play at 100% or something daft. But when I checked it, I hadn't. I ran the AI tester and got all normal results, calling a variety of packages. So I went back to the packages. Each one tally's to exactly 100%, the right players are called at all times and there are no duplicate plays.

Back to the AI to check there, all is as it was before this game when it worked as intended. I cannot understand how simply separating out my power back plays from my elusive back ones into two packages that are seemingly correct could have caused this. I changed no inputs on the AI, only outputs and the tester calls them all correctly.

I figure this must be a problem in the packages as they are called but the plays were not. However I cannot find an issue. Its almost as if the AI simply got "stuck" on a specific play. Seemingly everything got updated as it should have when I did it earlier today and it was all done a couple of hours before sim time.

Since I can't find a fault I will be leaving everything as it is for next game. I'll see then if it happens again. In the mean time if anyone has any ideas or has experienced something similar info would be useful.

Thanks

Ara
Edited by VolBrian on Nov 17, 2010 07:07:50 (Closed)
Edited by VolBrian on Nov 15, 2010 08:21:28 (Needs more info)
 
GosuPho
offline
Link
 
For package, all play's at 100%?
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XoOxICE
For package, all play's at 100%?


Already answered in the above post but no. The play in question is a 25% call. Each package totals to exactly 100% when all plays are added together.
 
GosuPho
offline
Link
 
I think you should try with every play in the package at 100%
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XoOxICE
I think you should try with every play in the package at 100%


Why? I don't want them all called equally and I've never run a package like that since they were released for use. I must have designed over 100 offensive packages over the past few seasons for various teams and I've never had a problem before. Also I would assume that doing that would mean the first play on the list always got called, after all GLB uses a checkdown tree system for it's AI's.
 
dragonslade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arayel
Originally posted by XoOxICE

I think you should try with every play in the package at 100%


Why? I don't want them all called equally and I've never run a package like that since they were released for use. I must have designed over 100 offensive packages over the past few seasons for various teams and I've never had a problem before. Also I would assume that doing that would mean the first play on the list always got called, after all GLB uses a checkdown tree system for it's AI's.


Yeah I agree, what would setting every play to 100% solve? Just gonna mess up his settings.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Well wouldn't solve anything, but just a point, you don't need to have everything add up to 100%. It will scale all the numbers so that it comes out to 100% when the package is called.

But beyond that, did you have auto adjust on in your packages? Did you select "Enable Offense AI (required for these settings to work)" in your AI? Do you have auto adjust on in your basic tactics?

It just seems like an auto adjust type thing since it didn't only call this play all game long (which you would expect if you had some sort of AI bug) but it called it an excessive amount relative to your other plays.
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Well wouldn't solve anything, but just a point, you don't need to have everything add up to 100%. It will scale all the numbers so that it comes out to 100% when the package is called.

But beyond that, did you have auto adjust on in your packages? Did you select "Enable Offense AI (required for these settings to work)" in your AI? Do you have auto adjust on in your basic tactics?

It just seems like an auto adjust type thing since it didn't only call this play all game long (which you would expect if you had some sort of AI bug) but it called it an excessive amount relative to your other plays.


No Auto-Ajust anywhere, never have used it. Yes I had the AI enabled otherwise the different pacakges wouldn't have been called in the first place.

As far as I can tell every time this package was called that particular play got used. The player only ran another play when another package was called or another output on the AI.

I'm an experienced OC, I've run multiple teams since season 3 and have never come across a problem with an AI that I couldn't find a reason for. I did not come to this forum lightly. Another of my teams will be running the same package (slightly different setup though) later today so I shall see if it was an isolated incident then.

Thanks for the suggstions though
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Well, I'll just mark this needs more info and await the results of the second scrimmages before proceeding then.

Needs more info
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
The sim loves HB slam weak . You actually ran the play 20+ times in the first scrimmage, 14 or so in your 2nd game and averaged over 4 yards a carry in each game.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Check your playbook. Maybe accidentally you switch to a playbook which didn't contain the other plays.

 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Was auto adjust turned on?
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Check your playbook. Maybe accidentally you switch to a playbook which didn't contain the other plays.



Checked and still on the playbook that contains all plays in the book. I rely on my packages.

I didn't notice in the first game but perhaps I should have. I hadn't done my revamp of the packages so the offense was still running the same setup as the previous season, which if you look at previous games had nothing like these percentages for rushing, especially the 90% left balance. The final game of the previous season ran exactly 50-50 left and right with the same setup!

Ok so another of my offenses just played http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=479 and a similar result. Despite the package only calling the two major plays a total of 30% between them they account for nearly half the plays called the intire game. Not only that the AI called 85% left side plays in a setup that is deliberately balanced.

I'm now totally confused. If I hadn't been through everything over and over again I'd be convinced this was my error but I really can't find anything. It also confuses me that the opening game of the Iron-men also went this way using old packages that I hadn't touched.
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
Was auto adjust turned on?


No. Not for either team. I've answered this three times now
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Check your playbook. Maybe accidentally you switch to a playbook which didn't contain the other plays.



Yeah this just came to mind too. Since it is possible to have plays in packages not in your current playbook, perhaps you have a gap in coverage, reverting to a basic tactic and that is the only play available. If perhaps in the playbook you have only 1-2 plays available, it has to call one of those if the Basic ai decides that should be called (which it did often on 1st downs)

In the second half you called HB Slam weak on 1st down every time except once (on a 2nd down).

In the first half It was called on various second downs and once on 1st down late in the second.

I'd check though your AI for anything special happening in the 3rd or 4th quarters on 1st down. And also check 2nd down conditions for gaps in overall or for 1st/2nd Q specific.

Ah perhaps not, since you said in your post while i was typing that you did check your playbook. But i'd still check through those AI conditions, and see what your basic tactic settings are to see if you have anything unusual, like it being set to 100% run or something.
Edited by alindyl on Nov 15, 2010 13:39:07
Edited by alindyl on Nov 15, 2010 13:37:44
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.