User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
It appears to be higher than 40 seconds. Example, three consecutive QB kneels:


1:39 1st & G OPP 6.5 Teabag McJorts rush up the middle (1 yd loss)

(47 seconds elapse)

0:52 2nd & G OPP 7.5 Teabag McJorts rush up the middle (1 yd loss)

(47 seconds elapse)

0:05 3rd & G OPP 8.5 James Whistler rush up the middle (1 yd loss)


Am I missing something?
 
northstar09
fist flint
offline
Link
 
The playclock should start a few seconds after the previous play ends, but certainly not 7 seconds after. Seems a little weird.
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
bump
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
Goal Line Blitz is not affiliated with the NFL or any other professional football league.


?
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
What game was this from? i'm looking through a bunch and don't see this set of plays so far. A Link would be nice, unless it's a private scrim.
 
queenbee
offline
Link
 
maybe 7 seconds is the time it took the play to run.
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
A QB Kneel takes one to two seconds, max.
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Goal Line Blitz is not affiliated with the NFL or any other professional football league.


The assumption is that GLB uses a 40 second play clock because 'most' plays fall within this time frame. However, the official GLB play clock time is undocumented, as I've scoured the forums, GLB wiki, FAQs, and the changelog. This doesn't really have anything to do with the NFL, other then the fact they use a 40 second play clock.


Originally posted by alindyl
What game was this from? i'm looking through a bunch and don't see this set of plays so far. A Link would be nice, unless it's a private scrim.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1416772&mode=pbp

more examples (check the bottom, last plays):

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1416830&mode=pbp (47 sec)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1416784&mode=pbp (47 sec)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1416786&mode=pbp (47 sec)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1432512&mode=pbp (47 sec)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1416803&mode=pbp (3-4 second play running 49 seconds off the clock)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1416802&mode=pbp (3-4 second play running 49 seconds off the clock)

There are tons of examples out there, and in almost every game GLB there are several examples of a short, 2~4 second play executing, then 44+ seconds elapsing between the next play.

The actual play clock timer should be noted in the OAI, tactics page, FAQ, some where, but it's not. 40 seconds? 45? 47? 50?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by d1sregard
A QB Kneel takes one to two seconds, max.


In real football, doesn't the play clock actually start from the moment the referee sets the ball, rather than from the end of the previous play? I seem to recall that's how it's done.

Using your example... QB takes the snap at 1:39, and stands there for a second or two. 1:37. He takes a knee, which kills another second. 1:36. The referee jogs over to get the ball from the QB, but remember, the QB is trying to milk the clock, so he's not exactly going to be in a hurry to hand the ball back to the referee -- watch any college or NFL game, and you'll see the sorts of things the QB can do to eat up another second or two easily. 1:34. Ref finally gets the ball, but it takes him a second or two to set the ball and signal for the play clock to start. 1:32, and the 40-second clock starts.

And at 0:52, the QB takes the snap right as the 40-second clock is about to expire.

There's your 7 seconds right there, assuming GLB uses a 40-second play-clock.
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
In real football, doesn't the play clock actually start from the moment the referee sets the ball, rather than from the end of the previous play? I seem to recall that's how it's done.

Using your example... QB takes the snap at 1:39, and stands there for a second or two. 1:37. He takes a knee, which kills another second. 1:36. The referee jogs over to get the ball from the QB, but remember, the QB is trying to milk the clock, so he's not exactly going to be in a hurry to hand the ball back to the referee -- watch any college or NFL game, and you'll see the sorts of things the QB can do to eat up another second or two easily. 1:34. Ref finally gets the ball, but it takes him a second or two to set the ball and signal for the play clock to start. 1:32, and the 40-second clock starts.

And at 0:52, the QB takes the snap right as the 40-second clock is about to expire.

There's your 7 seconds right there, assuming GLB uses a 40-second play-clock.


I considered these things, still seems a bit too long, but that's fine with me. I wish the official time was documented some where accessible on this site.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Hmm... I checked Wikipedia just for giggles. Looks like college and the NFL are different.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Play_clock

"In amateur American football, teams have 25 seconds from the time the ball is declared ready for play." That would be when the ref sets the ball.

"In the NFL teams have 40 seconds timed from the end of the previous down, or 25 seconds after the ball is declared ready for play after certain administrative stoppages and game delays." From the end of the previous down would actually mean that the play clock does start right away, regardless of when the ref gets the ball set.

So, does GLB use a 40-second clock or a 45-second clock? And do they follow the NCAA rules of not starting the play clock until the ball is set, or the NFL rules of starting the play clock as soon as the previous play is dead?

Either way, looks like this question got complicated in a hurry.
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
Good post.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Just for additional data to this, there are 6 ticks (5 frames+initial tick) of time in play 1 and 5 ticks (4 frames +initial tick) in the 2nd. I couldn't get the third play because of the end of game graphics that pops up in flash. I think how long each frame is has been discussed, i don't recall it offhand what they were though. Maybe half a second per frame/tick

If there is a 45 second clock, and each tick were half a second, that would account for the 47 seconds coming off the clock on each kneeldown.

Perhaps see if you can get catch to answer how long the play clock and ticks are, in his ask catch forum, to get a better idea if there is any issue.
Edited by alindyl on Nov 1, 2010 21:52:10
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
bump
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I'm still not seeing the issue. A failure to figure out the length of the playclock?
Edited by Mat McBriar on Nov 2, 2010 21:10:59
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.