User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > there is no use for pass rush aggressiveness bar
zero
offline
Link
 
per VolBrian (not attacking you VB, just starting a discussion about it)

Originally posted by VolBrian
The passive/aggressive slider determines how aggressively the DE will try his blitz. The slider will tell the DE how much he should try and blitz. Even a "passive" DE will still blitz especially depending on what his assignment is in the defense.


Why have a blitzer who doesn't try? What happened to using -100 on the slider for stopping screens?
 
Sprocket
offline
Link
 
When did this change?
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sprocket
When did this change?


lol
 
Sal Basss
offline
Link
 
Hmm... haven't paid much attention to this in a long time. Had a DE once who sniffed out some screens pretty quick (in the screen era, no less) while being on 100. I don't think this bar has meant anything in a long time, it's just that nobody cared because screens were so pointless for so long.
 
ddingo
offline
Link
 
Many of the player tactics are stupid.

LOL @ being "run-focused" for an entire game. But yeah, OP is right. Ability to pick up a screen should be a vision-based check. This slider is lame.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zero
per VolBrian (not attacking you VB)


Actually you kind of are, but I'm a big boy, I can take it.

This issue is actually more related to this:

Sept 20, 2010
- Fix issue causing some QB's to throw a larger number of low screen passes
- Update pass blocking to handle overloads inside out
- Add 1 tick to blitzer base reaction time
- Increase reaction delay for blitzers after pass is thrown
- Increase difficulty of vision check for DE's sniffing out screen passes

I believe than the slider, but I'm probably gonna reopen that thread.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
zero, the bugs mods help out the game by organizing the Bugs forum and you come here and attack them like this? For shame
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
I don't believe this characterization is correct. Doesn't the slider give a penalty to breaking blocks in exchange for a bonus to the vision checks to recognize screens?
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Doesn't the slider give a penalty to breaking blocks in exchange for a bonus to the vision checks to recognize screens?


Yes, it does. Which is why I reopened the thread Zero is taking me to task over, but the real question is how much was the DE's Vision nerfed by the tougher check in the changelog? Does it invalidate the slider settings?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Does it invalidate the slider settings?

No. In fact, I imagine the intent was to make the slider settings even more important. Basically, DEs on 100 were still recognizing screens a fair amount of the time and blowing them up, so Bort decided to make that vision check tougher. So your 100 aggressiveness DE will now recognize screens much less frequently than he used to, which makes playing on another setting more viable if you're concerned about screens.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

No. In fact, I imagine the intent was to make the slider settings even more important. Basically, DEs on 100 were still recognizing screens a fair amount of the time and blowing them up, so Bort decided to make that vision check tougher. So your 100 aggressiveness DE will now recognize screens much less frequently than he used to, which makes playing on another setting more viable if you're concerned about screens.


True. So, what I'll need over there is more examples from other "passive" DE's to make sure that the slider is still working at all.

Obviously if we have a bunch of passive DE's getting fooled every time than something is screwed up.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
True. So, what I'll need over there is more examples from other "passive" DE's to make sure that the slider is still working at all. Obviously if we have a bunch of passive DE's getting fooled every time than something is screwed up.

Yeah. -100 was never intended to let you pass those vision checks every time, the question becomes how much of a benefit does it provide. Personally I wish that instead of a flat penalty to passing those vision checks, Bort would have scaled it according to the slider. Basically, have it so that 100 is 20% less likely to pass the vision check than it used to be, 0 would be 10% less likely, and -100 would be 0% less likely. That would only increase the value of the -100 setting, whereas this change may or may not have. The problem, as always, is how you balance the bonus from -100 to vision checks with the penalty to breaking blocks. If the penalty is not very large (and I do not believe that it is), then it's hard to justify the bonus being very large.

 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ddingo
Many of the player tactics are stupid.

LOL @ being "run-focused" for an entire game. But yeah, OP is right. Ability to pick up a screen should be a vision-based check. This slider is lame.


Actually, think of those sorts of sliders as build choices for your dot. You're slapping on some +run detect vision goggles EQ, but they come with -pass detect vision. Your C is putting on some +run blocking gloves for the game, but they have -pass blocking on them too. That sort of thing.

...but unlike every other build option, these aren't set in stone. You can change them EVERY GAME. So it's not AEQ that is essentially welded onto your player when you buy it, or SP that's spent into an attribute never to be recovered if you decide it's spent wrong.

I've found they're less annoying when I think of them like that and less like actual football play tactics that you would naturally change from game to game.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
I've found they're less annoying when I think of them like that and less like actual football play tactics that you would naturally change from game to game.

Yeah, they were intended to add a little strategy. So back in the day you might have your defense set on pass focus versus NBA Jam Arcade, whereas they might be on run focus versus MPHD. Now it seems like teams rarely change tactics that often, but I remember using them in that fashion long ago.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.