User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Team scout game issue - DUPLICATE THREAD - CLOSED
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Haven't seen this recently and only looks to be an issue in one game.

Scouted this game from both teams involved and get same results.
This is the game:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1371539

Adding summary:
The number of left/right runs for both inside and outside plays does not match the total number of inside or outside plays.
Inside runs - 21
Inside left - 6
Inside right - 0
Outside runs - 17
Outside left - 0
Outside right - 4

I've looked at these results on two different computers, and have had the results verified by another agent...

Both Boston offense and LUX defense scouting provides run data that does not match:
Both show Boston to have run 38 HB plays.
Both show 21 inside and 17 outside rush plays.
Both show only 6 inside left/right plays
Both show only 4 outside rush left/right plays.

HB Rush Calls
Rushes 38 TDs 4
Yards 303 Avg 7.97
First Downs 17 TFL 3

Inside Rushes
29%
0%

Rush Inside Left - 6 Total
Rush Inside Right - 0 Total
Inside Rush 21 TDs 2
Yards 78.5 Avg 3.74
First Downs 6 TFL 0
Inside Rushes Left
Inside Rush 6 TDs 1
Yards 22 Avg 3.67
First Downs 1 TFL 0
Inside Rushes Right
Inside Rush 0 TDs 0
Yards 0 Avg 0
First Downs 0 TFL 0

Outside Rushes
0%
24%

Rush Outside Left - 0 Total
Rush Outside Right - 4 Total
Outside Rush 17 TDs 2
Yards 224.5 Avg 13.21
First Downs 11 TFL 3
Outside Rushes Left
Outside Rush 0 TDs 0

Yards 0 Avg 0
First Downs 0 TFL 0
Outside Rushes Right
Outside Rush 4 TDs 0

Yards 15 Avg 3.75
First Downs 1 TFL 2
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 28, 2010 12:12:52 (Duplicate)
Edited by im4ut999 on Sep 27, 2010 11:28:44
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
I think i see what you're going for (should have summarized the bug someplace clearly)

In the box score it shows 40 runs for boston. I count 39 HB runs, 1 FB run, 0 QB runs. In the scout it shows 38 HB runs, 1 FB run, 0 QB runs.

For LUX It shows 36 runs in the box score. 34 in the Scout.

I think i found where the discrepancy might be. Iron man from Boston had 1 fumble. Juke Mcfly from Lux had 2 fumbles. It would appear that the scout does not record fumbles as runs when the scout goes through the data since the person running the ball does not retain control through the end of the play.

Don't know if it's a bug but that seems to be the likely reason for the difference between the scout and the box score data.
Edited by alindyl on Sep 27, 2010 11:19:31
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
I think i see what you're going for (should have summarized the bug someplace clearly)

In the box score it shows 40 runs for boston. I count 39 HB runs, 1 FB run, 0 QB runs. In the scout it shows 38 HB runs, 1 FB run, 0 QB runs.

For LUX It shows 36 runs in the box score. 34 in the Scout.

I think i found where the discrepancy might be. Iron man from Boston had 1 fumble. Juke Mcfly from Lux had 2 fumbles. It would appear that the scout does not record fumbles as runs when the scout goes through the data since the person running the ball does not retain control through the end of the play.

Don't know if it's a bug but that seems to be the likely reason for the difference between the scout and the box score data.


No, it's not off by just a couple....

In the glb scout tool for each team, looking at the Boston offense (or LUX defense), the number of rushes are correct, but when it splits them up at the bottom into left/right runs, it is short of the total number of plays by 15 inside runs and 13 outside runs.
Inside Rush 21 TDs 2
Inside Rushes Left
Inside Rush 6 TDs 1 (left)
Inside Rushes Right
Inside Rush 0 TDs 0 (right)
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Likely part of a bigger and long standing "bug" I'd guess. The bug is that on fumbles the yards gained by the fumbling player are not recorded and just vanish, so I wouldn't be surprised to see the fumble carry not showing up as a carry either. Don't see why it should if yards disappear. Anyway, since the Scout runs off the DB records and it's not recorded by player/boxscore you get your discrepancy since the actual run play itself is recorded somewhere.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
No, it's not off by just a couple....

In the glb scout tool for each team, looking at the Boston offense (or LUX defense), the number of rushes are correct, but when it splits them up at the bottom into left/right runs, it is short of the total number of plays by 15 inside runs and 13 outside runs.
Inside Rush 21 TDs 2
Inside Rushes Left
Inside Rush 6 TDs 1 (left)
Inside Rushes Right
Inside Rush 0 TDs 0 (right)


I get your point now. It seems to have completely left out all of your HB Direct Snap and HB Pitch Right plays from the info at the bottom. It accounts for the yardage and plays in the main Inside/outside info but skips most of the plays when it breaks down by direction.

For example you had 3 outside handoff and 1 HB sweep, which is the 4 outside plays and then 5 slam weak and 1 HB Dive for the 6 inside plays. But the 15 Direct snap and 13 Pitch Right were ignored from the break down by direction.

Not sure if it's a bug but perhaps there's some data corruption going on with it. I definitely see the same issue you are though so it's not a local issue.
Edited by alindyl on Sep 27, 2010 11:35:43
Edited by alindyl on Sep 27, 2010 11:35:10
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Ok, there is currently a filed bug on the scouting tool. I'm going to request this link be added in and close this as a duplicate. Hopefully the whole thing gets a look.

Closed as duplicate
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.