User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Resolution of MVP - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Not a particularly big deal to me, but my dot - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=2011203 - was listed #1 in the ST MVP race yesterday and had a day-40 contract. The MVP trophy was just awarded to another dot, which - unlike mine - is signed through next season. Is it possible that MVP (and perhaps corporate endorsements) and contract end dates are being processed in the wrong order, or am I just misunderstanding the process here?
Edited by MC_Hammer on Nov 7, 2010 16:16:48 (support issue)
Edited by VolBrian on Nov 4, 2010 10:57:17 (Support issue)
Edited by Crawly on Nov 2, 2010 01:41:10
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
I've got a dot who was 2nd and got the endorsement....but didn't get the trophy gif....so there goes the idea that you finished 1st but didn't get the MVP or the endorsement...
 
shane827
offline
Link
 
the dots that finishes 1st gets the GIF. its a toss up between either the top 3 or 5 dots on who gets the EQ. i think it totally random
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
I've got a dot who was 2nd and got the endorsement....but didn't get the trophy gif....so there goes the idea that you finished 1st but didn't get the MVP or the endorsement...

I'm not sure I follow. Your dot, signed through season 19, finished second behind a dot that is also signed through season 19. That dot finished first and got the trophy GIF. You got the endorsement, which has nothing to do with who gets the trophy. My dot was listed as first yesterday, but is no longer listed in its conference's MVP race at all, since its contract ran out after day 40. I was under the impression that a day 40 contract was enough to get the MVP GIF, but it appears I was wrong.
 
shane827
offline
Link
 
the dots that finishes 1st gets the GIF. its a toss up between either the top 3 or 5 dots on who gets the EQ. i think it totally random

I got a KR/PR and the last 3 seasons finished 2nd, 1st, 2nd, and finally got the EQ for the first time this season

Edit - My dot signed a contract before the awards was handed out
Edited by shane827 on Nov 2, 2010 01:57:08
Edited by shane827 on Nov 2, 2010 01:55:59
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
I haven't seen anyone able to debunk this with a counterexample yet, and I asked/looked around. Trophies for stats work fine, but those are maintained at the league level - a player can win those even if they only played a single game for a team, in theory, and they will remain listed in the league stats. The issue, if there is one, seems to only pertain to MVP trophies (and possibly endorsements).
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
It's hard to say at this point what happened since neither you or the other players are in cap22 #5 anymore to see where you were in the rankings so there's no way to confirm one way or the other that you were in 1st place.

The ST players who received the equipment also did not receive trophies so perhaps it just hasn't happened yet.

Just for convenience, this is the league you were in http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=133
Can scroll to the bottom to see who won the equipment. Neither of those players have an MVP trophy. In fact none of the 6 equipment winners have an MVP trophy. It is very unlikely that, with the weighted lottery system in place, that none of the #1's would win equipment.

Likely issue is that the trophy gif haven't been handed out yet.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Likely issue is that the trophy gif haven't been handed out yet.

The trophy was handed out - it's on this dot right here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=2004730

I'm aware that there's no way to confirm my dot was #1 - but that's not an issue, as I really don't care much about getting the GIF in this case (it's a non-boosting throwaway KR/PR dot with one season left before age-based leagues make it obsolete). However, if there's an actual issue with the way these things are handled in the code (particularly if it also impacts who gets the endorsements, which have an actual in-game impact), I'd like to see it looked at.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
As we have no way to verify that your player was #1 in the standings at the end of the season, you'll have to go through support for this issue. Please file a ticket with them.

Not likely a bug - support issue
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
As we have no way to verify that your player was #1 in the standings at the end of the season, you'll have to go through support for this issue. Please file a ticket with them.

I am not concerned with my dot's specific trophy. I just figured there might be an issue, and wanted someone with code access to check and see if things are working as intended or not. I'm unsure as to why you have to decide that this is "NOT LIKELY A BUG" considering nobody has been able to come up with a counter-example or any indication that MVP trophy/endorsements are handed out before players with day-40 contracts are removed from rosters (thus rendering them ineligible for MVP trophies and endorsements), but I guess there's no way to have this actually looked at, so I'll drop the issue.
Edited by Crawly on Nov 4, 2010 11:32:47
Edited by Crawly on Nov 4, 2010 11:31:49
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crawly

nobody has been able to come up with a counter-example or any indication that MVP trophy/endorsements are handed out before players with day-40 contracts are removed from rosters


Simply because we, as Bugs Mods, have no way to verify that the said dots were rightfully winners of the various MVP races and should get the trophy. Only support can verify that.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Yeah if he was #1 he would have got the award. Contract end date doesn't have any affect. The guys below had better stats overall (blowout adjusted) so you were probably mistaken about him being #1. I know some leagues were weeks behind updating the MVP list so that is what may have happened to your player.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=2088516
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=2004730
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Yeah if he was #1 he would have got the award. Contract end date doesn't have any affect. The guys below had better stats overall (blowout adjusted) so you were probably mistaken about him being #1. I know some leagues were weeks behind updating the MVP list so that is what may have happened to your player.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=2088516
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=2004730

I've dropped the issue, but still feel obligated to point out:
1) Your assessment that he would have gotten the award if he was #1 is not based on any actual information that you've provided. What makes you so sure of this?
2) The guys below did have better stats, but since when does the MVP race care about that? My dot played on a terrible team where it was listed as the top-performing dot in virtually every game (excluding those where all five spots were occupied by opposition dots), which is factored into the MVP race.
3) This league updated its MVP, and I am not mistaken about his #1 ranking. The reason I can easily be so sure is that he was #2 until day 37 or so, which is when the #1 dot left the league. At this point, my dot was listed as #1 both in its "Award" page and the MVP race on the conference page. The dot that actually won the MVP race was originally listed #3, and was listed at #2 after the original leader left the league.

Since this post clearly is out of place in the 'bugs' forum, I'd like to request moderators lock it and move it to wherever bugs threads go to die.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
This might be the key point that you mention

"The reason I can easily be so sure is that he was #2 until day 37 or so, which is when the #1 dot left the league. At this point, my dot was listed as #1 both in its "Award" page and the MVP race on the conference page."

What happened is this- because he was no longer in the league at day 37, it didn't show him in the MVP rankings. However the rankings take into account the stats racked up by every player- whether in the league or not at that point- and determines the MVP.

So in fact you did not really move up to 1st place by stats, only by the fact that the MVP list only shows those currently in the league. Thats why when you look at the lists now, say here http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=13 you'll notice the MVP lists are incomplete. (and please, don't argue that it's because it's after day 41, i understand that, it's an example)

His stats were still valid for day 1-37. He would not earn any new stats in whatever league he ended up in on 37-40 (playoffs don't count toward MVP) so he was still eligible.

Make sense?
The TL;DR summary- Your player only appeared to be in 1st, but the 1st place player was simply not on the list because he left the league. but his stats were still there and part of the calculation.
Edited by alindyl on Nov 4, 2010 12:00:29
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Make sense?
The TL;DR summary- Your player only appeared to be in 1st, but the 1st place player was simply not on the list because he left the league. but his stats were still there and part of the calculation.

It would, except the trophy GIF went to the dot that was third before he left, and second after he left. This is stated in my post above.


[edit]As I consider this matter dropped, I will not be reading any more responses. Apologies to Bugs mods for continuing the discussion and cluttering up their forum
Edited by Crawly on Nov 4, 2010 12:04:53
Edited by Crawly on Nov 4, 2010 12:02:44
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.